A Collection of Forum Discussions

http://forums.obsidi...ription-system/

- "The main character being consistent, like the Nameless One in Planescape: Torment"

- "Colors, Mini-Portraits, Italics, Bolds, Underlines"

http://forums.obsidi...cting-dialogue/

- "Appearance, Charm, Manipulation, Attire, Sex Appeal etc. etc. effecting Dialogue"

http://forums.obsidi...s-vs-alignment/

- "Alignment, Values, Fame"

http://forums.obsidi...e-npcreactions/

- "Believable NPC Reactions, Reputation, Fame"

http://forums.obsidi...hanic-you-want/

- "Dialogue Mechanic Thoughts"

http://forums.obsidi...ns-from-my-pov/

- "Difficulty in Dialogue Options, from OP's POV"

http://forums.obsidi...-a-little-evil/

- "On being evil"

-------------

HEALTH/MANA/STATISTICS/LEVELS

http://forums.obsidi...echanics-sucks/

- "Long-term Damage, Poison, Curses, Injuries, Crippling"

http://forums.obsidi...er-suggestions/

- "Fatigue/Health/Stamina Thoughts"

http://forums.obsidi...ith-your-level/

- "Experience Thoughts"

http://forums.obsidi...fficiency-idea/

- "More Experience Thoughts"

http://forums.obsidi...-level-up-rate/

- "Level up rate/How fast do you level up?"

http://forums.obsidi...9950-level-cap/

- "A Max Level that you can't transcend"

http://forums.obsidi...telligence-etc/

- "Stats Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...bject-of-stats/

- "Thoughts on Stats"

-------------

CHARACTER CREATION

http://forums.obsidi...acter-building/

- "Character building with feats/perks/stats or ability points"

http://forums.obsidi...-gain-in-power/

- "Your character grows graphically, visually changing as you level up and get new equipment"

http://forums.obsidi...acter-creation/

- "Character Creation"

These 3 polls differ

http://forums.obsidi...implementation/

- "Character Creation Poll"

- "More Character Creation Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...-circumstances/

- "Yet another Character Creation Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...er-doll-thread/

- "Character Appearance Creation"

http://forums.obsidi...ke-them-deeper/

- "Character Creation Rant"

-------------

COMBAT/TACTICS

- "Tactical formations"

http://forums.obsidi...3-taking-cover/

- "'X-COM: Enemy Unknown' inspirational and how it could be implemented into P:E"

http://forums.obsidi...ces-and-styles/

- "Stances and Fighting Styles/Art"

http://forums.obsidi...ows-and-arrows/

- "What is the power of bows and arrows versus guns?"

http://forums.obsidi...s-and-bayonets/

- "Firearms with a slow rate of fire"

http://forums.obsidi...-muskets-in-pe/

- "Magical Muskets"

http://forums.obsidi...ch-backer-goal/

- "Real time pause" (Osvir's Note: Discussion about a CARD GAME)

http://forums.obsidi...ncrease-damage/

- "Accuracy as a Damage multiplier"

http://forums.obsidi...-friendly-fire/

- "Friendly fire"

http://forums.obsidi...-filler-combat/

- "No filler combat please"

http://forums.obsidi...ranged-weapons/

- "Firing Guns from prone?"

http://forums.obsidi...ear-and-shield/

- "Spear and shield combinations"

http://forums.obsidi...d-cooldowns-20/

- "Ability Cooldowns/Magic/Combat/Techniques/Power"

http://forums.obsidi...-you-have-time/

- "Combat Tactics"

http://forums.obsidi...bat-interfaces/

- "Dragon Age Tactics"

http://forums.obsidi...apon-functions/

- "Off-hand Tactics?"

http://forums.obsidi...-type-of-games/

- "Melee Combat"

http://forums.obsidi...l-play-through/

- "Non-Lethal Tactics"

http://forums.obsidi...-pe-design-doc/

- "Grappling Tactics" (Osvir's Note: Grappling animations are not going to be part of the game, which in my opinion doesn't exclude "grappling" abilities)

http://forums.obsidi...tional-effects/

- "Critical Hits/Misses and Additional Effect Poll"

-------------

MAGIC

http://forums.obsidi...fs-vs-passives/

- "Buff's and ways to handle them"

http://forums.obsidi...-kind-of-magic/

- "Different ways to handle Magic, Rune Magic, Battle Magic and other tidbits"

http://forums.obsidi...0996-abc-magic/

- "Different ways to handle Magic, the Spellbook prior to the Grimoire"

http://forums.obsidi...lness-of-mages/

- "Mages in Baldur's Gate deadweight when run out of spells, standing in a corner"

http://forums.obsidi...ability-system/

- "Low level spells cast in abundancy, but the more you cast the weaker they get" (Osvir's Note: A Magic Missile could get weaker as you cast it in succession many times?)

http://forums.obsidi...asting-effects/

- "Meaningful Effects, Potency & Resistance, Spell Protections & Counterspells"

http://forums.obsidi...c-system-ideas/

- "More Magic ideas"

http://forums.obsidi...dundant-spells/

- "Spell preparation"

http://forums.obsidi...casting-system/

- "Spell Usage/Locking out"

http://forums.obsidi...ing-magic-rare/

- "Healing magic is rare"

http://forums.obsidi...imited-casting/

- "Magic: Limited Casting? Poll"

-------------

CULTURE

http://forums.obsidi...fect-the-world/

- "A natural feel to faith"

http://forums.obsidi...currency-in-pe/

- "POLL: Thoughts on Currency" (Osvir's Note: Coins in the Culture because some discussion on "Cultural Currency")

- "Thoughts on Currency"

http://forums.obsidi...chter-creation/

- "Culture at Character Creation"

http://forums.obsidi...conomy-in-crpg/

- "Economy, Merchants, Bartering"

http://forums.obsidi...ks-and-scrolls/

- "On Books and Scrolls, Hints and Mysteries revealed in Books"

http://forums.obsidi...omancyshamanic/

- "Factions Poll"

- "Necromancy and thoughts, Obsidian thoughts"

-------------

TRAVELING/CAMPING/EXPLORING

http://forums.obsidi...ddling-with-it/

- "Exploring the world"

http://forums.obsidi...ew-rest-button/

- "Camping/Resting in the world"

http://forums.obsidi...sting-mechanic/

- "Thoughts on how Baldur's Gate handles Resting"

http://forums.obsidi...098-fog-of-war/

- "Fog of war"

http://forums.obsidi...le-area-please/

- "Fear of Fog of War"

http://forums.obsidi...y-engine-games/

- "Fog of War and Pathfinding"

http://forums.obsidi...-a-rest-button/

- "Camping out"

http://forums.obsidi...stivals-clocks/

- "Time, World Calendar, Seasons"

http://forums.obsidi...smart-monsters/

- "Random Encounters"

http://forums.obsidi...95-pack-a-mule/

- Osvir's Note: Can't go far without a trusty pack mule!

http://forums.obsidi...257-journalism/

- "How to 'journal' your adventures?"

http://forums.obsidi...on-and-effects/

- "Environmental Effects; Destructibles~ Burning down houses etc. etc."

http://forums.obsidi...tion-linearity/

- "IWD or BG exploration thoughts/linearity"

http://forums.obsidi...-endless-paths/

- "The Endless Paths (Mega-Dungeon)"

-------------

GEAR/EQUIPMENT/CRAFTING

http://forums.obsidi...ms-in-pe-world/

- "Epic items"

http://forums.obsidi...ns-and-scrolls/

- "Potions and scrolls rare, Rogue's can use some magical scrolls if applicable"

http://forums.obsidi...-combat-skills/

- "Speech skills, out of combat roles, thieving, sneaking, take downs, trading etc. etc."

http://forums.obsidi...60040-crafting/

- "A collection of loot used to craft with"

http://forums.obsidi...rafting-system/

- "Arcanum inspiration"

http://forums.obsidi...ng-enchantment/

- "Crafting and Enchantments"

http://forums.obsidi...ords-and-rings/

- "More Items apart from the regular 'Swords n Rings'"

http://forums.obsidi...ists-confirmed/

- "Questions on semi-random loot"

http://forums.obsidi...chemy-crafting/

- "A good loot Poll"

- "Alchemy Thoughts"

http://forums.obsidi...ck-scalability/

- "Enchanting items"

http://forums.obsidi...s-limited-ammo/

- "Limited Ammo; Limited Quivers, Bullets, Black Powder etc. etc."

http://forums.obsidi...-more-than-one/

- "More Rings than standard"

-------------

AI/ENEMIES

http://forums.obsidi...ake-difficulty/

- "A convincing and competent AI is a challenge" - soulmata

http://forums.obsidi...-arpg-controls/

- "Action oriented Control options, QWER"

http://forums.obsidi...at-that-i-like/

- "Poll: What kind of computer Roleplaying combat do you like?"

http://forums.obsidi...ggro-mechanics/

- "Related to AI management" (Osvir's Note: Mistaken for "WoW" mechanics)

http://forums.obsidi...en-games-cheat/

- "Spawning Guards, AI Discussion"

http://forums.obsidi...u-like-to-face/

- "Many enemies, hordes, few memorable enemies?"

http://forums.obsidi...-enemy-parties/

- "Post Mid-Game Difficulty"

-------------

GAME OPTIONS

http://forums.obsidi...-and-reloading/

- "On Save Scumming"

http://forums.obsidi...ch-of-a-hassle/

- "More Save Scumming"

http://forums.obsidi...-mode-features/

- "Expert Mode Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...e-mode-options/

- "Hardcore Mode"

http://forums.obsidi...ale-encounters/

- "Hardcore Gaming, Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...gets-some-love/

- "Cut-scenes, camera love, zooming in and out. Camera control" (Osvir's Note: Camera control in an isometric way)

http://forums.obsidi...le-resolutions/

- "More camera love, Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...246-combat-log/

- "Feedback on 'dice rolls' and 'saving throws' and similar" (Osvir's Note: Think IE Game Options on "Feedback")

-------------

MISC

http://forums.obsidi...always-ask-why/

- "Always ask why"

http://forums.obsidi...n-add-rule-set/

- Osvir's Note: Based on AD&D? No. Inspired by AD&D? Yes.

http://forums.obsidi...eternity-world/

- "Pen and Paper Inspiration"

http://forums.obsidi...ale-encounters/

- "Level Scaling" (Osvir's Note: I recall some really interesting posts)

http://forums.obsidi...scaling-rumors/

- "Level scaling rumors"

http://forums.obsidi...ic/61007-co-op/

- Osvir's Note: No Co-Op/Multiplayer will be in P:E

http://forums.obsidi...on-age-origins/

- "Lessons to be learned from Dragon Age: Origins?"

http://forums.obsidi...c-by-orchestra/

- "Voice over suggestion, real live music~"

http://forums.obsidi...world-building/

- "Arcanum Inspiration"

http://forums.obsidi...102-frame-rate/

- "Unity Engine and Frame Rate"

http://forums.obsidi...n-based-combat/

- "Turn based versus Real Time Discussion"

http://forums.obsidi...ol-down-period/

- "What is the meaning of cooldowns?"

http://forums.obsidi...te-this-thread/

- Osvir's Note: Not really a helpful thread for us, but for the Moderators

http://forums.obsidi...pic/61181-hugs/

- "Hugs are very important!" (Osvir's Note: Hugs! :D)

Edited November 5, 2012 by LadyCrimson
Title change by request

BetrayTheWorld · November 5, 2012

I am jealous of the amount of free time you must have. Good job.

Sacred_Path · November 5, 2012

holy **** I just saw the rats thread for the first time

Hormalakh · November 5, 2012

Yeah....just wanted to say thanks. I really would wish people would search first for a topic thread that might fit before starting another one.

Osvir · November 5, 2012

I am jealous of the amount of free time you must have. Good job.

Yeah....just wanted to say thanks. I really would wish people would search first for a topic thread that might fit before starting another one.

No problem bros just want to help out.

mcmanusaur · November 5, 2012

Dayyyyyyyyum.

Sacred_Path · November 5, 2012

I just tried to find the threads where there's direct dev feedback, but only got as far as the "paladins & bards" thread. I'm too tired for this ****.

Osvir · November 5, 2012

Yeah I did the rest of the pages too, went faster this time o:)

I just tried to find the threads where there's direct dev feedback, but only got as far as the "paladins & bards" thread. I'm too tired for this ****.

Eh, check the "Known Informations" thread or the Kickstarter Page for updates. I did this list objectively to collect everything as well as possible in "Tiers" of what we are discussing for ease of use for everyone. But you are right still, dev feedback is always nice:

If anyone reads through any of these threads and finds dev feedback, could you perhaps post it here in this thread?

So I constructed a method that worked very well for me, and it went really fast.

Some few are duplicates (3-5 duplicates at max?) from my previous post (Tabs are king).

http://forums.obsidi...ty-or-quantity/

- "Quality or Quantity? Poll"

BEARD TECHNOLOGY

http://forums.obsidi...cter-portraits/

- "Beard technology"

---------

CLASSES

http://forums.obsidi...losopher-class/

- "Natural Philosopher Class"

http://forums.obsidi...8-ranger-class/

- "Ranger Class

http://forums.obsidi...the-monk-class/

- "Monk Class"

http://forums.obsidi...26-druid-class/

- "Druid Class"

http://forums.obsidi...for-repetition/

- "A new type of Monk"

http://forums.obsidi...ncountersareas/

- "Class restricted encounters/quests/areas"

http://forums.obsidi...merchant-class/

- "Merchant Class"

http://forums.obsidi...ould-be-writer/

- "Writer Class"

http://forums.obsidi...role-of-rogues/

- "Rogue Class"

---------

HEALTH/STATS/LEVELUP/ExPERIENCE

http://forums.obsidi...-during-combat/

- "On the Stamina and Health"

http://forums.obsidi...ry-perspective/

- "Stamina and Health"

http://forums.obsidi...ent-attributes/

- "Should HP and Stamina be determined by different attributes? Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...1-reverse-mana/

- "Mana Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...e-scaling-poll/

- "How do you feel about level scaling? Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...r-no-level-cap/

- "Cap, no cap? Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...y-to-the-enemy/

- "Stamina/Health Mechnism Discussion"

http://forums.obsidi...itality-please/

- "Changing the name of Stamina to Vitality? Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...nt-max-stamina/

- "Health limiting current max Stamina?"

http://forums.obsidi...estcamp-system/

- "Arcanum and Stamina"

http://forums.obsidi...acter-building/

- "Should rleplaying, story, companions, choices, affect your character building?"

http://forums.obsidi...c/62046-respec/

- "Re-specialization of stats"

http://forums.obsidi...ic-or-medicine/

- "Issues with no healing magic or medicine" (Osvir's Note: I would like to see it like this; "Health = Mortality, Stamina = Health" mechanically)

http://forums.obsidi...-or-increasing/

- "Attributes: Fixed or increasing?"

http://forums.obsidi...c/62034-curses/

- "Curses!"

http://forums.obsidi...-instant-death/

- "Instand Death"

http://forums.obsidi...5-talent-trees/

- "Talent trees"

http://forums.obsidi...ing-objectives/

- "Experience Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...atistics-in-pe/

- "Character Traits and Statistics"

http://forums.obsidi...-gain-in-power/

- "Visually see you characters gain in power"

http://forums.obsidi...joy-of-rebirth/

- "Resurrection from death"

---------

ENEMY/AI/NPC'S (Non-Playable Character)

http://forums.obsidi...-never-leaving/

- "Guards appearing hostile and never leaving"

http://forums.obsidi...und-characters/

- "Walking background character? Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...ique-abilities/

- "Enemies with unique abilities"

http://forums.obsidi...8-boss-battles/

- "Boss Battles"

http://forums.obsidi...predictability/

- "Maintaining risk and unpredictability"

http://forums.obsidi...-enemy-respawn/

- "Enemy Respawn Poll"

---------

FACTIONS/CULTURE

http://forums.obsidi...-transhumanism/

- "Necromancy"

http://forums.obsidi...r-pistol-build/

- "Pistols & Pirates"

http://forums.obsidi...currency-value/

- "currency Value"

http://forums.obsidi...omancyshamanic/

- "Necromancy"

---------

LORE/STORY/QUESTS

http://forums.obsidi...ment-lucky-you/

- "Being a Deity's plaything for a while"

http://forums.obsidi...8-story-wanted/

- "Story wanted! Plot, Scenes, Choices, Characters"

http://forums.obsidi...eatable-quests/

- "Repeatable Quests? Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...-randomization/

- "Random quests"

http://forums.obsidi...1874-whodoneit/

- "Whodoneit? Sherlock Holmes Quest"

http://forums.obsidi...-for-each-item/

- "Descriptive items and books"

http://forums.obsidi...61916-scribing/

- "Scribing/Journal/Quest handling"

http://forums.obsidi...urnal-sketches/

- "Journal and Art"

http://forums.obsidi...ifferent-story/

- "Main plot varying depending on difficulty Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...uest-line-ends/

- "Will there be an Open Ending, roam around after beating main quest"

http://forums.obsidi...-quest-markers/

- "No more 'go here' quest markers"

http://forums.obsidi...ain-characters/

- "Quests"

http://forums.obsidi...ic/62158-deeds/

- "Deeds"

http://forums.obsidi...257-journalism/

- "Journal"

---------

OTHER GAMES

http://forums.obsidi...i-dragon-age-2/

- "Dragon Age 2 pointers"

http://forums.obsidi...d-from-arcanum/

- "Good and Bad Arcanum Poll"

---------

LOOT/GEAR/INVENTORY

http://forums.obsidi...ollecting-loot/

- "More loot"

http://forums.obsidi...-the-inventory/

- "Thoughts on Inventory"

http://forums.obsidi...nventory-items/

- "Talking Junk on Inventory"

http://forums.obsidi...-and-heres-why/

- "Health potions begone"

http://forums.obsidi...ting-equipment/

- "Starting Equipment Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...vs-flexibility/

- "Inventory: Strategy versus Flexibility"

http://forums.obsidi...estion-of-loot/

- "Loot Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...ct-in-the-game/

- "Food and food quality?"

http://forums.obsidi...wn-items-in-pe/

- "Identifying unknown items in PE"

http://forums.obsidi...rsus-artifacts/

- "Lore versus Artifacts Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...asts-of-burden/

- "Pack Animal Munchy Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...ventory-system/

- "Proposed Inventory System"

----------

ARMOR

http://forums.obsidi...armor-mechanic/

- "Armor on Armor on Armor"

- "Armor Rant"

http://forums.obsidi...anics-thoughts/

- "Armor mechanic thoughts" (Osvir's Note: Good read)

http://forums.obsidi...32-armor-class/

- "Armor class: How do you want to reduce armor? Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...armour-musings/

- "Armor thoughs"

http://forums.obsidi...anics-thoughts/

- "Armor thoughts [Merged] might be in another link too"

http://forums.obsidi...r-and-clothing/

- "Armor inventory management"

http://forums.obsidi...-leather-armor/

- "Leather 'Armor'"

http://forums.obsidi...-wearing-armor/

- "Wizards wearing armor Poll"

---------

WEAPONS

http://forums.obsidi...eathed-weapons/

- "Sheathed Weapons, not wielding weapons in towns Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...apon-mechanics/

- "Weapon Mechanics, 'Reach', 'Critical hits', 'Smaller and generally obvious things'" (Osvir's Note: Is this a good place to discuss if unreachable enemies will be present? (Standing in a tower only reachable by long range weapons etc .etc.)

http://forums.obsidi...itical-failure/

- "Critical Hits based on a dice roll?"

http://forums.obsidi...apon-artifacts/

- "Non-Weapon Artifacts" (Osvir's Note: Treasure! :D)

http://forums.obsidi...s-attack-speed/

- "Two-Handed Weapons and Attack Speed"

http://forums.obsidi...ts-on-firearms/

- "Thoughts on Firearms"

http://forums.obsidi...-weapons-topic/

- "Another weapons topic Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...on-familiarity/

- "Weapons Familiarity"

http://forums.obsidi...-handed-swords/

- "More Two-Handed Weapons"

http://forums.obsidi...pic/61927-ammo/

- "Different types of ammo? Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...apons-mechanic/

- "More weapons"

http://forums.obsidi...-combat-skills/

- "Arsenal in P:E Poll"

---------

SKILLS

- "Randomness and non-combat skills"

http://forums.obsidi...g-and-thievery/

- "Stealth, backstabbing and thievery"

http://forums.obsidi...-combat-skills/

- "Favorite non-combat skills"

http://forums.obsidi...om-prior-games/

- "Crafting mechanics and lessons from prior games?"

http://forums.obsidi...-better-choice/

- "On [speech] skills and why it is a better choice"

http://forums.obsidi...ethal-takedown/

- "Pacifism & Nonlethal takedown"

---------

DIALOGUE/FAME/APPEARANCE

- "Dialogue Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...4-playing-evil/

- "On being evil"

http://forums.obsidi...ersations-ever/

- "No realtime dialogues or conversations"

http://forums.obsidi...1822-alignment/

- "Thoughts on alignment"

http://forums.obsidi...61896-emotions/

- "Emotions"

http://forums.obsidi...-to-being-good/

- "A price to being too* good?" (Osvir's Note: Editted)

http://forums.obsidi...log-combat-log/

- "On Dialogue and Combat Log" (Osvir's Note: Could've been Game Options too)

http://forums.obsidi...-and-atributes/

- "Dialogue, Skills and Attributes"

http://forums.obsidi...king-n-talking/

- "Walking and talking"

http://forums.obsidi...his-appearance/

- "NPC's reacting to PC's differently depending on appearance"

http://forums.obsidi...ialogue-option/

- "Written answers to riddles"

http://forums.obsidi...hoices-in-rpgs/

- "A plea for choices"

http://forums.obsidi...lling-all-npcs/

- "Being evil Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...mpact-on-world/

- "Influence/Opinion/Relationship Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...e-be-presented/

- "Presenting the PE Dialogue? Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...62079-dialogue/

- "Dialogue Options and Character Customization"

- "Dialogue Poll"

---------

COMBAT TACTICS/MECHANICS

http://forums.obsidi...or-customising/

- "More party formations"

http://forums.obsidi...hanics-be-like/

- "Discussion on different combat mechanics from different games"

http://forums.obsidi...uld-work-in-pe/

- "Combat resources"

http://forums.obsidi...f-pe-mechanics/

- "Mathematical comprehensibility of P:E Mechanics Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...-up-the-player/

- "Tension that wakes up the Player"

http://forums.obsidi...ces-and-styles/

- "Combat stances"

http://forums.obsidi...akes-micro-fun/

- "Micro-Management, clicking and casting skill shots" (Osvir's Note: Kind of like copy+pasting this list phew, I'm a micro-adept, high APM)

---------

COMPANIONS/HOUSING

http://forums.obsidi...-enhanced-pets/

- "Enhanced Pets"

http://forums.obsidi...s-of-the-party/

- "Good 'Companions in the party' Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...onghold-prison/

- "Stronghold Prison" (Osvir's Note: Maybe kind of a jailoring management?)

http://forums.obsidi...mpanions-in-pe/

- "Good 'When the will companions join the party?' Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...-get-xp-or-not/

- "Should your inactive Companions get experience or not? Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...on-differences/

- "Inter personal party quarrels and relationships"

http://forums.obsidi...tactics-system/

- "Party Tactics System; Scripts"

http://forums.obsidi...f-the-treasure/

- "Companions demanding stuff from us Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...ing-experience/

- "Companions not in party gaining experience"

http://forums.obsidi...in-strongholds/

- "Strongholds"

http://forums.obsidi...bat-challenges/

- "Companions contributing to non combat challenges"

http://forums.obsidi...ts-in-the-game/

- "In-game Pet"

http://forums.obsidi...y-spokesperson/

- "Can a companion be the Leader?" (Osvir's Note: In Baldur's Gate I made a fodder character for the Main Story and made a follower that was "my" character following the Bhaalspawn, which could work)

http://forums.obsidi...ty-member-poll/

- "Forced party members? Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...like-your-npcs/

- "How independant do you want your Companions? Poll"

---------

MAGIC

http://forums.obsidi...ool-down-based/

- "On Magic Use and Magic Casting (Not cooldown based)"

http://forums.obsidi...e-magic-system/

- "Thoughts on Mana and the Soul"

http://forums.obsidi...storing-spells/

- "On Rest and Restoring spells"

http://forums.obsidi...evelopment-etc/

- "Magic system, character development"

http://forums.obsidi...-plug-and-play/

- "Magical Gear"

http://forums.obsidi...uld-magic-miss/

- "Miscasting magic, missing with spells?" (Osvir's Note: Difficult to implement perhaps but could AI react and dodge spells?)

http://forums.obsidi...l-casting-time/

- "Spell Casting Time" (Osvir's Note: Perhaps some can be instantanous and some take time/ritualistic?"

http://forums.obsidi...tion-and-ideas/

- "Thoughts on Grimoires function, speculations and ideas"

http://forums.obsidi...ell-assortment/

- "Spell Assortment Poll"

---------

THE WORLD/TRAVELING/EXPLORING

http://forums.obsidi...oy-environment/

- "Destroying environment? Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...ding-mechanics/

- "World-Building Mechanics"

http://forums.obsidi...xploring-areas/

- "Random Generated/Explorable Areas"

http://forums.obsidi...aynight-system/

- "Day/Night"

http://forums.obsidi...ng-and-running/

- "Walking and running?"

http://forums.obsidi...dom-encounters/

- "Random encounters"

http://forums.obsidi...to-protagonist/

- "How does the World respond to the Hero? Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...ling-curiosity/

- "Curiosity on traveling and ideas"

http://forums.obsidi...resting-system/

- "Resting system Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...term-resources/

- "Multiple points, money, fame, spell memorization, stamina, logistics, time, reactions etc"

http://forums.obsidi...ties-in-cities/

- "Parties in Cities?"

http://forums.obsidi...rrative-design/

- "2 Cities, Mega Dungeon, Narrative Design. How big is P:E?"

http://forums.obsidi...ld-do-you-want/

- "How big will the world be? Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...1942-solo-play/

- "About Solo Play"

http://forums.obsidi...ferent-endings/

- "Different endings"

http://forums.obsidi...t-replay-value/

- "About Replay value"

---------

RACES

http://forums.obsidi...c-intro-quests/

- "Races and Quests"

http://forums.obsidi...61448-subraces/

- "Sub-races"

http://forums.obsidi...ike-and-orlans/

- "Druids, Races, Godlike and Orlans" (Osvir's Note: A Druid Race perhaps? )

http://forums.obsidi...1-about-humans/

- "Humans Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...rcs-discussion/

- "Orcs Poll" (Osvir's Note: Could the orc idealogy be applied to another race?)

---------

GAME OPTIONS

http://forums.obsidi...mbat-solutions/

- "HoF Mode (Heart of Fury?)"

http://forums.obsidi...n-based-combat/

- "Thoughts on Turn Based Combat"

http://forums.obsidi...tart-locations/

- "Different Start Locations" (Different Origins depending on our culture perhaps?)

http://forums.obsidi...o-pause-system/

- "Comprehensive auto-pause"

http://forums.obsidi...h-a-controller/

- "Playing PE with a controller/joystick?"

http://forums.obsidi.../61967-hotkeys/

- "Hotkeys"

http://forums.obsidi...ficulty-option/

- "Game speed. Fast. Faster. Fastest?"

http://forums.obsidi...61811-new-game/

- "New Game+" (Osvir's Note: I see this as "Extra Content" on a second playthrough)

---------

MISC

http://forums.obsidi...s-gate-or-nwn2/

- "Portraits like Baldur's Gate or NWN? Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...e-29-mechanics/

- "Update 29: Mechanics"

http://forums.obsidi...was-turn-based/

- "If Project Eternity was Turn-Based? Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...y-the-ie-games/

- "How do/did you play the IE Games? Poll"

---------

PHILOSOPHY

http://forums.obsidi...mportant-in-pe/

- "Arachnophobia (No Spiders)"

http://forums.obsidi...nce-inequality/

- "Experience Inequality"

http://forums.obsidi...opic/61977-omg/

- "OMG"

http://forums.obsidi...e-in-this-game/

- "Thought on what 'must be in a game'"

http://forums.obsidi...s-a-game-great/

- "What makes a game great?"

http://forums.obsidi...gaming-problem/

- "The Powergaming Problem"

http://forums.obsidi...-to-non-combat/

- "On Powergaming and non-combat"

http://forums.obsidi...rom-abusing-it/

- "On Self-Discipline"

Edited November 5, 2012 by LadyCrimson
added spoiler tags for length

Osvir · November 5, 2012

Could the title be changed to something more appropriate if possible? (Collection of Forum Discussions) or something

LadyCrimson · November 5, 2012

Could the title be changed to something more appropriate if possible? (Collection of Forum Discussions) or something

Done. I added spoiler tags for length reasons, as well. If you don't know how to use them, it's just:

[ spoiler ] .... [ /spoiler ] (no spaces)

Osvir · November 5, 2012

Yes I saw thank you very much that's awesome :D

EDIT: And I'll try to think of that one (I usually use the icons instead of writing BBCode)

Edited November 6, 2012 by Osvir

Sacred_Path · November 6, 2012

For what it's worth, the threads in the OP with dev feedback are:

under GAME OPTIONS, called Hardcore Gaming, Poll on page 3

under MISC, called Osvir's Note: Based on AD&D? on page 1

Osvir · November 6, 2012

For what it's worth, the threads in the OP with dev feedback are:

under GAME OPTIONS, called Hardcore Gaming, Poll on page 3

under MISC, called Osvir's Note: Based on AD&D? on page 1

I know there should be more, but might be in General Discussion. Thank you :D I also did this:

This also means I accidentally posted the wrong link (Because "Hardcore Gaming" gets you to "Level Scaling"), and it's not a Poll either:

http://forums.obsidi...rs/page__st__40

I don't know where this topic came from, but I don't expect to use level scaling much, if at all, in PE.

http://forums.obsidi...n-add-rule-set/

We also want to have a deep class system with a lot of options.

And again, thank you

EDIT: Here's the right link for the Hardcore Gaming Poll under GAME OPTIONS

Edited November 6, 2012 by Osvir

Hormalakh · November 6, 2012

It's a shame we can't edit posts after a while. It would have been nice to get this pinned. So much easier to navigate.

BetrayTheWorld · November 6, 2012

Could always copy and paste this into a new thread to be pinned with a request not to post in the thread unless you're adding new information to it. Mods might even be able to lock it so that it can't be posted in except by them, in which case updates could be PMed to the mod for insertion into the pinned thread.

Osvir · November 6, 2012

It's a shame we can't edit posts after a while. It would have been nice to get this pinned. So much easier to navigate.

It's fine without the edit (but I do agree, been looking at this list and I kind of want to maintain/update it, make it prettier and even easier and effective, correct faults, better descriptions underneath. Name of OP next to it).

I'll make new posts here when there's enough new topics (10~ or so?) and it should be easier to manage and easier to see what is what in those posts (Instead of 100 links or so in one post ).

Thank you, makes me glad to hear that it works as intended

EDIT:

Could always copy and paste this into a new thread to be pinned with a request not to post in the thread unless you're adding new information to it. Mods might even be able to lock it so that it can't be posted in except by them, in which case updates could be PMed to the mod for insertion into the pinned thread.

That is one way to do it.

Personally I don't want to put that sort of "responsibility" on the Moderators nor do I think they want that kind of responsibility, I might be wrong ofc (No ill intended but I'm seeing the "Known Informations" thread in the corner of my eye: "Edited by Tale, 02 October 2012 - 04:53 PM." and the latest post by Zu Long: "Posted 14 October 2012 - 10:35 PM").

Edited November 6, 2012 by Osvir

Hormalakh · November 6, 2012

Yeah honestly, the discussions here flow so fast that it really becomes a full time job just to keep things organized and readable. The moderators already have a full time job moderating over the boards. It's a weird dilemma - too much information and ideas flowing at once.

I wonder how many of these threads the devs actually get a chance to read? You'd probably need 2-3 people reading the boards full time just to keep up with the discussions and not all of the posts (like this one here) really add much to the discussions of mechanics and gameplay. It's a tough job and I'm glad Osvir's doing it

Osvir · November 6, 2012

You (All of you) could definitively use this thread to categorize your own threads and post them in here (if you have more than one).

(I use Font-Size 24, Golden Rod color and Bold (CTRL+B) for Poll). A cool idea, a cool quote etc. etc.

For most ease-of-use try to:

* Minimal discussion

* Maximal information/knowledge/wisdom

* EDIT: Objectiveness

Edited November 6, 2012 by Osvir

Sacred_Path · November 6, 2012

There are no dev comments in the threads in Osvir's second post.

JFSOCC · November 6, 2012

The only dev comments I've seen is in threads which concerned them directly. I think it is wise for the devs not to get bogged down in the discussion. As tempting as it may be, they might influence the discussion. And we punish them a little for doing it. In another thread Josh posited an example of lockpicks and we fell on that like a hungry pack of wolves.

It's cool to get to discuss things with the devs, the highlight of my day if one of them responds to something I say. But that engagement seems pretty intense on their side, I think. All in all I think it's cool they respond when they do, but I can certainly understand the reasons for not doing so.

Sacred_Path · November 6, 2012

I'm not faulting them for it, only pointing it out for those interested (like me), because obviously their posts attract the most interest.

Osvir · November 7, 2012

Low on Page 1; Bump.

New Threads:

Dialogue, how about some cool mechanics for it?

http://forums.obsidian.net/topic/62167-how-about-some-cool-dialog-mechanics/

Player vs AI Challenge.

http://forums.obsidian.net/topic/62176-i-dare-you-to-beat-this-party-player-setup-versus-ai/

Osvir · November 8, 2012

Bump from Page 2, only one new:

Class Design and Combat Performance Poll

Should all classes be able to reach similar combat potential if the player chooses to do so?

Yes, my choice to play a certain class should not hinder my performance in combat
No, not all classes value combat skills the same way. Classes should be balanced considering both it's combat and non-combat value.

http://forums.obsidian.net/topic/62185-class-design-and-combat-performance/

Osvir · November 8, 2012

I've started with the old old pages of the General Discussion as well and here are some. These are about 8~9 days worth. Try not to necro anything until I've done the entire General Discussion (I'm finding some topics I had no idea about existed that I've brought up and stuff like that)

-----------

From General Discussion (Page 60-76~)

OLD TOPICS FROM SEPTEMBER 11 to 19

http://forums.obsidi...5-release-date/

- "Release Date" (Gyges, 17th Sept) (Osvir's Note: Read the OP post, IMPORTANT)

-----------

INTERVIEWS

http://forums.obsidi...nity-interview/

- "Gamebanshee" (Brother None, 14th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...me-speculation/

- "Tim Cain with Eurogamer" (Starwars, 18th Sept)

-----------

STORY SPECULATION

- "Speculation" (MrAlbum, 12th Sept) (Osvir's Note: Great read)

http://forums.obsidi...orm-ourobouros/

- "The Worm Ouroboros" (Ohverture, 12th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ords-two-herds/

- "Two Words = Two Herds" (Prosper, 11th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...this-new-world/

- "How about a short-story novel?" (Chaos Theory, 16th Sept)

-----------

GENERAL SPECULATION

http://forums.obsidi...baldurs-gate-3/

- "Baldur's Gate 3?" (projectx, 12th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...fallout-online/

- "A new fallout?" (glomecave, 12th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...tarter-project/

- "Kickstarter Spiritual successor to PS:T?" (Zorky, 13th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ame-for-skyrim/

- "New Vegas-ish game for Skyrim" (igliu, 12 Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-wheel-of-time/

- "Wheel of Time" (Darkenmal, 13 Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...923-the-wayeon/

- "The Way(Eon?!)" (Astiaks, 14th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...x-t-x-eternity/

- "Riddle stuff, Project: Eternity" (Venctin, 12th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...nuclear-device/

- "Trinity was the code name for first nuclear det." (Prosper, Sept 14)

http://forums.obsidi...-about-the-map/

- "Talk/Speculate on Map" (Sarkus, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...m-for-infinity/

- "Eternity as a synonum for Infinity?" (Skie Nightfall, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ong-soul-means/

- "Figuring out what it means to have a strong soul" (AW8, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-pst-successor/

- "PS:T Successor?" (slopesandsam, 18th Sept)

-----------

GENERAL A

http://forums.obsidi...ike-to-know-is/

- "What Dawuss wants to know is..." (DAWUSS, Sept 12, JESawyer Quote)

http://forums.obsidi...r-being-sneaky/

- "JESwayer being Sneaky" (FearMonkey, 12 Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...h-the-memories/

- "Memories" (fan, 14th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ic/59993-lingo/

- "Lingo" (WDeranged, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...opic/60000-drm/

- "DRM" (Reddie, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...74-beta-access/

- "Beta Access" (Hornet85, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...projekt-gogcom/

- "Polish Localization?" (True_Spike, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...looks-familiar/

- "About the Map" (silvercross, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-about-the-map/

- "More on the Map" (WDeranged, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...s-stretch-goal/

- "Bring in BioWare Poll" (Vatdim, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...168-about-time/

- "About time..." (Junai, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...s-and-sketches/

- "About items..." (Phekdra, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...the-game-world/

- "About introduction..." (fan, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-doesnt-repeat/

- "About Kotor2 and lessons learned" (Sylvius the Mad, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ld-like-to-see/

- "Kotor2 and lessons" (AW8, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...c/60238-threat/

- "Threat" (Leferd, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-new-game-plus/

- "New Game Plus" (Moonlight Butterfly, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-member-titles/

- "Member titles" (Entropious, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...60272-licenses/

- "License" (molarBear, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-how-this-goes/

- "Looking forward to it" (cealicu_ca, 18th Sept)

-----------

GENERAL B

http://forums.obsidi...y-free-license/

- "Eventual Royalty Free license?" (fgf, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-torment-style/

- "Planescape Torment Style" (czinczar, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi.../60313-min-max/

- "Min-Maxing" (Malchidael, 19th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...o-try-to-avoid/

- "Something to try and avoid" (Moonlight Butterfly, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...r-us-munchkins/

- "Make this game fun for the munckins" (Shevek, 19th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...iple-languages/

- "Multiple Localization" (Darustet, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-for-immersion/

- "The little things" (StupidFahk, 19th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...similar-flavor/

- "Using the IEngine or something new?" (NerdBoner, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...re-as-90s-rpgs/

- "Hardcore as 90's RPG's?" (Gibbscape_Torment, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-a-little-more/

- "The bad about the classics, lessons learned" (TomSuperpatriot, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...tarter-profile/

- "A more original symbol for P:E?" (Longknife, 18th Sept)

-----------

KICKSTARTER A

- "Obsidian with Kickstarter Profile" (C2B, 12th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...e-have-liftoff/

- "Lift-off" (Drowsy Emporer, 14th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ity-website-up/

- "Eternity Website Up" (C2B, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...pledge-rewards/

- "Pledge rewards" (Kaldurenik, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ayment-methods/

- "Alternate payment options" (domanz, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-paypal-option/

- "PayPal Option" (vrailor, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-facebook-page/

- "About Facebook" (JMoore, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-stretch-goals/

- "Why no stretch goals?" (Mloren, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...kickstarternow/

- "Need an update... NOW!" (Metabot, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-stop-pledging/

- "Don't stop pledging" (guiskj, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...s-on-our-hopes/

- "What are the boundaries..?" (Darth Trethon, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...pledge-however/

- "For the 1st time, I want to pledge..." (Yarazin, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...straight-males/

- "Get rid of Straight Males and I will pledge" (lord of flies, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-to-contribute/

- "Any way to contribute?" (Lars Westergren, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...c/59940-paypal/

- "PayPal" (Serrano, 14th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...nity-raise-10m/

- "Will it reach $10M?" (XSLIGE, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...eaking-a-sweat/

- "More $10M thoughts" (AlphaWhelp, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...c/59929-omgbbq/

- "OMGBBQ!" (alanschu, 14th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ll-the-trigger/

- "Questions before pledging" (Streamlock, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...w-tier-rewards/

- "Suggested new tier rewards" (Lars Westergren, 17th Sept)

-----------

KICKSTARTER B

http://forums.obsidi...folks-thoughts/

- "Topups Kickstarter, folks thoughts" (Azzy, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...al-with-paypal/

- "Linux Support" (rohezal, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...digital-copies/

- "Kickstarter Tier offering multiple Digital Copies" (Crabby_Bastard, 18th Sept) (Osvir's Note: Yay, 18th September... I'm on page 68 as I'm typing xD)

http://forums.obsidi...0105-new-tiers/

- "New Tiers?" (Havoc, 16th Sept) (Osvir's Note: And back to 16th )

http://forums.obsidi...-stretch-goals/

- "Stretch Goals Poll" (BasaltineBadger, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...pal-is-enabled/

- "Will you reopen $20 pledge option?" (monkofwar, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...stretch-goal-2/

- "Stretch Goal #2" (NateOwns, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-stretch-goals/

- "Stretch Goals" (13loodangel, 19th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-at-16-million/

- "Holy Toledo, $1.6M!" (septembervirgin, 19th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ed-by-obsidian/

- "Kickstarter Q&A with Obsidian" (SnideCipher, 19th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ached-congrats/

- "Stretch Goal #2 Reached" (Vatdim, 19th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-a-media-blitz/

- "We need a media blitz!" (CommissarMega, 19th Sept)

-----------

GAMEPLAY

http://forums.obsidi...ing-forward-to/

- "What I'm looking foward too..." (PeteRR, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...043-randomness/

- "Randomness" (agent12345, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi.../60077-ruleset/

- "Ruleset" (Mystwalker, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...nt-or-no-taunt/

- "Taunt or No-Taunt? Poll" (Flying dutchman, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ameplay-lenght/

- "Gameplay length? Poll" (Hellion, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-morale-system/

- "Morale System" (Troller, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...orality-system/

- "Morality" (Skyhawk02, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ld-like-to-see/

- "What I'd like to see..." (Ashram, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-off-the-bench/

- "Ideas, suggestions, off the bench" (mrverbal, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-and-epilogues/

- "Endings/Epilogues" (Badmojo, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...1-replay-value/

- "Replay Value" (Eich, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...stylecharacter/

- "Replayability" (Darkpriest, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...failure-states/

- "Failure States" (Nonek, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ture-of-quests/

- "Difficulty/Mixture of quests" (Fluid29, 18th Sept)

-----------

EXPLORATION/WORLD

http://forums.obsidi...oration-system/

- "Exploration System Poll"

http://forums.obsidi...dom-encounters/

- "Fast-Travel/Movement?" (Darkpriest, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...99-jump-around/

- "Jump Around" (Monte Carlo, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...assage-of-time/

- "Passage of time" (AutoReiv, 16th Sept) (Osvir's Note: +1 for Ergo Proxy screen name)

http://forums.obsidi...d-have-a-child/

- "Children?" (KenThomes, 17th Sept) (Osvir's Note: Don't really want to -explore- that)

http://forums.obsidi...59916-mlp-game/

- "Ponies" (ridethispony, 13th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ight-of-riches/

- "weight on Coins" (Cantousent, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-value-of-gold/

- "Value of Gold" (SanguineAngel, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...60273-factions/

- "Factions?" (Dem, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...and-encounters/

- "Travel Map/World and Encounters Poll" (Crosmando, 18th Sept)

-----------

COMBAT/NON-COMBAT

http://forums.obsidi...ombat-gameplay/

- "Out of combat.." (Delterius, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...log-and-combat/

- "Combat Log~" (Jozape, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...combat-systems/

- "Defending Turn Based Combat" (Baudolino05, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...me-have-crates/

- "Destructible Environment" (Krezack, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-there-be-guns/

- "Guns?" (Aram, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...at-and-spacing/

- "Close-Combat" (dknight99, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...n-based-combat/

- "Turn-Based?" (NoxNoctum, 14th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ing-the-battle/

- "Pacifist" (Blablachar, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...4-pacifist-run/

- "Another Pacifist" (Auxilius, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...n-turn-by-turn/

- "Turn by Turn" (Enkidu98, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ices-in-combat/

- "Non-Magic needs Interesting Choices" (Vaeliorin, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ee-of-succcess/

- "Critical Hit/Miss Poll" (septembervirgin, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...please-no-guns/

- "Please, NO GUNS!" (ZeshinX, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...mbat-mechanics/

- "Symmetrical Combat Mechanics" (Sylvius the Mad, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...6-auto-tactics/

- "Auto-Tactics" (ilhdr, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...n-v-simplicity/

- "Combat - Immersion v. Simplicity Poll" (Shevek, 19th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-combat-system/

- "Combat System"

-----------

DESIGN

http://forums.obsidi...-mature-themes/

- "Mature Themes?" (pseudonymous, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...e-game-setting/

- "Concerns regarding setting" (serinox, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...uld-be-avoided/

- "Tropes that could be avoided" (Margaretha, 14th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...of-game-system/

- "What type of game system? Poll" (Metabot, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...a-little-vague/

- "[Merged] Info was a little vague" (oldmanpaco, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...will-look-like/

- "What will the game look like?" (kinemitor, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...gn-and-setting/

- "Gamedesign, Art design, setting" (Akratus, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...velscompanions/

- "Game Scope" (SnideCipher, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-fatigue-sleep/

- "Hunger, Thirst, Fatigue, Sleep" (Nakia, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...e-no-cooldowns/

- "Please no cooldowns" (metiman, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...80-my-thoughts/

- "Thoughts on Opening/Quests/Crafting/Ending" (ramt1n, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...prefer-and-why/

- "Class/Skill Based System, Hybrid?" (Stiler, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...vs-stylisation/

- "Photorealism vs Stylisation" (slopesandsam, 18th Sept)

-----------

WANTS/THOUGHTS

http://forums.obsidi...ld-like-to-see/

- "What I'd like to see?" (Knacki99, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-am-hoping-for/

- "What I'm hoping for" (patboy12, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi.../60213-my-turn/

"My turn" (Sammael, 17th Sept)

-----------

CAMERA

http://forums.obsidi...g-to-be-locked/

- "Camera Locked?" (Chaz, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...out-the-camera/

- "Camera love" (Scribbles88, 17th Sept)

-----------

CHARACTER/PLAYER

http://forums.obsidi...tions-for-npcs/

- "Text typing answers" (drithius, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...er-interaction/

- "Character Interaction" (Eraydon, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...alogue-puzzles/

- "Dialogue Puzzles" (entrerix, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ue-text-length/

- "Adjustable Dialogue Text Length" (Micru, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...y-why-i-exsist/

- "Player Personality & Why I Exist" (CrazedWeevil, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...47-leveling-up/

- "Leveling Up" (Leferd, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...oints-of-views/

- "Villains" (Starwars, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...s-and-all-that/

- "Narration/Flashback" (the proctophantasmist, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...tified-by-npcs/

- "Character getting identified by NPC's" (kenup, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...portant-to-you/

- "Non-storyline important to you? Poll" (Intoxicated_Ant, 16th Sept)

-----------

RACES

http://forums.obsidi...antasy-setting/

- "Non-human races in fantasy"

http://forums.obsidi...tive-race-poll/

- "Races Poll" (Troller, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi.../60027-dwarves/

- "Dwarves" (Volourn, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...eternity-world/

- "Human Supremacy" (Qumi, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...1-player-races/

- "Playable Races?" (Terradonn, 19th Sept)

-----------

STRONGHOLD/CITY

http://forums.obsidi...ns-and-taverns/

- "Moar Inns/Taverns" (Infinitron, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ongholdpc-base/

- "Stronghold/PC Base Poll" (Bos_hybrid, 15th Sept)

- "Player Housing" (Klaleara, 16th Sept)

- "Player Housing" (Continuity, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-big-huge-city/

- "Player Housing" (13loodangel, 16th Sept)

- "One big huge city" (novander, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-special-place/

- "Player Housing and Influence" (ExtraLarge, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ours-and-scale/

- "Tea Parties/Player Housing" (Mamoulian War, 16th Sept)

- "House and Size" (Korron, 18th Sept)

-----------

MAGIC

http://forums.obsidi...6-magic-system/

- "Magic System" (oldmanpaco, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...edible-breadth/

- "Magic~" (drithius, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...generic-spells/

- "Plea for non-Generic Spells" (limaxophobiacq, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...caleable-magic/

- "Scaleable Magic" (level10, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...sleep-spamming/

- "Spellcasting system vs. Sleep spamming" (Aoha, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...wondering-this/

- "Many wondering about this...?" (General_Disarray, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...m-speculations/

- "Magic System speculation" (Lars Westergren, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...mature-setting/

- "Mature Magic" (1varangian, 16th Sept)

-----------

WEAPON

http://forums.obsidi...9-weapon-types/

- "Weapon types" (entreri, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...y-of-the-sword/

- "The Way of the Sword" (Bloodshard, 18th Sept) (Osvir's Note: Should be in Philosophy but I'm guessing this is about combat mechanics)

http://forums.obsidi...bg-bow-follies/

- "Let's not repeat BG Bow Follies" (PsychoBlonde, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ew-pew-pew-pew/

- "Pewpewpew" (fan, 19th Sept)

-----------

ARMOR

http://forums.obsidi...r-vs-chainmail/

- "Plate vs Chain" (lord of flies, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...with-shirts-on/

- "About wanting women dressed" (Belias, 14th Sept) (Osvir's Note: There is a challenge in getting them un-dressed, don't neglect that challenge)

http://forums.obsidi...mportant-to-me/

- "Dress-Up is important" (salty, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...oaks-and-capes/

- "Cloaks and capes" (MrGeekyGamer, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...dont-you-think/

- "Female Armor" (Troller, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...othing-control/

- "Full Clothing" (Someone, 19th Sept)

-----------

COMPANIONS

http://forums.obsidi...021-party-size/

- "Party-Size" (2ane, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...944-party-size/

- "Party-Size Poll" (oldmanpaco, 14th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...npc-companions/

- "Concerns about Super Deep Companions" (Zombra, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...r-developement/

- "Companions Development" (MReed, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...panion-choices/

- "Plea from a tactical fan" (tilly, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...rty-formations/

- "Formations" (h4mm32, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...used-in-a-game/

- "Companionship" (andreisiadi, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ons-game-scope/

- "Companions+Game scope" (floyd ryan, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ent-big-baddie/

- "On gathering Companions" (Domigorgon, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ead-companions/

- "On dead companions" (Kopi, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ounds-like-yea/

- "Character background" (Pop, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-loyalty-meter/

- "Loyalty" (dmbot, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...mpanions-great/

- "Things that make Companions great" (overlordrauz, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ics-done-right/

- "Pet Mechanics" (lankyplonker, 19th Sept) (Osvir's Note: 19th o.o there is light at the end of the tunnel!)

http://forums.obsidi...they-so-choose/

- "Companions are never forced on the player..." (DRevan, 18th Sept)

-----------

CRAFTING

http://forums.obsidi...60012-crafting/

- "Will there be crafting?" (J_BYYX, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ut-professions/

- "Professions" (HarTstaRx, 17th Sept)

-----------

MUSIC

http://forums.obsidi...ic/59932-music/

- "What kind of music?" (Quitch, 14th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ound-and-music/

- "Composer for 'Project Eternity'?" (Casey Edwards, 15th Sept)

- "Sound and Music" (Li_Lai_Fu, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...you-devs-again/

- "About musical talent from Devs" (C2B, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...then-directing/

- "Music Direction(?)" (StrangeCat, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...d-related-goal/

- "Stretch Goal: Orchestral Score"

-----------

USER INTERFACE (UI)

http://forums.obsidi...bout-menu-bars/

- "Menu bars Suggestion" (PsychoBlonde, 17th Sept)

-----------

ROMANCE

http://forums.obsidi...omance-options/

- "Transexual Romance" (oldmanpaco, 15 Sept, CLOSED)

http://forums.obsidi...1-the-romances/

- "The Romances?" (patboy12, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...s-are-included/

- "If romances" (zrani, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...d-romance-poll/

- "Sex and Romance Poll" (Troller, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-inclusiveness/

- "Anti-Gay Option" (Troller, 18th Sept) (Osvir's Note: Why not?)

http://forums.obsidi...-inclusiveness/

- "Include Gay Option" (c0wb0ycliche, 18th Sept) (Osvir's Note: Why not?)

-----------

CLASSES

http://forums.obsidi...sychics-psions/

- "Psychics/Psionics" (Luhaja, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...dmulti-classes/

- "Prestige/Advanced/Multi-Class" (Mystwalker, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...unique-classes/

- "Unique Classes" (NoxNoctum, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-psionic-class/

- "Psionic" (Mystwalker, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ss-speculation/

- "Class Speculation" (NateOwns, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ber-of-classes/

- "Companions and Classes" (TiLT42, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...60119-psionics/

- "Psionics Poll" (Aoha, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...7-class-system/

- "Class System" (Cariannis, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ranger-bondage/

- "Ranger Class"

http://forums.obsidi.../60292-classes/

- "Classes"

-----------

MODDING/TECHNICAL STUFF

http://forums.obsidi...0005-day-5-dlc/

- "Day 5 DLC" (13loodangel, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...duct-placement/

- "Item/NPC/Tavern naming help~" (Chaos Theory, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...n-stretch-goal/

- "Mod Support $2.2M Stretch Goal?" (Nills, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...09-mod-support/

- "Mod Support Poll" (Lynchbread, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ng-opportunity/

- "Voice-acting" (Nerevatar, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...etc-are-viable/

- "Co-Op ideas" (RogueBurger, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...bout-mods-baby/

- "Let's talk some Mods baby" (Shadowstrider, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ations-modding/

- "Modding animations" (Kopi, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...about-eternity/

- "About Modding" (Alupinu, 17th Sept~)

http://forums.obsidi...multiplayerlan/

- "Multiplayer/LAN" (AutoReiv, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...on-mod-support/

- "Mod Support Stretch Goal Suggestion" (piethief100, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...y-rules-system/

- "Red Ash World Engine" (Chris Jokinen, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...onsole-release/

- "Console?" (Kenny Powers, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ugs-and-polish/

- "Bugs and Polish" (Justinian, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...sharing-a-mods/

- "Modding tools" (testerius, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...y-of-a-toolkit/

- "Possibility for toolkit?" (fan, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...rats-mac-users/

- "For Mac users" (Muzrub333, 18th Sept)

-----------

PHILOSOPHY

http://forums.obsidi...0041-seriously/

- "Seriously" (Erlioth, 16th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...ed-of-grognard/

- "A Different Breed of Grognard" (Tamerlane, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...-this-is-silly/

- "This is silly" (gongal, 17th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...gion-and-ideas/

- "Mantra on Politic, Religion, Ideas" (Cantousent, 18th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...o-long-to-read/

- "Thoughts on RPG's" (Umberlin, 17th Sept)

-----------

MEMBER TO DEVELOPER RELATED

http://forums.obsidi...ns-to-the-devs/

- "Some questions (17 of them)" (13loodangel, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...from-this-game/

- "What I am looking forward to..." (Tsumoro, 15th Sept)

http://forums.obsidi...guys-want-okay/

- "Obsidian Forums? Official Forum?" (Hornet85, 16th Sept)

- "Do what you want to do!" (mickeym, 16th Sept) (Osvir's Note: The only thing I want to stress Obsidian about, personally, do what you want to do)

http://forums.obsidi...se-of-eternity/

- "Give us some basic info of premise" (Naked Ninja, 16th Sept)