Uhm. Okay.
I watched the first episode of Komi Can't Communicate. Immediately after it was over, Netflix suggested I continue with...
Back Street Girls: Gokudols.
Here's what Wikipedia has to say:
I'm uncertain what is more offensive, the fact that this is a thing that apparently exists, or the fact that Netflix thinks I would like to watch this, let alone perhaps enjoy it. Well, there's one nice thing, I no longer feel so bad about liking Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha even though I'm not sure what's that worth, lolicon still frames aren't a lot better than suggesting sepukku and sex reassignment are a similar level of punishment for a real Japanese yakuza (or men, in general). I don't think I need to say it, but I'm not liking Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha for its lolicon content, and it thankfully was short and hopefully will never come back again.
The really disgusting part about this is that it sounds like the classic racist defense, hey, I'm not racist, but... sigh. Ah, well, we all have our moments like these, right?
Also, in case you don't know what lolicon anime is, then, uhm, don't look it up. Let's just say that it would put Pedosus to shame, or rather, make him really hor... erm, happy.
As always with first episodes of a new anime, this post will contain somewhat unmarked spoilers and a general outline of the first episode (unless something imporant and twisty happens in the first episode, which it doesn't in this case).
Komi Can't Communicate, Episode 1: The beginning of a beautiful friendship (if you can stand the animation, voice acting and direction of this, which is a tough sell, really)
This pretty accurately portraits my face while watching the episode, for the most part.
Not sure where to start. This... doesn't look good, but thankfully I sat through 39 episodes and two movies of Sailor Moon Crystal and now have a different perspective on what bad looking animation is, so I no longer mind animes like this. Or rather, it's no longer enough to dismiss it out of hand. Alas, I'm not entirely certain that's entirely a good thing, but it was in the case of K-On!, and that was good enough to stay a net positive for a while though.
With that out of the way, we can proceed to the direction and it's adaptational quality. Or lack thereof. This has a very similar problem as Sailor Moon Crystal insofar as that it feels like a manga with animated frames, not an animated show that makes good use of the change in medium. It's filled to the brim with frames that would work as stills in a manga, but don't in an anime, and to make matters worse, a narrator lady and Hitohito take turns narrating what we can see anyway.
Please don't run away, Erica edition. The show can't know that I won't run even though I would like to. Curiously enough the best scene in the episode, because there is absolutely no talking.
Our two protagonists are Shouko Komi, who managed to get into an elite private high school in spite of not being able to talk to anyone at all, and Hitohito Tadano, a very literal average boy who by all means doesn't even have the grades to be accepted. He even narrates this himself. In good anime tradition, the character name are puns, or at least meaningful. Tada no hito really means "just a guy", as in - well - average dude. If you write Shouko's name in its correct Japanese myoji, then namae form, Komi Shouko, it turns into punny spelling of Komyushou-ko. Communication disorder girl (as mentioned earlier in this thread, "ko" means girl).
Hitohito wants nothing more than to not be noticed and average, and Shouko... wants to find friends. Clearly, fate decrees that the join forces to overcome their problems. Being a coward for Hitohito which is an unbearbale trait for any shounen protagonist to have, and Komi really suffers under her crippling shyness.
Every now and then Komi grows cat ears for no reason. Maybe she tries to hear the narrator lady.
Hitohito brutally overacts his narration, by the way. Shouko says a handful of words, but only when she's alone in the classroom with him while he's asleep.
In spite of her not being able to talk, she immediately becomes the most popular girl in the class - maybe even the entire school. Mr. Average Guy is the only person on the planet to notice that Komi is cripplingly shy and comes up with the idea of writing to communicate with her, instead of talking, in a scene which is, not going to lie, absolutely stunning in its brilliance.
For a moment, the framing and direction no longer matter, and nobody talks at all, and all of the dialogue plays out by Komi and Tadano writing a heap of kanji at each other on the classroom's chalkboard.
It's hard to describe how great this scene really is, and I mean that.
Sadly it also leads to Komi eventually running off, and it ends, and the anime goes back to being animated manga frames with a supremely weird outro and a bonus scene after the credits (literally called bonus scene).
Tadano asks Komi what her dream is, and she writes down having a hundred friends. He replies that he's going to help her find another 99 then. Yes, by all means, go ahead and help the girl find more friends. Don't bother suggesting she might go to a specialist with her disability. Well, we wouldn't have something to watch then.
At this point it goes back to being weird, because the narration suddenly kicks in and tells everyone that this private elite high school only accepts eccentric weirdos, so Tadano is going to have to work really hard to find 99 friends for Komi, who - as I mentioned already - has an enitre school full of people who want to be friends with her, because she's mysterious and beautiful. She doesn't even get yelled at by a teacher when asked to read a page of a book, because that teacher thinks it's a statment that reading is meant to be a quiet and contemplative activity, not a loud one.
You might wonder why this post is more chaotic than usual - that's because it's a reflection of the episode. It's total chaos, most of the time the framing and direction doesn't work, the voice actors overact to the point where you could take the dialogue and transplant it to JoJo's Bizarre Adventure without it being weird and the artstyle takes some getting used to. However, at least I didn't totally hate it*, and if the nice scene about the two finding a common ground to start from is any indication, it might get better in the future. It also just might stay that way. We'll see.
Assuming it stops trying to be funny, because it really wasn't. I can't explain why this falls flat while something like K-On! works for me. Probably because K-On! made sure that I liked the characters before it made them do funny things or end up in embarrassing situations. I really hope they're going to drop the cat ears thing. Really. It's... it was bordeline not funny in K-On! when Azusa was forced to wear a headband with cat ears (although it made for an immensely funny scene much, much later in the anime), but it's really, uhm, dumb here.
*I almost made a post after the first five minutes stating: "I hate this already!", just so you get an idea how much that one scene salvaged this. Things work like that for me sometimes, you can take a sea of terrible and give it one brilliant moment, and that'll be enough. It is, in this case, but it remains a big if for future episodes.