Portrait Poll

[Monte Carlo]

So, old-skool or hi-tech.

 

Obviously I want old-skool with the choice of importing custom ports.

[LadyCrimson]

Definitely old-skool and custom ports.

[Infinitron]

Duh.

Lack of portraits was one of the worst things about NWN2. Those disembodied 3D heads looked rather horrible.

[Seagloom]

Old-skool. I like using my own custom portraits. Unless there are a ton of appearance customization options, which I doubt, 3D portraits will not be anywhere near as personalized.

[Humanoid]

Blind answer would be portraits of course, but a final answer would need to wait until we get some preliminary shots of what the in-game models look like - DA:O would have looked ridiculous with painted portraits at the level of zoom you could do.

 

I'd like the portrait option split into two though - close-ups only or full body.

[Nakia]

Old school with custom portrait imports if possible.

[level10]

I wonder how feasible it would be to have some kind of 'live' portrait, that updates with what your character is wearing, and possibly their HP level, which is processed through some kind of filter to give it a traditional painted feel...

[generic.hybridity]

I didn't mind the Dragon Age 1 portraits so much but I think that old school portraits are better,

[Gurkog]

3d models of heads lack the personality that the old style portraits conveyed. Plus it is awesome to put Bobby Kotick's head on a companion and treating it like ****.

Edited September 17, 2012 by Gurkog

[Kalavan]

If we have to choose, definitely old-school

 

But we could have them both, like in ToEE

[Majek]

Oldskool portraits blinking and moving lips. :D

[Pangur]

Obviously I want old-skool with the choice of importing custom ports.

This. Definitely this.

[Smejki]

It is simple. You cannot make a animated head that:

- is cheap to make

AND

- does not feel out of space

 

so 2D art rules in this.

 

though Dragon Age did (non-animated) 3D heads decently they were hust heads. Compare it with Minsc portraits - stylised, with Boo (hamster) and some emotions... basically a whole story in itself.

Edited September 17, 2012 by Smejki

[Kilroy_Was_Here]

Exactly. In fact, I think there should be another voting option. Every portrait, regardless of race or gender should be of Minsc and Boo.

[Lady Evenstar]

I love searching out portraits that can express (or inspire) the character of my PC, so definitely old-skool with import of custom portraits here.

[Smejki]

...damn. bad reaction

Edited September 17, 2012 by Smejki

[Kai]

2d portraits with the option to have custom ones.

[Arrgeron]

Why not both?

 

This forum needs a Zoidberg smiley...

[Jozape]

Dragon Age didn't have animated portraits/moving avatars, that was Planescape: Torment. They're nice looking, but I think the portraits in BG and IWD looked much nicer, with the added ability to port our own. Custom portraits win hands down.

[Adam Brennecke]

Old skool of course!

[Monte Carlo]

Yay an early win!

[Sensuki]

Pointless thread

[JediMB]

I voted for #2 mostly because an animated character portrait would be essential to show facial expressions in an isometric game.

 

Of course, if they (and people loading in custom portraits) are prepared to have a huge variety of expressions drawn for their 2D faces instead, I'm fine with that.

[Karranthain]

I'm in favour of old-school portraits. They just ooze personality and quite often are simply works of art. And you have an option to use whatever you like with custom options.

 

Check out this topic as well : http://forums.obsidian.net/topic/60122-stretch-goal-hire-justin-sweet-to-make-portraits/

 

I think you'll love them if you like the IE style character art.

[^Rayne^]

I think this one has a clear winner. I remember back in the day the talk of removing them because they were a bit old fashioned when there was 3D characters on the screen. However to this day those 3d characters never properly show the status of the character. Plus there is something cool about the idealized portrait of each PC being shown rather than a 3D rendering of them. I hope they do go back to the portrait views.

 

The real goal should be to make the 3D character in the game actually resemble the portrait to a large degree. I would love to see these little marching characters actually look something like their portraits even if they're miniature in a top down fixed view.