New Game + vs Once and Done

[Cariannis 10]

Which type of replay are you more interested in? New game plus where you can beat the game with one character and start the game over with the same character (Baldur’s Gate did this). Or more along the lines of once you finished the game you need to make a new character (Dragon Age: Origins like). Or a game that never ends (Elder Scrolls).

[Bos_hybrid 375]

Meh, I want it to be the type of game where I start it up again straight away with a new character and see how choosing differently from the first character changed the game.

 

That's the kind of replay I'm interested in.

[Wintersong 203]

New Game+ sounds like ARPG and hunting for more higher level loot.

 

I'm happy with ending the story of my character and leaving replayability to starting a new character.

[czinczar 28]

With my newgame+, I also want chocobos and Nobuo Uematsu as music composer.

[Gorth 3,097]

Meh, I want it to be the type of game where I start it up again straight away with a new character and see how choosing differently from the first character changed the game.

 

That's the kind of replay I'm interested in.

This.

[Merin 338]

I'll replay with a new character, try new things, hope to find new and different stuff.

[Jancarius 2]

I would like the option to import my character ala Baldur's Gate, NWN, and Icewind Dale. This serves the purpose A) easy SP to MP conversion and B) "HAHA FEAR THE WRATH OF MY MAGE-GOD PUNY CELLAR RATS!" <-- who hasn't enjoyed doing this

[Elthosian 15]

I prefer no shallow NG+ modes, really, just give me lots of replayability!

[lolaldanee 164]

i loved how it was done in alpha protocol

if you started out as the "recruit" class in your first playthrough, you could unlock the "veteran" class and had some new dialog options because people asumed you are a battle hardened guy - quite well done if you ask me

[Inertia 39]

Heart of Fury mode in iwd2 was pretty cool how about something like that?

[Aedelric 276]

All are good, which is best depends on the kind of story, game mechanics and setting.

Edited September 26, 2012 by Aedelric

[Armand 32]

I don't know really, I mean, haven't all previous IE games had a lot of replay value already in that you can make such different characters and take so many different paths? Even if the main game plays out similarly.

 

One idea though, could be that you play as any good old adventurer in new game+, and the main quest is happening in the world, but it's not surrounding you? And you can go wherever and just do side quests, and see reactions to what's happening in the main quest, in places and from perspectives that weren't available to you as you played the characters actually doing the the mq the first time round? (phew, long sentence.) You could import any character and just get going. Experience the game world freely.

 

But, I'd rather not spend resources on that, and just have a terrific main game.

[nikolokolus 805]

New character, new class/race and back to square one for me

[Jozape 75]

I never understood why anyone thought new game+ was a good idea. Wouldn't you rather just have the ability to create a higher level character from the start?

 

Meh, I want it to be the type of game where I start it up again straight away with a new character and see how choosing differently from the first character changed the game.

 

That's the kind of replay I'm interested in.

 

Likewise. Playing a different character is rewarding enough to warrant subsequent playthroughs.

[nikolokolus 805]

I never understood why anyone thought new game+ was a good idea. Wouldn't you rather just have the ability to create a higher level character from the start?

 

Some people really love grinding I guess? Personally I can think of nothing nastier and more soul sucking

[IchigoRXC 46]

I want both replayability from creating new characters and trying out lots of different things, but I also want an import export function for my character during the game and also upon completion.

[Enclave 31]

Always a fan of being able to import my old character, equipment and all.

[Volourn 2,546]

Bos hybrid wins this thread. GAME OVER.

[Orogun01 2,848]

I'm a fan of NG+ although I would prefer it if they actually incorporated something that makes replay with a carryover save worthwhile, like collectibles, or special items.

[Gurkog 73]

Newgame+ should stay in the ****ty console games and ARPGs that have little to no story and all combat. An import/export option does not really even make sense either as there is no multiplayer. I would rather they spend more effort on making a cohesive world and story than an everlasting mmo-esque trash feature.

[Redwulf 50]

New game plus sounds good, I figure why take options away? I probably wouldn't start over with the same character, but, who knows, if there was a greater challenge, and I really liked the chracter I made, I might just decide to. So why not, I daresay, why not!

[Enclave 31]

Newgame+ should stay in the ****ty console games and ARPGs that have little to no story and all combat. An import/export option does not really even make sense either as there is no multiplayer. I would rather they spend more effort on making a cohesive world and story than an everlasting mmo-esque trash feature.

 

Uhhuh, doesn't belong eh? Just like it didn't belong in those classic Infinity Engine games that had it via character import?

[Monkcrab 52]

NG+, why not? Sometimes I get attached to a character and want to do another run with them, only doing things differently (for different character debelopment). Having NG+ makes the grinding more tolerable in that case.....and having it takes essentially nothing away from those times when I want to create someone new, so.

 

Maybe having extra options ala AP would be nice, too, but I shan't wish for the moon.

[Darth Trethon 206]

This is Obsidian we're talking about so the amount of branching in the story based on our choices is going to be insanely good with tons of endings so it'd be a waste to play the game just once. One way or another there will be tons of replay value and I'd very much appreciate the NG+ option to help things along on repeat playthroughs.

[Chaos Theory 126]

I savor nearly every moment of the first playthrough, which ends up taking me twice as long as most. I often call it a "completionist" playthrough, however this isn't accurate. I don't find every easter egg, uncover every piece of content, etc. But I do find and complete every quest, and if there is a crafting component involved (armor or weapons, only), I'll spend hours upon hours mastering that. I play as if I were the protagonist and since I'm not into the 'evil' side of life, I have zero interest in a replay just to see what that's like.

 

Therefore, I'm a once-and-done player that loves sequels if it means I can continue my original character-- indefinitely if allowed. I may replay after several years, but only if it was a great first playthrough.