Everything posted by PK htiw klaw eriF
-
Anita Sarkeesian/Tropes and Women in Gaming
That refers directly to why she is blocking comments on her video, not that the audience is literally being deprived of their ability to have opinions or is incapable at having discussions anywhere else. He isn't claiming that it is impossible to have an opinion about the video, he is stating that it is impossible to post one's opinion of the video where the people who made the video are most likely to see it. 1. Maybe she should be. If she wanted to start a conversation about negative tropes for women in video games, why doesn't she start a small forum for people to talk about it? She did over shoot her budget by $144000, so it isn't like she doesn't have the resources. 2. That is a good thing. Someone could see an interesting perspective they had not thought of and come out better for it. There would also be a centralized location for people to talk about it, rather than have to navigate several video game forums in search of an interesting conversation. If 9% are active participants, then she is screwing them out of their say by blocking everyone's comments. If her supporters want to congratulate her on a video they think is well done, they cannot do it directly. If a detractor with something more intelligent than "FEMINAZIS SUK BALLZ! LOLOLOLOLOLOL" wants to present a legitimate complaint about the video, they cannot do it directly. By taking a blanket approach to weed out trolls, she is depriving herself of direct exposure to the initial thoughts of others. Nobody gains anything by blocking comments, while some have a chance to gain something by allowing them. EDIT: Frankly I'm a bit tired of arguing about a badly made video that was very superfluous. Last statement from me until she posts another. I dislike how she disabled the comments. Feedback(especially negative) is always something to consider. I think she is depriving herself of feedback that could allow her to make a better video by cutting off a direct link to feedback. I think the video is not well executed. She mainly talks about 4 franchises in about 24 minutes, which she could have done in 10 minutes. I think she assumes too much about DiD plot model. For Star Fox, it was about putting resources behind a more recognizable IP that was fairly popular at the time. For Zelda, the villain is neutralizing a threat, not simply kidnapping a helpless princess. For Mario, Bowzer is a goddamn dragon turtle that breathes fire and commands armies. For Double Dragon, it is a stupid ass 80s game, of course it is regressive crap, it was made a quarter century ago.
-
Steam
PK htiw klaw eriF replied to One-Eye Jack's topic in Pillars of Eternity: General Discussion (NO SPOILERS)I'll take DRM-free over cloud saving any day.
-
Concept Artist Kazunori Aruga aka *K*
Wait, he? Uhhhhhhhhhhhhh..... Excuse me, have to correct some things. It seems your detective skills are a bit rusty.
-
Steam
PK htiw klaw eriF replied to One-Eye Jack's topic in Pillars of Eternity: General Discussion (NO SPOILERS)You can buy it on Steam if you wish. Or you can make the sensible decision and buy it from GOG. It will not require Steamworks.
-
Anita Sarkeesian/Tropes and Women in Gaming
How far did you get in to the video? He actually says "Trying to censor the dissenting point of view does not make it go away". He doesn't assert that "dissenting views will not be presented". His point was that by disabling peoples ability to discuss her video at the same place where her video resides, she is giving the impression that her ideas can not hold up to scrutiny. Instead, she has become a Damsel in Distress who needs various white knights to save her from the various hordes of the internet. She exemplifies the stereotype that she spent 24 minutes railing about. Yes, we are having the discussion here on the Obsidian Forums. There is no discussion on her youtube channel and she isn't directing people to where they may discuss her video either. The average viewer isn't going to think "I have something to contribute, let me go to [forum where a discussion is occurring] and post my thoughts and see what others think!" It is hardly a copout. The internet is an extremely toxic place saturated with trolls who like nothing better than to **** with people, especially those who seem to believe in something. The negative reaction her kickstarter pitch and video received is hardly an uncommon one. She should have known what would happen.
-
Anita Sarkeesian/Tropes and Women in Gaming
That anti-porn but pro-sex article was incredibly condescending. On the video, .
-
The good, bad, and the ugly in Infinity Engine games
PK htiw klaw eriF replied to PrimeJunta's topic in Pillars of Eternity: General Discussion (NO SPOILERS)I dislike the 2E ruleset quite a bit.
-
The good, bad, and the ugly in Infinity Engine games
PK htiw klaw eriF replied to PrimeJunta's topic in Pillars of Eternity: General Discussion (NO SPOILERS)Well they do have an IWD module for NWN2.....would that count? IMO 3/3.5E/Pathfinder rules are much better than 2E(and translate into video games slightly better).
-
The good, bad, and the ugly in Infinity Engine games
PK htiw klaw eriF replied to PrimeJunta's topic in Pillars of Eternity: General Discussion (NO SPOILERS)Damn you Prime and Raz! Now I really want to run through PST or BG. I can't bring myself to break from the MotB playthrough I just started though. BTW, is BGEE worth it?
-
EA lives in a different reality
You did that too? Anyways, I couldn't care less about EA, because I am not interested in any of their products. I will stick to kickstarter to get my fix, and major publishers can continue to make the cinematic swill they think is irresistible to young males.
-
Crazy cyber-attack map
Russians spending their days attacking people electronically? Very likely.
-
Anita Sarkeesian/Tropes and Women in Gaming
I think one of the reasons it is scrutinized in more detail in video games and comic books is that the female characters portrayed in those mediums are not real people, so one could see it as creating a standard that no real woman could reach. Which has some truth to it, if you look at the average large breasted anime girl or sultry female video game characters, you do in fact see physiques that are nearly impossible for a real woman to obtain, even with surgical enhancements. Of course(like we covered before IIRC),the problem is taking one extreme example of X and assuming every instance of X is like that.
-
Neverwinter Nights 2 or Dungeon Siege 3?
NWN2 hands down. OC isn't great, but is pretty good if you are ok with some horrible trash mobs during the first act. MotB is an excellent story that surpasses PST IMO. SoZ is closer to IWD, but is pretty good if you like those types of games. Make sure you install Kaedrin's PRC if you go for NWN2.
-
Anita Sarkeesian/Tropes and Women in Gaming
Absolutely. Peoples experience with certain parts of X do factor in to their opinions and view of X. For example if I told someone whose only experience with video games were first-person shooters and sports games that video games were capable of telling great stories on par with novels and films, they would probably not understand where I was coming from, because they have not been exposed to games like PST. Well of course there are going to be differences in how armor fits male and female characters, but there is a difference from a set of breastplate adjusting to fit a woman's form, and a woman strutting around in a skintight designed to accent her busty form.
-
Might & Magic X Teased by Ubisoft, To Be Revealed at PAX East
Not interested. This is more than likely going to be something like the Ultima game Bioware is doing.
-
Anita Sarkeesian/Tropes and Women in Gaming
Well yeah, but the majority of people are not going to follow the game's development. Most people are going to see a commercial during a TV show and form their opinions based on that.
-
Anita Sarkeesian/Tropes and Women in Gaming
Agreed. We could probably spend all week presenting extreme examples that support arguments that X is always childish. sexist, etc. without actually touching what the majority of what X actually is. Just to clarify, I don't mean that everyone who plays those games are necessarily younger(hell, I'm 21 and I can't stand them), just that they are marketed in a way the people marketing the game thinks attracts younger(14-25) males. Absolutely. Most commercials for video games are full of actiony cutscenes filled with violence. Just look at the ME3 commercials that were played during The Daily Show and The Colbert Report last year. Nothing about making hard choices, just a giant ship invading earth and a group of soldiers landing and fighting giant monsters. You could probably look at any commercial(which is what the average person will see) for any AAA game and see huge amounts of action but little else. So it doesn't even have to be the game itself is all action, just the commercial/ public perception of it.
-
Anita Sarkeesian/Tropes and Women in Gaming
In comic books, it is pretty common actually. Outside of Liefield's art(which is generally panned) most males are illustrated as very fit, but do not look like body-builders. Never got over two hours in to DA2, so I can't really comment on how the characters are portrayed. I would say the problem with the portrayal of women in video games is complete perception. You view Isabella as a complex female character who happens to enjoy having sex(who doesn't!?) but doesn't exist solely to have sex with the PC. Someone else may view Isabella as pure fanservice created just to give the player the ability to watch the PC have white-underwear notsex with. The same can be said of the whole "save the girl" trope. Some might view it as a tired but true motive for the protagonist, while others may consider it to be disrespectful to women because it means they are good for nothing but getting kidnapped. What really matters is the writers intention. Did the DA writers intend for Isabella to be a complex character or a digital sex machine? Did Zelda writers intend for Zelda to be a helpless girl incapable of saving herself or someone who has the misfortune of being the victim of an incredibly powerful villain and is needed to stop the villain? Well I don't really enjoy those games(hell I'm willing to throw money through kickstarter because I find them that bad) and don't play them so I wouldn't know. It seems that these games are being marketed to a specific group(younger males who play on console), who are perceived to appreciate a half-naked woman with large breasts over interesting female characters who are nuanced and have complex plot-lines. I prefer games like NWN2, where the focus is less on sex and action and more on characterization. I would recommend that those who dislike the over sexualization of wimminz in teh vidya gaems try playing something besides main-stream action games which seek to appeal to the lowest common denominator.
-
Anita Sarkeesian/Tropes and Women in Gaming
I know. Most of the female X-men fall in to that category, as well most female Marvel, Image, and some Dark Horse characters. I would say the same about DC, but ever since the New52 brought back 90s artsyles......well no.(I would go into a "Blame DC" for the overseualization/hyperidealization, but don't feel like posting it) Anyways, doesn't sexualization and idealization cross over? I mean almost every time an empowered confident woman is portrayed in fiction, they happen to be quite attractive. Hell men in fiction are generally closer to Ryan Gosling than some steroid swallowing hulk, so it isn't like men aren't sexualized at all. Maybe I don't play enough games(or read enough comics) where women are one-dimensional characters that just sit there and look pretty. Bioware does bungle female characters quite a bit IMO. Like Jack, who a male PC can cure of the crazies by (tenderly)putting it to her.
-
What makes you like your favorite games?
PK htiw klaw eriF replied to PrimeJunta's topic in Pillars of Eternity: General Discussion (NO SPOILERS)That is a very common problem. I played Arcanum on a friend's advice and thought it would be perfect but found myself terribly disappointed. I can't really put my finger on why exactly Arcanum just doesn't do it for me, but it just doesn't.
-
Anita Sarkeesian/Tropes and Women in Gaming
That would be quite nice. As many times as I've heard the false equivalency argument, I've never actually seen someone give an example of what an idealized(instead of sexualized) woman would be/look like.
-
Armed Force lose tuition assistance
Well this sucks. As an inhabitant of a state saturated with right-wingers, I apologize for any half-baked conspiracies that might come from Alex Jones on this matter.
-
How much funding do you think Torment: ToN will raise
I think they will raise somewhere between 3.5-4.5 million. I don't think they will exceed the amount PE raised by much(if at all). When you look at how quickly T:ToN raised the funds, you have to take in to account that it was promoted quite a bit before the kickstarter started, while PE was not.
- Racism alive and well in the UK
-
What makes you like your favorite games?
PK htiw klaw eriF replied to PrimeJunta's topic in Pillars of Eternity: General Discussion (NO SPOILERS)Oy vey, putting AC right next to ME. Dem's fight words. I don't follow. He means ME is garbage. The way BioWare handled ME2-3 and its issues along with their fake choice system mkaes me inclined to agree. Fixed that for you.