I think any video game movie screams straight to video.
Like comic book movies back in the day, Hollywood won't treat them seriously, and won't allow the directors to handle them properly.
Anyone remember the old Fantastic Four movie, the old Captain American movie, the old Punisher movie, etc. etc.
Only now Hollywood will hire a proper geek and allow them control to do a comic book movie justice. M$ is demanding tight control over a Halo movie, and that may be the first video game movie to be done right.
I know Doom is already headed for disaster, and I don't trust Bloodrayne will be much better.