Music is degraded to *MONO* 10kHz @ 48 kbit/s?!

[markussun]

Sorry for the long rant below to get my point across, but if you don't like long reads, here's the short version:

 

To all who read this,

 

Please contribute just a few minutes of your time to make a real difference and email LucasArts:

 

CLICK HERE to request the proper 44kHz *STEREO* music for KotOR2.

 

Telling LucasArts how you feel about the degraded (MONO 10 kHz muffled) music is arguably the single-most effective way you can contribute to this effort. If continuing feedback shows them that this is a bothersome issue to more than a handful customers, they will do something about it (as history showed with KotOR1).

 

Please, be proactive -- every voice counts!

 

Why is the music in KOTOR2 such a muffled, narrow-sounding, low-quality mess?

 

Because it's all compressed in the lowest bitrate with a 10 kHz-filter, and, to make things even worse, converted to MONO!

 

Why MONO?! Is this a bad joke?

 

I was very much looking forward to this new Star Wars-like soundtrack, particularly since LucasArts had created enough buzz about KOTOR2 using a live symphony orchestra this time around to achieve a "big, powerful sound", with legendary Skywalker Sound mixing it.

 

Yeah right.

 

This game goes back for a refund first thing on Monday. KOTOR 2 is buggy enough, but as a gamer seeking quality entertainment I won't accept such sub-standard audio quality in a 2005 game release that comes on 4 CDs! There is no excuse for that.

 

I won't take space concerns as a poor excuse: The whole music assets in KOTOR2 take up a measly 24 MB in its current butchered state. There is over 80 MB (!) unused space left on the 4th CD. If the music were encoded in standard 128 kbit/s STEREO, it would just need an extra 41 MB (2.7x more bytes) -- which would have easily fit on the 4 game CDs.

 

This is preposterous.

 

No... outrageous!

 

Music is *half* the experience for me both in gaming and in movies. It totally creates the atmosphere of the setting, characters and story. Music can generate emotions and feelings and thus pull you into this fictional world -- an effect of immersion that (apart from being there for real and experiencing your own emotions) cannot be achieved by starring at 3D graphics on a flat (2D) 19" monitor alone and listening to some dialogue.

 

Gaming on a flat screen is like looking through a small window into a larger world. But it's the music which opens it up and enlarges that world for you.

 

I'm sure many gamers here are with me on this. Music is the most powerful tool any storyteller can have, because it acts like a second narrator, who can comment on things that are too hard or impossible to put into words. As long as game graphics are still so cartoony and artificial-looking, it is the music's job to add proper gravity and seriousness to the fictional world and story.

 

Ok, enough of this rambling. I'm sure you get my point of how crucial I regard music in this medium (particularly RPG/story-based games).

 

And LucasArts gives us music in MONO (!) at 10900 Hz (half the frequency) at the lowest bitrate?!

 

Excuse me? Are they out of their minds?

 

This ignores and erases more than 10 years of progress in game audio! Music in MIDI at that time was already presented in STEREO. Even games such as Quake (released in 1996) efficiently used pre-recorded STEREO music tracks streamed from the CD (which made a huge difference to the scary atmosphere of the game). LucasArts' own Grim Fandango used a great STEREO soundtrack in 1998 to create an epic experience. That was in the "golden days" of LucasArts of course, when such brilliant minds as Tim Schaffer were still employed there.

 

The original KOTOR from 2003 supplied Jeremy Soule's epic music in 16-bit 44Khz *STEREO* at 128 kbit/s, which is close to CD quality, and the proper way to present Star Wars-like music. It's a symphonic score for crying out loud!

 

Do you people know what MONO 10kHz 48 kbit/s does to the music? In case you don't, let me spell it out:

• 10 kHz:
  The music files are technically encoded in 32kHz, but the shocking truth was revealed when I analyzed the MP3 file-header (thanks Swaaye!), which stated that the music was encoded with a "Lowpass Filter: 10900 Hz". I couldn't believe that, so I fired up CoolEditPro and did a Spectral Analysis on the music files: There is absolutely nothing above 10900 Hz! That's what a lowpass filter does, it discards all frequencies higher than that. I was sitting there in disgust upon discovery of this fact.
   
  The human ear can hear up to 18-20 kHz. What this practically means is that all the "highs" of the original music were cut out -- half of the frequency range of the music is missing. It will sound muffled and dull because of that. And it does.
   
   
  
• 48 kbit/s MP3 lossy compression:
  It is well-known that the MP3 codec utterly fails at lower bitrates (less than 128 Kbit/s). At such a low bitrate as used in KotOR2 the music will be garbled and muddled due to excessive audio artifacting (aliasing) because of running out of bits. This in turn will affect the mid-range and make the music sound "hollow" and "metallic". Symphonic music with its strings and trumpets is particularly prone to this.
   
   
  
• MONO:
  Do I have to comment on what MONO does? Come on people, think about it, MONO! Is this the 50s? Playing back a symphonic (!) score in mono will make the whole range of the soundscape collapse. The musical score will not sound wide and epic, but small and narrow, like through a telephone. If you play your games with headphones, mono will give you a very unnatural music-in-your-head experience, which can become quite distressing to your ears after a while (listening fatigue).
  

Why didn't LucasArts encode the whole soundtrack in telephone-quality (~8kHz mono) right away? :angry:

 

Man, I'm really upset about this.

 

Releasing a full-priced title in such a poor quality is an INSULT to the gamer and also to the composer (Mark Griskey, who btw did an incredible job making this soundtrack much more Star-Wars-sounding than even Jeremy Soule did in KOTOR; Soule used synthesizers, Griskey a live orchestra and a style very similar to John Williams!).

 

A game company's job is selling an experience to the gamer -- to involve the gamer emotionally. That's the holy grail of game development. LucasArts has just shown me that they don't care about or understand the meaning of gaming "experience", and how that is achieved by a large degree through music. A shame for a company associated with arguably the greatest pioneer in sound-mastering and reproduction in the history of cinema.

 

Some readers might think I'm silly for missing out on the good things that KOTOR2 has, by returning the game because they bastardized the music. Well, try to see it trough my eyes (or ears): The original KOTOR for me really came to life through the epic music, more than anything else. It made the game for me. I was looking forward to KOTOR2 already after having heard the preview music, simply because the new music captivated me. And now this!

 

Who made this insane decision to present this beautifully composed symphonic live music in MONO 10kHz at the lowest bitrate? I'm certain that it wasn't Mark Griskey. I would love to find out how he feels about his work being disregarded and mistreated in such a way. He must be in agony as an artist and composer.

 

What's wrong with LucasArts? Why bother recording with a live Symphony Orchestra (which needs a bigger budget) to achieve a more organic higher musical quality, when you then pervert it by degrading it to near-telephone "quality" for the gamer who pays $50 for the experience? This is utterly pointless.

 

Let's not forget that LucasArts is under the auspices of George Lucas, the very man who repeatedly stressed the fact that music and sound make up for 50% of the entertainment experience (I couldn't agree more). Are we surrounded by hypocrites here? Is LucasArts still a Lucas company? How come a game from EA like "Lord of the Rings: Return of the King" gets THX treatment (!) (and it really made a difference, it sounded incredible), and LucasArts' own games have never received THX treatment since the program was introduced (by Lucasfilm) for games almost 1.5 years ago?

 

Something is really wrong with this company, and how they treat their own games. Some would call such behaviour schizophrenic.

 

The final product's quality stands in direct contrast with what they promote in such features as the Designer Diaries. Have you people read the "Designer Diary #5 - Music" where Mark Griskey writes about his work on KOTOR2? If not, go read it! You will be surprised how much care and expertise supposedly went into creating and recording the soundtrack. And then you will ask yourself even more why none of that effort ended up in the final game. I'm totally baffled about this.

 

Here are some interesting tidbits from that interview:

 

I was thrilled when recording engineer John Kurlander signed on for the project. John is a veteran film music engineer whose credits include the Grammy Award-winning Lord of the Rings soundtracks. I knew that John would be able to capture the big, powerful sound that I wanted for the score.

 

Yes, and I as a customer would also be thrilled if what was captured by John Kurlander would actually be reproduced when I play the game.

 

The score was recorded at the Bastyr University Chapel outside of Seattle. Bastyr is known for its acoustic properties, and John Kurlander took full advantage of the acoustics with some very methodical microphone placement. [...]

 

We mixed at Skywalker Sound. Mix engineer Dann Michael Thompson and assistant engineer Judy Kirschner provided their exceptional talents, and final mixes were completed after three long but extremely satisfying days. [...]

 

When all was said and done, we had over an hour of new, fully orchestrated music for The Sith Lords!

 

As you can see, an incredible effort was undertaken to live-perform, record, and mix the musical soundtrack for KOTOR2. Even Skywalker Sound was involved, the top address for sound recording and mixing in the movie industry. And then some moron in the game design process made the unexplicable decision to degrade it all down to near-telephone quality for the final product.

 

I truly wonder who made that stupid decision, and I wish the person(s) responsible for this mess will be fired.

 

To Obsidian: Weren't you able to have some say in this? Why did you let yourself be bullied towards such a questionable decision?

 

The question still remains why they did that. It's not a space issue (as demonstrated above already). It's certainly not a performance issue either. Decoding and playing MP3 music needs only one decode stream. MP3-decoding is very cheap on today's CPUs, it's a non-issue performance-wise (the bottleneck in the KOTOR engine is your gfx card, not the CPU). It makes no difference to CPU load if the music source is a 128kbps or 48kbps file (original KOTOR had 128kbps music and ran just fine).

 

To give you an idea of how insignificant MP3 decoding in games is performance-wise, take games like the recent Doom3 which have to decode OGG streams (which need roughly twice the CPU decoding power than MP3). Doom3 uses OGG encoding for almost all sound files, not just for music! At any given moment, Doom3 has to decode 10-20 OGG sounds in realtime (in a fight even more), which is a lot. Still, sound decoding in Doom3 takes up less than 6% of CPU load on a ~1500Mhz minimum spec system (which I confirmed via email with Robert Duffy, lead programmer at id-soft).

 

And that is in Doom3. MP3 decoding in KOTOR1 or 2 is a cakewalk compared to that, especially when we're talking about only 2-3 streams that need realtime decoding, i.e. the music stream, ambient stream and speech. Other sound effects are in WAV. So, that is not the reason why LucasArts/Obsidian decided to butcher the music files.

 

Do you know what I suspect? It just dawned on me: Maybe they supplied the music in such a low quality so they could later sell a potential Soundtrack Audio CD to the public, and make some extra profit from that. Then customers would have a reason to purchase the high-quality CD, since the in-game music was so crappy. But that ploy won't work with me. I want to experience the full-quality music while playing the game, not while driving in my car.

 

If I'm wrong, LucasArts/Obsidian, then prove me wrong: Release the proper 44kHz *STEREO* music for KotOR2 as a separate download (patch) to the public, so that we PC gamers can enjoy the music as it was meant to be. Then I will again consider buying the game.

 

Because, the other possibility is that this audio blunder was a big slip-up. After all, why are the music files encoded in the exact same format they used for their voiceover files? 48 kbit/s in MONO is sufficient for speech (I can accept that), but no sane person would encode music in that same quality. Maybe in the rush to release the game, they accidentally batch-encoded all the files in the same format they configured for speech.

 

Another fact substantiating this is the inclusion of a music track player (!) within the game, as a menu option feature (similar to the cutscenes player). This is pure irony: Who in their right mind would include a music track player so that you can listen to the great music in pure form (without sound effects) if the whole soundtrack is reduced to this sad telephone-quality state? This shows me that the music was always planned to be of CD-quality. If not, why code a CD-Player-like feature then?

 

Also, the splash screen (game launcher) on the Windows desktop features the music in CD-quality STEREO. This is the only time you'll ever hear the epic soundtrack (a short segment) in the proper way -- in the launcher window! How ironic. Once you hit the game's main menu, it's all muffled & narrow mono.

 

If they offered us the proper 44kHz STEREO music in a patch, it would only be a 60 MB download for the music, according to my estimates. That's not too big, considering that many game-patches these days have similar (and even bigger) sizes: Rome Total War - 60MB, Armies of Exigo - 50MB, Star Wars Battlefront - 173MB.

 

 

In the meantime, I urge the fan community to come up with our own solution to this. Maybe someone can somehow gain access to the higher quality stereo music files and then we could create a MOD to fix this mess ourselves. At least we would make enough noise about it to get noticed.

 

I think if enough of us push in the right direction and let them know what we think about this blunder, they will eventually do something about it. This is unacceptable. Nobody who bought the game should accept this. If you go to a multiplex theater and pay 13 bucks to watch a new movie, would you just accept watching it in analog MONO? Would you allow them to rob you of the full experience (Digital Surround) if you know better?

Go email LucasArts!

CLICK HERE to request the proper 44kHz *STEREO* music for KotOR2. Telling LucasArts how you feel about the degraded music is the single-most effective way you can make this happen. If they receive continuing feedback on this issue, the chances are good they will do something about it.

 

If you just sit here idly, nothing will come of it. We need to make noise about this -- and act NOW, before the first patches are coming out, because now is the time when Obsidian is still funded by LucasArts to implement any such changes. Later it will be in vain.

 

Also, it might help to add your comment to this thread and thereby let Obsidian know what you think about this blunder. It'll ensure that this thread stays a hot topic. But don't forget: It's LucasArts who needs to get the feedback from you... *they* need to be convinced in order to make the decision to fix this.

 

The music playback in KOTOR2 is below standards -- more than 10 years backwards. We consumers need to speak up about this to let game companies know that we don't accept sub-standard audio! Otherwise they will increasingly treat us like gullible pushovers, who shell out the money and won't know the difference. If we stay passive and don't demand quality, more and more developers will adopt the habit of only doing as much as they can get away with in order to ensure sales. Their marketing team will do the rest.

 

Quality and artistic vision will then begin to erode. Do you want this to happen?

 

It's in your hands. Vote with your gaming dollar and make your voice heard. Small steps can make a difference.

 

And yes, there are always more important things to worry about in life. I can imagine some readers thinking "geez, this guy is extreme, is that all he worries about? I can't even run the game properly!" etc. etc... It's all a matter of perspective. There are many other things in life I worry about, too. But that doesn't mean we have to ridicule things we deem less of a priority. We all have our own convictions and priorities. Right now, I have set my focus on this issue, and it's important to me. And that's really all there is to say.

 

I wrote this big post to inform and to make a difference.

 

Help to make this effort not be in vain...

 

Also, check out Kiwegapa's useful KOTOR 2 Game Issues Guide. It is a comprehensive guide to the game's Issues & Bugs, and a central collection of Feature Requests & Performance Tips.

[Zach Morris]

wow. That is an intense read. I'll have to come back to it when it isn't 3 in the morning. I think this one wins the award for longest post I have seen.

[Astatine]

Good rant

 

One quibble. Dropping the 10kHz-20kHz frequency range doesn't remove "half" the audible frequency range -- that would be half the octaves -- it just removes the topmost octave (it's a log scale). It's not quite that bad... (Especially since old farts such as myself can't hear those frequencies very much any more anyway )

 

...still reprehensible, though...

[Meshugger]

The xbox version is mixed in mono aswell. But the quality is higher, it's 44kHz at 128kbit/s.

[Nevan]

Nice Post, I hope all the complaints to LA and OB really make a difference... People returning a game though is a sure way to get there attention though , if enough people do it at least.

[><FISH'>]

o.O how long did it take you to research and write out that post?

[Mondo]

Yea it sucks it was such low quality. :/

[Bokishi]

Awesome post.

[Whitemithrandir]

I honestly couldn't tell the difference.

[darth moon]

Mono!? I knew it!

[Salsabettis]

I was able to become immersed into the game, so it wasn't that bad. I also don't notice audio quality that well. I will listen more carefully during my next playthrough.

 

After reading all this I have one question for you. Can you return a game for a refund after it has already been opened? Any store around here, you can only return opened software for the same exact thing. It must be different in Canada.

[Bokishi]

I thought everything was free in Canada

[NeverwinterKnight]

I thought everything was free in Canada 

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

except volourn. hes an expensive item.

[Darth Drabek]

Nice research! I played TSL on a cheap TV that only plays in mono anyway, so I didn't notice the low quality too much.

 

I bet Griskey feels about the same way Nicky Katt does about his hard work being thrown out in the street. "

 

(If you didn't get that, check the spoiler forum after you beat the game)

[Zach Morris]

128 K/sec isn't that good anyways. When I play my MP3 player through my car's stereo system I can tell right away when a 128K song comes on as opposed to 320K. The 128K song sounds muffled next to a 320K.

 

I played TSL through headphones and did notice some poor quality sounds. Especially when casting heal over the music.

[Ace]

I'm not the only person then who's complaining about the music this game being at a much lower resolution then the music in the first game.

 

Which is a true pitty because the actual score is very nice.

 

I'd expect this from a budget title, but this is supposed to be a Lucas related company that prides itself in its sound quality.

 

When first playing the game and hearing the music in the main menu I swore that a bug was responsible for the muffled sound. I then checked the files, and it wasn't me it was the source files.

 

Maybe we can get a patch with high resolution music and the full ending?

[Aryanne]

one word patch game needs it bad.If for anything just to make it compatible with todays hardware.Which btw im still waiting for my patch OBSIDIAN tick tock tick tock. "

[Ace]

Well I'll probably be sued by Lucasarts for doing this, but I've done up an upsampled version of the Sion theme.

 

128kb, stereo .mp3. The high range has been enhanced, the bass has been enhanced, and some subtle reverb effects are added in to make the instruments sound more natural. Not perfect, since there's only so much you can do to hide the audio artifacts.

 

PM me if you want a copy of it, since I'd rather not risk the wrath of Lucasarts

 

Edit- I tried doing the same with the Exile theme, but converting the file to an .mp3 makes the end part of the track sound harsh. Better than before, but the .wav version I did is up there in the 20 meg sized range though it sounds better.

 

Edit#2- Actually I'm taking back the offer on sending them to other folks, since I'm not pleased with the lack of dynamic range even after all of the tweaking. They sound shallow compared to the KOTOR1 tracks still, mainly because no matter how hard you try you can't really upsample something. *grumbles* I want higher res versions of the recordings! Release the soundtrack... now!

[stoo]

Whether I agree/care or not, this post surely is one of the best I've read in a long, looong time, and for a number of reasons. To promptly vanquis any lingering doubts, I agree with the post.

 

Star Wars is a lot about its soundtrack (just try imagining it without its original ST, but with some mediocre one, and think of what would become of the 'magic'), and the soundtrack element is even stronger in SW games. Ever since Sw games begun to be released, LucasArts realized that spamming the movies' OST over and over wasn't feasible, and had to invent some original, fitting, SW-like tracks to make their games deliver the same feelings the movies do (sadness, peace, epic-ness, rage, passion, struggle, exaltation and so on). And they managed to, with most (all?) games.

 

I think k2 is a good game, taken per se. But, we cannot overlook some facts: it carries a 'heavy' license (Star Wars, anyone), it is the sequel to one of the most acclaimed Sw games in history, it is developed by a team who's always released top-quality gamesm it's been one of the most anticipated games in the last year, it's got a huge fanbase which they were sure would have bought the game blindfolded on its release.

 

These facts given, my rating of k2 really drops deep, very close to the pits where rip-off's lurk, and your post makes it fall even deeper. I mean, why did they have to save on audio quality? Why didn't they release a DVD version (4CD are a real pain in the ***, IMO)? How could they make a sequel which is technically inferior to its predecessor, althoug using the same base technology?

 

I'm sorry if I went somehow OT, my 1.99cents anyways. Stoo.

[Sammael]

I honestly couldn't tell the difference.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Neither could I.

[stoo]

I honestly couldn't tell the difference.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Neither could I.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

Guys, just get some decent headphones (anything priced above 30$ will do). j/k.

 

I can understand you didn't notice the low audio resolution, but the mono output is easily recognizable by anyone who's got both ears in good health (it's really UN-immersive).

[Silverblade]

Frankly, I thought it was all in my mind. I did notice there was someting quite not right about the music, but I attributed it to my headphones. Funny that music from other games sounds OK...

[Sammael]

I honestly couldn't tell the difference.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Neither could I.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

Guys, just get some decent headphones (anything priced above 30$ will do). j/k.

 

I can understand you didn't notice the low audio resolution, but the mono output is easily recognizable by anyone who's got both ears in good health (it's really UN-immersive).

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Dunno. I have fairly decent 4.1 speakers (I paid around $100 for them three years ago), so I am either simply not paying attention to the music (and it's good enough that it isn't distracting me), or there is something wrong with my hearing. There are also lots of dialogues and sound effects that are probably drawing my attention away from the music.

 

I have no clue as to why they sampled the music in such a way, but it's not bothering me in the least.

[markussun]

128 K/sec isn't that good anyways. When I play my MP3 player through my car's stereo system I can tell right away when a 128K song comes on as opposed to 320K. The 128K song sounds muffled next to a 320K.

 

Yes, I can tell the difference, too. In my listening tests (with a very good "monitor") I think 190 kbps at VBR (!) (variable bitrate) for encoding MP3 with a good encoder like LAME v3.90 results in very transparent audio, practically indistinguishable from the original source.

 

Personally, I don't use MP3 for private encoding anymore. I've switched to OGG Vorbis. That superior codec has convinced me that MP3 is outdated.

 

At any rate, I think that 128 kbps is the absolut MINIMUM acceptable encoding quality for MP3 music in games. 190 kbps VBR would be nice, but given that game music plays with many other sound streams concurrently, any encoding artifacts would likely be masked and much less offending. In a game's case I find 128 kbps acceptable.

 

On the other hand, in KOTOR2's case, when a developer offers a built-in music player in their game to give the gamer a chance to listen to the pure music tracks outside the game, one would expect that they realize that even 128 kbps is too little for such a feature.

 

It is apparent that the developers thought of their symphonic music so highly that they put in the extra effort to enable us to enjoy it separately from the game. The music player feature literally screams: "Here, enjoy our great music because we think music is such an important aspect of this game".

 

And then you wake up to the fact that they perverted the music to MONO 10kHz at one of the lowest MP3 bitrates imaginable...

 

It's all schizophrenic to me.

 

Makes you wonder... why didn't Lucasarts instead offer this music player feature as a 1-900 playback service over the telephone line? They could have made some extra profit and the quality and experience wouldn't be much of a difference to what it is now. Now, there's a brilliant idea. "

 

Go to Mark Griskey's website (the composer) to download and listen to a few KOTOR2 music tracks -- in full quality! Only makes you weep more...

 

Anyways, thanks to all of you for the comments so far. Keep this thread going and please stay on-topic.

 

And don't forget to email LucasArts (!) and tell them you want the proper 44kHz *STEREO* music back in the game. It only takes you a minute, but is arguably the best thing you can do if you want to see an effect... because Obsidian is powerless, and I doubt Lucasarts is following this message board.

 

The more people do this, the higher the chances for a fix.

[Meshugger]

Ack, after hearing the tunes "The Sith Lords" and "Darth Sion" at Griskey's homepage....Well, feels like half the game is made by a snakeoil-saleman.

 

Of course Lucasarts will never release the soundtrack at a higher bit-rate, we're enthusiasts afterall, a mousefart in the universe.