I understand what Nolan was trying to do, and I think he acccomplished it very well. Yes, the film is coherent and makes sense in the way you mean. I got it. It's just that the last third of the movie is so... all over the place. Anyhow, I do plan on seeing it again sometime, and I'll probably enjoy it more the second time... though my fiance who loved it did go see it again and said it was much less effective the second time around.
Anyhow, to the movie list you put up... (I didn't list the movies I haven't seen)...
Or Titanic... not a huge fan of this movie, but that has more to do with having lost my son in the year before and being completely freaked out by all the bodies in the water. I actually thought the ending was pretty cool, though.
or Seven... BLECH!
or Alien 3... Saw it and I think I liked it... *shrug*
or Dances With Wolves... Great movie. While it was depressing in some ways, I liked the way it ended.
or Blade Runner... I didn't get this movie. I might like to see it again sometime, but the first time I just thought it was weird.
or Hamlet - ok, now you're just being silly
or The Usual Suspects - Damn, I love this movie
or Citizen Kane - Very interesting movie. I watched it during a film class when I was pregnant, though and I'm not sure I was awake the whole time. I probably need to see it again... lol
or Braveheart - I enjoyed this one too... not sure why I didn't find it so depressing, actually.
or Wag the Dog - enjoyed it
or Fight Club - great movie
or Saving Private Ryan - how is this depressing? It's all about the sacrifice of the many for the one, in juxtaposition with Schindler's List which is the sacrifice of one for many... While I wouldn't watch Schindler's List just because, I do know it's a great film.
I think the difference between most of these and TDK is that I like the way most of these ended. TDK, not so much.