Boeroer

It would do pierce/slash/crush/saw damage. But honestly: a weapon which would do pierce/slash/crush would actually be pretty powerful - without the noobs noticing.

Huh? I thought Curoc's Brand has pierce/burn and not burn/pierce and therefore doesn't work with Scion of Flame? Anyways: why all the implements?

It's basically a wooden club (crush) with sharp stone edges (slash). So slash/crush seems to be plausible. That doesn't say anything about how long it would last in a "real" fight. But if you are concerned that it breaks on usage you shouldn't consider it in the first place. But since items in PoE don't need repair and don't deteriorate at all I would just skip those concerns and concentrate on coolness.

Pretty difficult with official companions though.

Int the beta they had FoD shots with over 1000 damage with arquebuses.

But I can't decide which spells are used - this makes it very quirky. Same with buffing - for example Devotions. Healing works quite well because the trigger is clear, but I can't tell the priest to always use Devotions at the start of the encounter. So maybe I would only take companions which are not spell related. Builds which work quite well with no micro are monks with focus on retaliation (Fire Godlike, Turning Wheel, Lightning Strikes, Blood Testament, Rooting Pain, retaliation gear) and also barbarians with the same approach (Fire Godlike, Blooded, One Stands Alone, Vengeful Defeat, Barbaric Retaliation, retaliation). They need no micro whatsoever and still deal good damage. Maybe Zahua and Mahena would also be good with this approach although they lack Battle Forged. If Long Pain gets casted by AI I would totally go for that because the resulting auto attacks are very powerful and need no additional wounds while working great at range and in melee. Maneha with Frenzy + Bloodlust + Blood Thirst + Hours of St. Rumbalt or Tall Grass can also be valuable in bounties at higher levels. The carnage-CC as passive and works quite well if you're fast enough. Or with a single CC weapon like Cladhaliath... Devil of Caroc is nice as auto-attacker with Godansthunyr or We Toki + Badgradr's Barricade and the Binding Rope. She will get Deathblows a lot because she will deliver the afflictions by herself passively (stun/prone + stuck) and will be sturdy enough with the shield. ToTV will use Deathblows, too. Maybe even Riposte is worthwhile. Applying Deep Wounds via retaliation may also be a good idea as a bonus. Edér with dual wielding or two hander + Sanguine Plate + Swaddling Sheet + Shod-in-Faith (although his INT is only 10) may also be viable. I never use Overbearing Guard but maybe with a two hander like Tidefall it's cool to prevent enemies from running around too much? I would skip everything too squishy. Sagani with Stormcaller for example is nice, but once she gets targeted it's quickly over. Do ciphers cast Mind Control on immune enemies if controlled by AI?

In this video it's explained why obsidian makes sharper edges than metal can: https://youtu.be/2C6_pSEPbO8?t=281 But while OBS is very sharp when chipped porperly it's also very brittle. So if one could solve those issues (infuse with aweseome essence for the win) it could indeed be a very fearsome weapon.

By the way: the Hawaiian/Polynesian (even more like Huana) variant of that is named "Leiomano". It's basically the same weapon, but instead of stones they used shark theeth.

That Multlutlicl (blazing aztech names, I swear ) weapon does slash/crush damage obviously. Could also considered to be a mace or morning star. Depends on the final shape and dimensions I guess. Best idea so far in my opinion. Just needs some backstory why the BIB have it. And another thing: may be that we see those weapons all the time on Huana warriors. Could be that OBS had the same idea and give them sonte weapons with adra, flint and obsidian (I mean in "Deadfire" Archipelago there should be plenty of vulcanos and therefore also obsidian) - then our Mutchupitchulatlprattl wouldn't be so unique anymore. Hm...

Ok - I really don't know how the AI behaves when it comes to cast things like Devotions, Relentless Storm or The Long Pain as soon as possible. It does an ok job with Force of Anguish for example. And I don't know how good AI is with buffing (priest). I didn't use AI since 2.03 or so...

Yes, my MC would also be a chanter with the same setup. I would use Ancient Memory + Beloved Spirits + Veteran's Recovery with both so that the regeneration effects stack nicely, supported by survival (healing bonus) and an item that does the same (Fulvano's Amulett, Belt of Bountiful Healing). The shield would be the solace one with preservation. Kana might want to take Black Sanctuary because of Withdraw. Then it depends how much micromanagement is allowed. For example if it's ok to trigger spells by yourself especially at the start of the encounter or if everything should be handeled by AI. If manual spell casting from time to time is ok I'd take Hiravias with a non-spiritshifting "tanky" build, using the storm spells, Form of the Delemgan and also Moonwell and stuff. I would aim for Little Savior. Same with durance for Devotions and so on. Pallegina for Sacred Immolation and the Outworn Buckler. And Zahua with the Long Pain (can't say if it gets cast by AI) or Sagani with Stormcaller or Aloth with Blast (non-squishy builds) Grieving Mother with Mindweb would be desirable but I think ciphers are just too much micro. If Hiravias is too much micro because of casting I would take Edér with Godansthunyr + Badgradr's Barricade or Devil of Caroc with the same setup or Maneha with the same setup (aiming for Dragon's Maw perhaps).

Kana Rua with Dragon Thrashed for starters.

Well from lvl 13 on a paladin can be a DPS monster due to Sacred Immolation. Before that it's all about damage per hit, not per second (dps). Good alpha strikes can turn difficult encounters into easy ones, that's why they are so effective - and paladins can do that job very well. But when looking a sustained DPS they just lack special abilities or skills besides Sacred Immolation. But since you can develop very impressive alpha strike capabilities without gimping the support abilities too much a paladin can be a great alpha/support hybrid character.

Right. Everything that gets infused with essence in PoE gains some special properties anyways. PoE's Azureth's Stiletto (the wooden stiletto you mentioned) is a backer item by the way. Cladhaliath has a core of adra and doesn't break. Argwe's Adra... Adra Animats... there are enough examples that magic and animancy can prevent shattering of otherwise brittle objects.

Looks good. If you keep recovery as short as possible (invocations cause recovery and pause chanting) you can paralyze-lock with Killers Froze Stiff pretty early (needs crits first, then later also works with hits). Most enemies will not have shrugged off the effect when you cast it again. However, in easy fights all enemies might be dead before the first use of Killers is ready. Chanter problems... that's why doing something good with the bow or arbalest is nice, too. With Sure Handed Ila and Outlander's Frenzy you can shoot very quickly until Killers is ready. Cloudpiercer could also be very nice because rending + speed is a good thing. But because of stunning I think Borresaine is the better bow. But Hold-Wall is fun, too. With Gunner, high Dex and Ila the reload isn't that long anymore and because of the speed enchantment it has nearly 0 recovery early on (combined with Ila + Outlander's).

Blunderbuss + Carow Golan led to ridiculous focus gain. Same with multi-retaliation. edit: I meant before the "nerf".

You definitely never build a wolf with Predator's Sense, Vicious and Merciless Companion and used Persistence...

This totally fits the Huana/Archipelago theme. Very nice!

"Bastard's Grip" - a severed golem's clenched fist, made of obsidian, that is mounted on a rod and looks like a mace. However, on critical hits the hand opens and chokes the enemy, causing the "unconcious" affliction for a short time. "Misborn's Slap" - same, but x% chance that the hand opens and hits a second time on the same attack with a backhand stroke - or doing crush/slash instead of only crush "Black Flak" - a hand mortar or blunderbuss with x% chance of casting Smoke Bomb "Chimaera" - a black armor with two additional arms that is essentially a golem, giving you two additional weapon sets. Or a long tail that gives you Knockdown 1/encounter or a scorpion's tail that gives you Envenomed Strike or drake wings which let you do Dragon Leap or <insert fancy idea here>

I'm really puzzling my head over the "bastard" part of that bastard sword. I mean usually you could wield such a sword with either two hands or one hand. I don't know if OBS has planned such features in POE2 anyways, but it would be cool if we could come up with some simple solution how to make that bastard sword usable with either one or two hands. I can't think of any though...

Don't know yet if ths is the right spot or if the original BIB thread is better since it's pinned already...?

Push push! Now that the BIBs crew got funded this has to happen NEXT! Keep the ideas coming! Please...

I would also like something like "Black Bile" because it relates to PoE1 (Aloth's questline) as well as to Black Isle.

Now let's get that item into the game! Suggestions for kind of item and name? - cat o'nine tails (flail): "Squid" - bastard sword (great sword or sword): "The Mongrel" or hey! A ledger (trinket) with some nice passive property - or a 1/rest summon of a random BIB crewmember - with all the "victims" of the BIBs in it. Hahaha... sneaking in through the backdoor. Stuff like that? Edit: Wow - I got ninja'd so hard...

If Maegfolc Skull is the best helmet or not strongly depends on your class and build. One could say that Munacra Arret is stronger or the Executioner's Hood, the Tempered Helm or even the Crossed Patch (when you're a ranger using Powder Burns). But it's true that Silver Tide is strong - especially because you'll have it from lvl 1 on and it's scaling. Even if you'd have helmets in mind that are way stringer than Maegfolc and stuff, you'll never get them at lvl 1 (and their properties wouldn't scale with level). This is also true for Battle Forged, but it starts weaker than Silver Tide and the trigger "50% endurace" also prevents it from being too useful for builds who have mediocre or low health pools.