Do you think it is a good idea to have a "secret police force"? By that I am encompassing all the security and counter-intelligence forces, like the CIA, FBI, MI5/6, KGB/FSB, Mossad, etc.
Now, assuming that our healthy democracy needs a scret service, what would you:
want them to be able to do?
not want them to be able to do?
For example, would it be okay to allow them to act "above the law", as long as they maintain everybody else's compliance with the laws?
Should there be penalties for the members of the force, e.g. they would not be permited to own anything (the state would provide for all their needs) to minimise personal gain from the system?
QVIS CVSTODIET IPSOS CVSTODES?
Most importantly, who would police these police? Another body? (Who polices them? etc)
As oxymoronic as it is, I don't think it is possible for a free society to exist without such a conceit ... but does it follow that the freer the society, the more powerful the secret police (and the more controlled they must be)?