-
Posts
5012 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
4
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Blogs
Everything posted by Gorgon
-
It is commonly represented as an 'either-or' scenario, either the bombs were dropped on two population centers or there would have to be a full scale invasion. The fact is, the Japanese posed no significant threat to anyone in their battered state. Their fleets destroyed and all sigificant holdouts in the Pacific taken. Trueman wanted the troops home before christmas, and here was a much appreciated chance to get the war overwith. The commonly accepted idea that that this final, perhaps unnecessary, act of destruction saved milions is equal parts guesswork and wishful thinking. Yes, the invasion would have been extremely costly on both sides, but we are assuming too much here. None of the powers involved in WW2 can be said to be without their own stories of mass killings of civilians, this is all common knowledge, and while the outcome still hung in the balance none would have hesitated to use new super weapons. When the bombs were dropped we were in the closing act, where no question remained who would be the victors. The political message of Hiroshima and Nakasaki was unmistakable though, it brough into existance the worlds first superpower.
-
Training in flashy sounding acronyms is mandatory in officer school.
-
" Don't get me wrong, the events of August 1945 are in no way, shape, or form a high point in American history. Unforunately, the decision to use the bomb was one that was hoisted upon the US by the Japanese. Attempts were made to end the war without the kind of wholesale loss of life that was witnessed those two days. As was mentioned before, anyone who thinks that the Japanese were not prepared to fight to the bitter end need only look at the fact that it took TWO bombs and several days for them to finally surrender." The US could have chosen another less densely populated target, but, they wanted effect. They didn't warn them because they wanted to make sure the bombers had a clear path. There were alternatives though that did not necessarily include the invasion of mainland Japan. Two bombs could have been dropped at minor sites. One prominent disident was Eisenhower. Churchil and Trueman had both comitted fully to the motto of 'unconditional surrender', to the point where no other kind of surrender would be considered, even if one had existed that would have shortened the war. This was a time and a war where the lives of civilians meant very little on both sides though, the only thing about this that really irks me is the idea that those bombs saved milions of lives, there is no evidence for it, other than a comparison of casualty rates in the even of an invasion. That is not fact, it's conjecture, and it's a bit too convenient.
-
Won't be long now before some American comes along and tells us all what an icredible act of mercy the bombings were, and how many million lives they saved.
-
These things might work against a fortified position, or even ambushing near a roadside, but they are pretty useless in a crowded city. How long do you think it would take before one got stolen and sold for parts.
-
The US seems to be going through another one of those phases were the word '****' is not allowed to be used in the more colloquial Chris Rock/Richard Pryer sense. I maintain that the word is not always racist, and not in this instance anyway.
-
Doesen't sound racist, unless the owner of the car is black that is
-
Never liked his movies that much.
-
What did you do, gank someone for his gold chains ?
-
Why would I want to run a mile, whos chasing me ?
-
Tough crowd
-
Humans should live to be around 260, that would be enough time to suck in the experience without being rushed.
-
Man guilty of abducting mom, feeding daughter to alligators
Gorgon replied to Guard Dog's topic in Way Off-Topic
I have moderated my position on capital punishment. A little. But this guy attempted to murder somone earlier in his life and was sentenced to 30 years in prision. He was let out early and what was the first thing he did? Murder someone. It seems if the prisons are just going to let these vermin go, excecuting them is the only way to keep us safe. I'll abandon my support for capital punishment the day the US adopts truth in sentencing laws. If you draw a 30 year sentence, you spend 30 years in prison. If you get life, you leave the prision in a body bag. Plus US prisions are far too nice. They have air conditioning, cable TV, libraries, etc. If they were more like the one in The Count of Monte Cristo then I would say we don't need the death penalty. You can argue that capital punishment is not effective but I do not see how. This guy got a 30 year sentence and murdered someone later. If he is exceuted for this he will not be killing anyone else will he? It is possible to sentence someone to life without parole, that means they will not be eligable to come before the parole board. Barring pardon, they are there for the duration. -
Man guilty of abducting mom, feeding daughter to alligators
Gorgon replied to Guard Dog's topic in Way Off-Topic
Here we go again arguing for the death penalty using one of these spectacular headline acts of violence. It deosen't become any more intelligent with repetition. Legistation affecting everyone and emotional and shock appeal headlines do not mix. -
They assassinated him years ago, but, it would be detrimental to strategic goals to release the information.
-
Evolution, creation or something else?
Gorgon replied to OverPowered Godzilla (OPG)'s topic in Way Off-Topic
**** I stepped on my glasses, again. Now I can't see well enough to write -
Evolution, creation or something else?
Gorgon replied to OverPowered Godzilla (OPG)'s topic in Way Off-Topic
I guess it's the glass being half full kinda thing, looking around at the world and going 'wow how amazing, god must have created that'. Thats fine and all, but it's not an actual argument, it's emotion. -
Man guilty of abducting mom, feeding daughter to alligators
Gorgon replied to Guard Dog's topic in Way Off-Topic
**** ? -
Evolution, creation or something else?
Gorgon replied to OverPowered Godzilla (OPG)'s topic in Way Off-Topic
The only reason this discussion even exists is as a kindness to the biblical screwballs. Had it been anything other than established religion proposing that the world was created mere thousands of years ago, ruling out dinosaurs among other things, no one would ever have wasted their breath discussing it. -
Simpsons unpopular among Pagans, threaten to make it rain
Gorgon replied to Nick_i_am's topic in Way Off-Topic
Paganism has a lot of flavor, I mean, human sacrifice, giant wickermen barbecues. The hippies gave it a bad name, but that ain't the fault of the religion. Naturalistic religions aren't more ridiculous than believing god made Adam out of one of his ribs, while were on the subject of BBQ -
Simpsons unpopular among Pagans, threaten to make it rain
Gorgon replied to Nick_i_am's topic in Way Off-Topic
The ancient chalk drawing has a boner. I can't seem to summon any indignation. -
It's like capitalism gone wrong No, it's Capitalism undiluted and unregulated. Ironically exactly what the whole concept of Comunism is supposed to be the cure for.
-
This looks like a lot of work, what am i getting paid exactly ?
-
Nah, they're both elitist. The rabble doesen't have any say whatsoever. At one point, when they came to power the rabble helped put them there, after that they could tow the line or wind up in the death camps/gulags.
-
Every year the Nazis band together for the Rudolph Hess march, I think he was the rather slow witted right hand of Hitler, and every year the extreme left wingers show up to throw bricks at them. It's a blast to watch, unless it's were you live.