I agree that there is no sense being negative, because it won't really make a difference.
At the same time, I can understand if people are disappointed about the possibility of it resulting in a change of direction for Bioware. If games like XCOM and Quest for Glory were the ones that got someone hooked on gaming, then unfortunately the industry right now is a bit less than "awesome" for them. But like you said Hurlshot, being jaded towards the people that ARE enjoying the gaming industry the way it is doesn't accomplish anything. I'm sure many of those people wouldn't be too interested if adventure games and RPGs were the big thing.
Well, given how little RPGs are actually on the market, I'd almost think people would want "cookie cutter RPGs reusing engines." Wouldn't an RPG fan rather some IWD type games between the Baldur's Gates, rather than waiting for a long time between games?