Hello to all GoT fans here...just watched episode 01 and 02 the other day and I'm compelled to say a thing or two. Having read all the books after season 01 ended last year I initially wanted to watch this new season without doing a critical comparison between the show and the books. But no matter how much I tried I couldn't help myself not to view the series through the prism of what I remember from the books. Before giving any criticism of the first two episodes one has to bear in mind that it's a very difficult, if not an impossible job to capture the essence of the story with high quality of the book A clash of Kings in just 10 episodes. That's actually the first thing I disagree with the HBO management, this season should of had at least 15 episodes in order to tell the story as it should be in my opinion. As a result any book reader that's gonna judge this series more thoroughly based on the book will be less impressed, vice versa. What people should understand is that this HBO series is an adaptation of the G.R.R. Martin's books, not a direct ecranization ( or what's the right word for it in English) of the piece which would require such an investment that no production company has or would be willing to make. So from the cost-benefit point of view it's pretty normal that each book be a different season for itself with limited numbers of episodes and no matter what, in the end there's always gonna be people satisfied and unsatisfied with show.
Back to the actual episodes...the first one was just a prologue, a set-up for the new season continuing the story of the knows characters where they left behind in the last season and introducing new ones. I myself think that this episode should of been a double one covering the same time length of the story. Why? Well, in 'just' 55 min a lot and too much was shown in too little time causing an effect, as a reader of the books, of moments where I was going: What? When? Already? How? I guess that's the result of unconsciously comparing the things I saw with the things I remember from the book. But putting that a side, various characters were shown a bit too little, too quickly, it felt like a long trailer for me, not the actual episode. On the other hand, maybe those that haven't read the book felt differently.
Looking at the new characters in season 2 the actor playing Davos is a total score capturing the very being of the character without having to say anything. Craster isn't much significant for the whole story, but I pictured him even more brutal and hideous regarding his looks and behavior. Stannis in my opinion isn't convincing, the actor in question doesn't radiate that unemotional, stone hard, resolved, conservative and authoritative figure like he is in the book in my opinion. This is Stannis. When it comes to Kings Landing and the new location for filming scenes in the capital it's a little funny to me to get accustomed to the idea of Dubrovnik being Kings Landing when I recognize the city in the show as I live about 200km from it. But the city itself is an excellent place for shooting GoT as the old center still has kilometers of walls and old forts standing. The problem for me is that it doesn't do justice for the large areas inside the royal castle in the Kings Landing, in the book and season 1 they are vast and royal. In Dubrovnik you don't have such areas to shoot those kind of pictures so in these two episodes everything feels a little bit to small and claustrophobic for me. I hope things will somehow be somewhat different in the episodes to come.
So now for the things that didn't workout so well for me is the fact that HBO yet again didn't miss the opportunity to make even Game of Thrones a sort of soft porn series. The sex scene that bothered me the most was the one between (*spoiler alert for those that didn't watch episode 02*) Melissandre and Stannis. Sex by itself is insignificant but it is a total misinterpretation of his character. Stannis is bold, decisive, old school, by the book kind of person, the one that always follows the rules to point of obsession. Now he looks as a week minded typical man that can't keep his **** in his shorts for 2.7 seconds. Sure he abandoned the old Gods, but he was never a religious nut as a honor and principle one. He accepted the Lord of the Light mostly because his wife persuaded him and he saw a mean of helping him get the crown. Also, in the book in question, there are indications the two of them maybe having something, but nothing was directly said about it and it is based only on their close cooperation. Well there is another reason perhaps why they put this scene and that is (*book spoiler alert*) to show how the wraith that killed Renly came to life. Although I still think it wasn't very necessary and it could of been shown more discretely like the very indications in the book that something was going on between them in the first place. This way, for a viewer that didn't read the book, I think they failed to picture Stannis to the audience as he really is.
But ok, I can live with that. And I repeat, I'm not a person that expects that everything in the book has to be shown in the series, but personally, those scenes that are done correctly by the book are mostly those that are the best ones. (*would be better not to read the following if you haven't seen episode 02*) The thing that bothers me the most is the added scenes, not because they introduced them, but because most of them look to me pointless and done very clumsy. Like some kind of futile attempts of personal interpretation of G.R.R. Martin's book by the screenwriters rather then good scenes that successfully fit in the broader picture. For an example the character of Ros Even. WTF is that chick even doing in the show? What's her purpose and significance other then the fact she has great boobs and looks attractive? If you watched episode 02 I ask you what's the point of all those sex scenes in the brothel other then to be a purpose for itself. Sure there are explicit scenes in the book, but they are totally secondary and in the series a viewer gets the idea it's one of the most important parts of the story. It's not. It looks just a cheap attempt by HBO to get the viewers count up, really pathetic. Then the slapping of Joffrey by Cersei, Cersei threatening Littlefinger with execution, what's the point of those scenes? To show a great amount of story in the book done otherwise through dialog and intrigue through these symbolic scenes? And even if they represent that they are totally inadequate and illogical because that feud between Littlefinger and Cersei is made up and doesn't hold ground. To that point Baelish is a clear ally of the house Lannister and the one that helped take out Ned Stark, there's nothing in the book A clash of Kings that says about such confrontation. And the slap is made up also and serves what purpose? To continue with Daenerys sending that member of her expedition to scout around, what's with that flirting? Just unnecessary, I thought she was gonna say: Oh **** of my Khalasar and that they were gonna do it behind the stones. Repeating for the tenth time, I don't mind the undogmatic storytelling and the new scenes that aren't in the book. But I don't mind them when they are done cleverly and with a good and precise reason, not when they are vague, pointless and actually unnecessary which some of these things I mentioned really are in my opinion. Still, I love this show and just hope things are gonna be better.