TOP 25 PC games of all time by IGN

[Purkake]

It's tough seeing, yet again, Bubble Shooter left out in the cold. There's a conspiracy against free flash games, and it's ugly.

 

Like the games?

 

*ba dum dish*

[Monte Carlo]

Bubble Shooter's art direction is perfectly executed, some big-budget efforts of late would do well to be half as good.

[Purkake]

Bubble Shooter's art direction is perfectly executed, some big-budget efforts of late would do well to be half as good.

 

Sorry, when I think of flash games, I think of ~12 year olds playing Adventure Quest in the computer lab.

 

I liked Radical Aces and the same developer's racing game.

[Aram]

These "Top #" lists are kind of a dumb concept--they're always someone's opinion and it never matches anyone else's. Not to mention that most of them are so popular we've already played them, so what are we really learning?

 

A better concept would be "# Games you need to play before you die" or something. Then you can put some really obscure **** in there, not because it was the most popular or got the highest review scores, but because it's actually a unique experience and everyone should give it a chance. Games like The Last Express and Dark Eye that even when new were largely overlooked.

 

Maybe we ought to try to write up a list like that--sort of a Criterion collection for vidjagames.

Edited August 10, 2009 by Aram

[Calax]

Having played most of those games I gotta say, I agree with what they're saying. admittedly I might choose CivII over IV. admittedly their grading scale seemed to value quality AND changing of the paradigm. Rather than just quality.

 

I did like mech 2 and tie fighter being high on the list, people often forget mech 2, and tiefighter is more often unappreciated.

[Oner]

No Oni or Masters of Orion sadly.

[RPGmasterBoo]

Oni was cool, but deeply flawed no?

[Purkake]

Oni was cool, but deeply flawed no?

 

Something about an anime girl shooting things with really ugly graphics?

 

I think I played the demo, i remember blue, lots of blue.

Edited August 10, 2009 by Purkake

[Oner]

Oni was cool, but deeply flawed no?

Graphics were kinda ugly but a: we don't care about that, b: had at least pretty colors.

The combat system had a few small problems - namely some moves required almost the same buttons to execute, which sometimes led to..complications. Nothing serious though.

The AI was superb for it's time, enemies manouvered, picked up dropped weapons(!), etc.

Oh yeah, cutscenes didn't have moving mouths, portraits were shown instead. Horrible.

 

@Purkake: Of course you remember ****ing blue, that was the main characters "uniform" color.

Edited August 10, 2009 by Oner

[Majek]

Nice list and i certainly agree on the top 2.

[Purkake]

@Purkake: Of course you remember ****ing blue, that was the main characters "uniform" color.

 

Nope, was there perhaps a "virtual" tutorial room? If not then it must have been the menus and maybe the effects(looking at screens, most of them are blueish).

[Oner]

@Purkake: Of course you remember ****ing blue, that was the main characters "uniform" color.

 

Nope, was there perhaps a "virtual" tutorial room? If not then it must have been the menus and maybe the effects(looking at screens, most of them are blueish).

The menu and clothes mostly, the other two things not particularly.

[Purkake]

@Purkake: Of course you remember ****ing blue, that was the main characters "uniform" color.

 

Nope, was there perhaps a "virtual" tutorial room? If not then it must have been the menus and maybe the effects(looking at screens, most of them are blueish).

The menu and clothes mostly, the other two things not particularly.

 

Maybe I'm crazy. It was like 10 years ago too.

[Deadly_Nightshade]

Hummm.... That's an ok list... Not great but not too bad, although Crysis should have never been on there.

[Humodour]

These "Top #" lists are kind of a dumb concept--they're always someone's opinion and it never matches anyone else's. Not to mention that most of them are so popular we've already played them, so what are we really learning?

 

A better concept would be "# Games you need to play before you die" or something. Then you can put some really obscure **** in there, not because it was the most popular or got the highest review scores, but because it's actually a unique experience and everyone should give it a chance. Games like The Last Express and Dark Eye that even when new were largely overlooked.

 

Maybe we ought to try to write up a list like that--sort of a Criterion collection for vidjagames.

 

Please do it.

[Oner]

Please do it.

Already did, slowpoke.

http://forums.obsidian.net/index.php?showt...=52914&st=0

Edited August 10, 2009 by Oner

[Magnum Opus]

Have never really looked at "strategy games" before, but have seen Civ IV Gold in the stores a lot recently, and I've been wondering whether or not I should give the game a looksee.

 

List seems to suggest I should, at any rate.

[Rostere]

I can see no Torment in that list, and no Thief either. This list thing is really kinda stupid

[Malcador]

I'd have liked to see Tribes take BF1942's spot. But other than that, agree with most of them being on there (sort of wished for TA to be on there).

[Gorth]

...or Masters of Orion sadly.

That list just failed any and all saving throws

 

Checking the list, I've played the following:

 

Grim Fandango

Fallout

Sid Meier's Pirates!

Battlefield 1942

Baldur's Gate II: Shadows of Amn

Star Wars TIE Fighter

 

(I've played X-Com and Sim City too, but not on PC)

 

I guess it is pretty pointless trying to create a list that mixes such a variety of genres.