Nobody loves Disciple :(

[Sikon 0]

Can you tell me why nobody on this board seems to like Disciple, and everyone wants to picture him as an idiot, a clown or a gay?

[KOTORFanactic 0]

Er...

 

Because it's funny. :D (w00t)

[Chyogte 0]

'Cause he's gay, he's screaming like a girl, he's for no use, and he's just an irritating organic meatbag...

[JediNaava 0]

Ummm.. Actually I LIKE disciple. I think he's a great character. (No don't laugh or throw rotten fruit), but the fact of the matter is I'm attracted to 'nice guys.'

 

No, I don't think he's gay. Di is just a friendly dedicated guy. Frankly, I'm really glad to see more than one option for staight women.

 

So yeah, I'm a Di fan. Atton has his attractions too... But Di is number 1 for me.

 

Naava

[Sikon 0]

And he's not for no use, I found him to be a perfect tank (if you don't play DS and have Hanharr, of course), somewhat compensating for your party's overall lack of tough characters. He's also the easiest one to convert to a Jedi.

[Darkside 0]

I really like Mical as he was intended; he seems really neat on paper. It's the finished product that's so easy to laugh at. I mean, seriously, don't they have orthodontists on Dantooine?

[Calax 625]

he's disliked because he's so Holyer than thou. Also his voice just grates on me. and his personality is just plain screwy

[jodo kast 5 0]

Disciple was as ugly as sin, if my dog had a face like that I'd shave it's ass and teach it to walk backwards.

[Cloris 0]

Can you tell me why nobody on this board seems to like Disciple, and everyone wants to picture him as an idiot, a clown or a gay?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

I like him, and he's a really useful character. I posted about that before, but it's been a while. Mical's got 'mad skillz,' for one, and is one of the only people from the PC's past that can be counted on to help.

 

Not only is he a tank, but he can heal you, recover your force points, AND serve as a lab station. Nevermind that he's the only one that figures out what the hell is going on (even if Kreia makes him forget)!

 

I like Atton, too, but he's just not as handy.

 

It's not Disciple's fault his teeth are too big for his chin! :D

 

Cloris

[Silvershadow 0]

I like Atton, too, but he's just not as handy.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I'm not sure why that made me laugh. Disciple must feel so... used!

 

So to sum things up:

 

Disciple: useful and nice

Atton: not as useful, but snarky and hot ()

 

I actually hated Disciple for my first two or three games... but then I warmed up to him and started to really appreciate him. Like I said in the romance thread, he's just misunderstood (and needs dental surgery).

[Blarghagh 4,870]

Ummm.. Actually I LIKE disciple. I think he's a great character. (No don't laugh or throw rotten fruit), but the fact of the matter is I'm attracted to 'nice guys.'

 

I didn't think girls like you even existed! Well, I've never met one, anyway.

[Weaponmaster303 0]

Ive never played female pc how does disciple figure out what kreia is doing?Is there some cutscene I might actually have to play female pc to see unless somebody tells me.I hate not having handmaiden in my team.

[Gabrielle 1]

I caught Disciple hitting on Hanharr.

[RealTalk 0]

imo he adds more to the story then handmaiden does, i never understood why people hate on him also

[Darkside 0]

imo he adds more to the story then handmaiden does, i never understood why people hate on him also

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

I couldn't stand the Handmaiden. "I'm sad because I can't date the cute guy I like without getting in trouble. Oh screw the promise I made, I want cute boyfriend NOW!!! *throws tantrum*" Maybe that's not her whole story, but at that point I was too bored with her to care about the rest.

[SteveThaiBinh 1]

"You have left me an opening!!"

[Gabrielle 1]

"You have left me an opening!!"

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

He said that when Atton was bent over picking up the soap from the floor.

[LadyCrimson 4,100]

I've loved Di pretty much since I started coming here. He did annoy me for about the first 10 hours or so but after that he grew on me in leaps and bounds so....now....*shrug

 

I understand why he's made fun of tho... heh

[jodo kast 5 0]

"You have left me an opening!!"

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

He said that when Atton was bent over picking up the soap from the floor.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

hehehehe (w00t)

[darth spock 0]

I never really liked Disciple because he seemed too martyr-Hercules-sacrifice-all-cliche-hero that every girl is suppoesd to love. But when you put up a messed up scoundrel guy in there, lots of people like him better. Thus, in simplistic math (!!!)...

 

Atton > Disciple

 

...IMO.

 

I remember wishing I went to Dantooine last in my very first playthrough as a female. <_<

[jodo kast 5 0]

I remember wishing I went to Dantooine last in my very first playthrough as a female.  <_<

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

i remember wishing that Disciple will die in the Atton vs Disciple cutscene

[darth spock 0]

I remember wishing I went to Dantooine last in my very first playthrough as a female.  <_<

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

i remember wishing that Disciple will die in the Atton vs Disciple cutscene

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

 

Now that would've been cut... except I would've gone through the process of learning to mod just to add that back in.

[GhostofAnakin 1,183]

The Disciple was pretty good as a character. The only reason I'm not too high on him is because you have to play as a female PC to get him in your party and I'm not partial to doing that. <_<

[ncr 0]

I liked the contrast between Disciple's optimism and Atton's fatalism. Sure Disciple is annoying, but Atton can be too.

[GhostofAnakin 1,183]

I liked the contrast between Disciple's optimism and Atton's fatalism.  Sure Disciple is annoying, but Atton can be too.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

As a DSer, you should have been given the option to turn them on each other at a specific moment.