Dont think it about Nurab not liking redeemed characters, but this post is about judging top 10 jedi.
So one having top place should represent the jedi ideals and the perfect jedi.
Luke accomplised more than most of the other jedi's did, without astraying from the ideals or foundations, of the jedi's.
<{POST_SNAPBACK}>
But Luke wasn't a "regular" Jedi, like the Jedi in the Old Republic, so you can't compare him with the rest. Luke never got in to the whole celibacy (sp?) thing, for example, and there are more things in which he differs from the other Jedi.