heh, doesn't that kind of kill the role playing?
I'm not against it, but it would seem like those anal guys around wouldn't like this.
Yes, some of the "anal" guys around would certainly diss the idea, because they somehow think role-playing is only possible with a blank-slate character. I do not share their views.
However, my idea is no more imposing on the protagonist than the idea that he starts out as a Republic soldier in KotOR. Instead, he simply starts off working for the Sith and has an option to turn to the Light Side during the game.
Yes, this idea is more theoretical and aimed at future games than it is at KotOR2.