I was mesmerized.
The first half was amazing. Lee's testimony touched at pretty much every little gripe I had with the show, except the love triangle thing.
It felt like this is the kind of balls-to-the-walls honesty we need in our justice systems.
Romo's exit was a bit too "Usual Suspectish" but still pretty cool. I wish they had introduced this character earlier.
The song... well I don't know what to think about that. First I figure it gives an indication as to the age of human civilization on Earth in the show, which would be current day(40 years of war with Cylons, AATWT was written in the late 60's, early 70's).
I also find that AATWT being an Earth song takes a big Science Fiction chunk out of the show. Like hearing a Black Sabbath song during LotR would take away some of the fantasy. Wierd.
I'm not convinced The 4 are Cylons. I'm convinced Roslin is The #1.
And I won't talk about the last minute of this episode right now(PM me if you want to know)... Maybe in a few days.
10/10 - Compared with the rest of Season 3
8/10 - Compared to the rest of the series