I'm not a major Star Trek fan so I didn't mind it was a terrible Star Trek film, since Star Trek is all about Utopias and ethical dillemas and that's boooooring. Okay, I'm totally exaggerating this, I enjoy Star Trek but like you I'm not a Trekkie and I enjoyed the reboot as a cool action flick (even though I'll totally make fun of the lens flares). I have no problems with J.J. and I think he'll pull off a decent Star Wars. I think his track record is pretty good, I enjoyed M:I 3, Star Trek and Super 8 though I hated the Star Trek sequel, that was because the script was awful.