Even though I don't think the storytelling is sloppy, I must agree with the former statement. K2, while a great game, doesn't feel as SW as it should. Perhaps it's the focus on morality in a setting in which good and evil should be well defined, perhaps it's the lack of SW-ish locations or the twisting of the present (and K1's!) plot to reflect some hidden "True Sith" conspiracy.
I think it's been proven that OE could rewrite the CRPG book given enough time and freedom to work in their own projects, and I really hope they get the chance to do it, but K2's is not the best example of a typical SW plot.