No.
Yes.
In Mass Effect 2 if you removed all the RPG dialogue and turned it into a Gears of War cover shooter, it would still be a decent experience. Remove the dialogue and RPG elements of DA 2 and turn it into a God of War action game, which seems to be the route they were taking, and you have gaming hell.
Still doesn't compute. I, of course, played the PC version, which played just as well as DAO apart from the retarded camera. Dumbed down just seems to be a general term for whatever the person using it doesn't like. Hell, a 1:1 comparison of friendly fireless DAO and DA2 tells me that simply the lack of an instawin button (*cough* storm of the century *cough*) makes DA2 miles "smarter"
Sure, the lack of auto attack in the original console release sucked, but I don't see too many games judged simply based on their initial release, certainly not when the bug has been patched within a month, and certainly not on this forum.