I agree, there are a few gems, but -as you acknowledged- most games made recently are not worth the discs they're burned on. As for the "Baldur's Gate II is the best RPG" argument, I really don't care; I was not addressing that particular claim, or your rebuttal, but instead was making a general statement. However, if you seek my opinion, I would say that while it, BG2, was certainly a great game and continues to be a classic, it might not be the best role-playing game ever created.