Jump to content

Welcome to Obsidian Forum Community
Register now to gain access to all of our features. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to create topics, post replies to existing threads, give reputation to your fellow members, get your own private messenger, post status updates, manage your profile and so much more. If you already have an account, login here - otherwise create an account for free today!
Photo

Can you lose companion for siding a faction?


  • Please log in to reply
79 replies to this topic

#21
E.RedMark

E.RedMark

    (6) Magician

  • Members
  • 672 posts

Which path leads to not losing any companions?

I haven't gotten far yet but is there a faction choice that's neutral, as in you don't lose any companions?

I was told you could go the solo route and not side with anyone . But siding with the pirate (principale) , nobody leave you . 



#22
mjn693

mjn693

    (1) Prestidigitator

  • Members
  • 12 posts

You can lose Pallegina quite early in game during the feuding families quest. 



#23
Gary1986

Gary1986

    (5) Thaumaturgist

  • Members
  • 508 posts
  • Deadfire Backer
  • Fig Backer

Which path leads to not losing any companions?

I haven't gotten far yet but is there a faction choice that's neutral, as in you don't lose any companions?

I was told you could go the solo route and not side with anyone . But siding with the pirate (principale) , nobody leave you .

Could you let me know what part of the game this choice appears at to go solo and not side with anybody? Also is this an official route?

Also is siding with the principale route a second route for nobody to leave you?

When do a these choices appear so that I don't mess up? Are there clear indicators?

Cheers

#24
E.RedMark

E.RedMark

    (6) Magician

  • Members
  • 672 posts

 

 

Which path leads to not losing any companions?

I haven't gotten far yet but is there a faction choice that's neutral, as in you don't lose any companions?

I was told you could go the solo route and not side with anyone . But siding with the pirate (principale) , nobody leave you .

Could you let me know what part of the game this choice appears at to go solo and not side with anybody? Also is this an official route?

Also is siding with the principale route a second route for nobody to leave you?

When do a these choices appear so that I don't mess up? Are there clear indicators?

Cheers

 

I can't tell you which route is the solo , since I haven't found it myself . I was doing the principal quest and end up stuck with them and no way to say 'NO THANX! BYE!' . You can say NO to the Valliant when they ask you . Dunno about the Huana and the 3rd faction . 

 

It's late in the game though . Just be careful and SAVE alot . 

 

When I went to the Valliant , they tell you 'It's time to choose' same with rauatia . That is the indicator . 

 

Principale homewhever , they just went 'Let's finish this quest Ahoy!' and before I could say anything we were in buziness ...



#25
Gary1986

Gary1986

    (5) Thaumaturgist

  • Members
  • 508 posts
  • Deadfire Backer
  • Fig Backer

Which path leads to not losing any companions?

I haven't gotten far yet but is there a faction choice that's neutral, as in you don't lose any companions?

I was told you could go the solo route and not side with anyone . But siding with the pirate (principale) , nobody leave you .
Could you let me know what part of the game this choice appears at to go solo and not side with anybody? Also is this an official route?

Also is siding with the principale route a second route for nobody to leave you?

When do a these choices appear so that I don't mess up? Are there clear indicators?

Cheers
I can't tell you which route is the solo , since I haven't found it myself . I was doing the principal quest and end up stuck with them and no way to say 'NO THANX! BYE!' . You can say NO to the Valliant when they ask you . Dunno about the Huana and the 3rd faction .

It's late in the game though . Just be careful and SAVE alot .

When I went to the Valliant , they tell you 'It's time to choose' same with rauatia . That is the indicator .

Principale homewhever , they just went 'Let's finish this quest Ahoy!' and before I could say anything we were in buziness ...

So how many factions are there, and which characters leave you during what faction quest line?

What act/chapter does all this happen in?

#26
E.RedMark

E.RedMark

    (6) Magician

  • Members
  • 672 posts

 

 

 

 

Which path leads to not losing any companions?

I haven't gotten far yet but is there a faction choice that's neutral, as in you don't lose any companions?

I was told you could go the solo route and not side with anyone . But siding with the pirate (principale) , nobody leave you .
Could you let me know what part of the game this choice appears at to go solo and not side with anybody? Also is this an official route?

Also is siding with the principale route a second route for nobody to leave you?

When do a these choices appear so that I don't mess up? Are there clear indicators?

Cheers
I can't tell you which route is the solo , since I haven't found it myself . I was doing the principal quest and end up stuck with them and no way to say 'NO THANX! BYE!' . You can say NO to the Valliant when they ask you . Dunno about the Huana and the 3rd faction .

It's late in the game though . Just be careful and SAVE alot .

When I went to the Valliant , they tell you 'It's time to choose' same with rauatia . That is the indicator .

Principale homewhever , they just went 'Let's finish this quest Ahoy!' and before I could say anything we were in buziness ...

So how many factions are there, and which characters leave you during what faction quest line?

What act/chapter does all this happen in?

 

act and chapter? 

 

There is no chapter 1 , chapter 2...or anything . 

 

There are : The Principal (Pirates) 

- The Valian (Think greedy corporation)

- the Reauta (really have a hard time spelling their names) . 

- And the Native .(with a queen) . 

 

Maia belong to the Reauta . Tekehu belong to the Native . Xoti is aligned with none , and neither is Eder (but they both probably will leave you if you piss on Eotha the whole journey) . There is also the orlan companion and he is with the Principale (dunno how he feel if ya were to kill them though) .

 

Pallagina is with the Vallian . And she is an ass about them . 

 

Maia will leave you if you side with the Vallian (romanced or not ) . Tekehu will leave if you betray the Native . Pallagina probably will spit on you if you do anything to the Vallian . 

 

I know the Reauta tell you at some point to make a choice (that is how you decide if you wanna join them ) . The Valliant did the same and I got to say No Thanx and keep Maia . 

 

Becareful with the Principale , they got me stumped and locked in joining them cose they have an awesome quest . Grrr I didn't wanna join them ! 

 

And you can do all their quest , just becareful and save often . 



#27
Gary1986

Gary1986

    (5) Thaumaturgist

  • Members
  • 508 posts
  • Deadfire Backer
  • Fig Backer

 

 

 

 

 

Which path leads to not losing any companions?

I haven't gotten far yet but is there a faction choice that's neutral, as in you don't lose any companions?

I was told you could go the solo route and not side with anyone . But siding with the pirate (principale) , nobody leave you .
Could you let me know what part of the game this choice appears at to go solo and not side with anybody? Also is this an official route?

Also is siding with the principale route a second route for nobody to leave you?

When do a these choices appear so that I don't mess up? Are there clear indicators?

Cheers
I can't tell you which route is the solo , since I haven't found it myself . I was doing the principal quest and end up stuck with them and no way to say 'NO THANX! BYE!' . You can say NO to the Valliant when they ask you . Dunno about the Huana and the 3rd faction .

It's late in the game though . Just be careful and SAVE alot .

When I went to the Valliant , they tell you 'It's time to choose' same with rauatia . That is the indicator .

Principale homewhever , they just went 'Let's finish this quest Ahoy!' and before I could say anything we were in buziness ...

So how many factions are there, and which characters leave you during what faction quest line?

What act/chapter does all this happen in?

 

act and chapter? 

 

There is no chapter 1 , chapter 2...or anything . 

 

There are : The Principal (Pirates) 

- The Valian (Think greedy corporation)

- the Reauta (really have a hard time spelling their names) . 

- And the Native .(with a queen) . 

 

Maia belong to the Reauta . Tekehu belong to the Native . Xoti is aligned with none , and neither is Eder (but they both probably will leave you if you piss on Eotha the whole journey) . There is also the orlan companion and he is with the Principale (dunno how he feel if ya were to kill them though) .

 

Pallagina is with the Vallian . And she is an ass about them . 

 

Maia will leave you if you side with the Vallian (romanced or not ) . Tekehu will leave if you betray the Native . Pallagina probably will spit on you if you do anything to the Vallian . 

 

I know the Reauta tell you at some point to make a choice (that is how you decide if you wanna join them ) . The Valliant did the same and I got to say No Thanx and keep Maia . 

 

Becareful with the Principale , they got me stumped and locked in joining them cose they have an awesome quest . Grrr I didn't wanna join them ! 

 

And you can do all their quest , just becareful and save often . 

 

 

Cheers for the response.

 

So i can do all faction quests up until they say something like  ''Hey now make your choice''?

 

And the only way to keep all characters is to side with the Principal? 

 

Side with Valian = Maia leaves

Side with Reauta = Tekehu Leaves

Side with Native = Pallagina leaves

Side with Principal = Nobody leaves

 

That about right?

 

EDIT: Also what quest locks you into the Principal faction?


Edited by Gary1986, 16 May 2018 - 10:32 AM.


#28
E.RedMark

E.RedMark

    (6) Magician

  • Members
  • 672 posts

 

 

 

 

 

 

Which path leads to not losing any companions?

I haven't gotten far yet but is there a faction choice that's neutral, as in you don't lose any companions?

I was told you could go the solo route and not side with anyone . But siding with the pirate (principale) , nobody leave you .
Could you let me know what part of the game this choice appears at to go solo and not side with anybody? Also is this an official route?

Also is siding with the principale route a second route for nobody to leave you?

When do a these choices appear so that I don't mess up? Are there clear indicators?

Cheers
I can't tell you which route is the solo , since I haven't found it myself . I was doing the principal quest and end up stuck with them and no way to say 'NO THANX! BYE!' . You can say NO to the Valliant when they ask you . Dunno about the Huana and the 3rd faction .

It's late in the game though . Just be careful and SAVE alot .

When I went to the Valliant , they tell you 'It's time to choose' same with rauatia . That is the indicator .

Principale homewhever , they just went 'Let's finish this quest Ahoy!' and before I could say anything we were in buziness ...

So how many factions are there, and which characters leave you during what faction quest line?

What act/chapter does all this happen in?

 

act and chapter? 

 

There is no chapter 1 , chapter 2...or anything . 

 

There are : The Principal (Pirates) 

- The Valian (Think greedy corporation)

- the Reauta (really have a hard time spelling their names) . 

- And the Native .(with a queen) . 

 

Maia belong to the Reauta . Tekehu belong to the Native . Xoti is aligned with none , and neither is Eder (but they both probably will leave you if you piss on Eotha the whole journey) . There is also the orlan companion and he is with the Principale (dunno how he feel if ya were to kill them though) .

 

Pallagina is with the Vallian . And she is an ass about them . 

 

Maia will leave you if you side with the Vallian (romanced or not ) . Tekehu will leave if you betray the Native . Pallagina probably will spit on you if you do anything to the Vallian . 

 

I know the Reauta tell you at some point to make a choice (that is how you decide if you wanna join them ) . The Valliant did the same and I got to say No Thanx and keep Maia . 

 

Becareful with the Principale , they got me stumped and locked in joining them cose they have an awesome quest . Grrr I didn't wanna join them ! 

 

And you can do all their quest , just becareful and save often . 

 

 

Cheers for the response.

 

So i can do all faction quests up until they say something like  ''Hey now make your choice''?

 

And the only way to keep all characters is to side with the Principal? 

 

Side with Valian = Maia leaves

Side with Reauta = Tekehu Leaves

Side with Native = Pallagina leaves

Side with Principal = Nobody leaves

 

That about right?

 

yup . 

 

You could try and turn down the Principale too . 

 

The reauta , Vallian and the Native are like the main factions . 

 

You can check on your characters sheet , the differents factions and how much -1 , 0 , 2 influence you have with them . 

 

I'm not sure if the Principale are even a faction as such . But they are there and you can join them . (maybe join someone else + Principale , but I can't be 100% sure) . 

 

And you can go solo . If you figure out how to do that lol let me know . 



#29
Armanz

Armanz

    (2) Evoker

  • Members
  • 52 posts
  • Location:Kuldahar
  • Steam:armanz92
  • Deadfire Backer

I romanced Maia and as far as I know, there's no way to keep her if you join the Huana's side. I tried begging as her lover and the diplomatic option, she still left.

 

What's worse, I can't side with the female pirate captain due to a glitch of quest order, and I don't like the male one. I don't have enough cash to upgrade my ship, either. So now I'm torn between Maia and Tekehu, my two favourite companions. Crap.

You can do the ghost ship quest and take the ship and just not return to the principi, thats what i did.



#30
Gary1986

Gary1986

    (5) Thaumaturgist

  • Members
  • 508 posts
  • Deadfire Backer
  • Fig Backer

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Which path leads to not losing any companions?

I haven't gotten far yet but is there a faction choice that's neutral, as in you don't lose any companions?

I was told you could go the solo route and not side with anyone . But siding with the pirate (principale) , nobody leave you .
Could you let me know what part of the game this choice appears at to go solo and not side with anybody? Also is this an official route?

Also is siding with the principale route a second route for nobody to leave you?

When do a these choices appear so that I don't mess up? Are there clear indicators?

Cheers
I can't tell you which route is the solo , since I haven't found it myself . I was doing the principal quest and end up stuck with them and no way to say 'NO THANX! BYE!' . You can say NO to the Valliant when they ask you . Dunno about the Huana and the 3rd faction .

It's late in the game though . Just be careful and SAVE alot .

When I went to the Valliant , they tell you 'It's time to choose' same with rauatia . That is the indicator .

Principale homewhever , they just went 'Let's finish this quest Ahoy!' and before I could say anything we were in buziness ...

So how many factions are there, and which characters leave you during what faction quest line?

What act/chapter does all this happen in?

 

act and chapter? 

 

There is no chapter 1 , chapter 2...or anything . 

 

There are : The Principal (Pirates) 

- The Valian (Think greedy corporation)

- the Reauta (really have a hard time spelling their names) . 

- And the Native .(with a queen) . 

 

Maia belong to the Reauta . Tekehu belong to the Native . Xoti is aligned with none , and neither is Eder (but they both probably will leave you if you piss on Eotha the whole journey) . There is also the orlan companion and he is with the Principale (dunno how he feel if ya were to kill them though) .

 

Pallagina is with the Vallian . And she is an ass about them . 

 

Maia will leave you if you side with the Vallian (romanced or not ) . Tekehu will leave if you betray the Native . Pallagina probably will spit on you if you do anything to the Vallian . 

 

I know the Reauta tell you at some point to make a choice (that is how you decide if you wanna join them ) . The Valliant did the same and I got to say No Thanx and keep Maia . 

 

Becareful with the Principale , they got me stumped and locked in joining them cose they have an awesome quest . Grrr I didn't wanna join them ! 

 

And you can do all their quest , just becareful and save often . 

 

 

Cheers for the response.

 

So i can do all faction quests up until they say something like  ''Hey now make your choice''?

 

And the only way to keep all characters is to side with the Principal? 

 

Side with Valian = Maia leaves

Side with Reauta = Tekehu Leaves

Side with Native = Pallagina leaves

Side with Principal = Nobody leaves

 

That about right?

 

yup . 

 

You could try and turn down the Principale too . 

 

The reauta , Vallian and the Native are like the main factions . 

 

You can check on your characters sheet , the differents factions and how much -1 , 0 , 2 influence you have with them . 

 

I'm not sure if the Principale are even a faction as such . But they are there and you can join them . (maybe join someone else + Principale , but I can't be 100% sure) . 

 

And you can go solo . If you figure out how to do that lol let me know . 

 

 

 

Cheers.

 

I hope this game doesnt lead down the path of at least 1 character has to 100% leave at some point, it would totally ruin it for me.



#31
E.RedMark

E.RedMark

    (6) Magician

  • Members
  • 672 posts

 

I romanced Maia and as far as I know, there's no way to keep her if you join the Huana's side. I tried begging as her lover and the diplomatic option, she still left.

 

What's worse, I can't side with the female pirate captain due to a glitch of quest order, and I don't like the male one. I don't have enough cash to upgrade my ship, either. So now I'm torn between Maia and Tekehu, my two favourite companions. Crap.

You can do the ghost ship quest and take the ship and just not return to the principi, thats what i did.

 

that maybe the mistake I made . Once I was done , I went back..and that was it . No way to back out . 


  • Juodas Varnas likes this

#32
Ryz009

Ryz009

    (4) Theurgist

  • Members
  • 344 posts
  • Deadfire Backer
  • Fig Backer

 

 

I romanced Maia and as far as I know, there's no way to keep her if you join the Huana's side. I tried begging as her lover and the diplomatic option, she still left.

 

What's worse, I can't side with the female pirate captain due to a glitch of quest order, and I don't like the male one. I don't have enough cash to upgrade my ship, either. So now I'm torn between Maia and Tekehu, my two favourite companions. Crap.

You can do the ghost ship quest and take the ship and just not return to the principi, thats what i did.

 

that maybe the mistake I made . Once I was done , I went back..and that was it . No way to back out . 

 

 

Yeah I did that and returned the sword. Ship kind of blows though so I ended up going back to my normal junk XD



#33
E.RedMark

E.RedMark

    (6) Magician

  • Members
  • 672 posts

 

 

 

I romanced Maia and as far as I know, there's no way to keep her if you join the Huana's side. I tried begging as her lover and the diplomatic option, she still left.

 

What's worse, I can't side with the female pirate captain due to a glitch of quest order, and I don't like the male one. I don't have enough cash to upgrade my ship, either. So now I'm torn between Maia and Tekehu, my two favourite companions. Crap.

You can do the ghost ship quest and take the ship and just not return to the principi, thats what i did.

 

that maybe the mistake I made . Once I was done , I went back..and that was it . No way to back out . 

 

 

Yeah I did that and returned the sword. Ship kind of blows though so I ended up going back to my normal junk XD

 

no I mean , went back to the Principale . And got stuck with them..

 

And then when I got to use the ship.....pfff..total disaster . 

 

cose once ya are stuck with a faction , your Junk boat get killed over and over . 



#34
AudreyBee

AudreyBee

    (1) Prestidigitator

  • Members
  • 10 posts

 

 

 

I romanced Maia and as far as I know, there's no way to keep her if you join the Huana's side. I tried begging as her lover and the diplomatic option, she still left.

 

What's worse, I can't side with the female pirate captain due to a glitch of quest order, and I don't like the male one. I don't have enough cash to upgrade my ship, either. So now I'm torn between Maia and Tekehu, my two favourite companions. Crap.

You can do the ghost ship quest and take the ship and just not return to the principi, thats what i did.

 

that maybe the mistake I made . Once I was done , I went back..and that was it . No way to back out . 

 

 

Yeah I did that and returned the sword. Ship kind of blows though so I ended up going back to my normal junk XD

 

Ha does it? My junk is fantastic right now so I will probably make the same choice.

 

I'm torn between choosing the Huana, since I like the queen, and just going solo if that's an option. 

 

Does siding with the Huana make you lose both Pallegina and Maia?



#35
Gary1986

Gary1986

    (5) Thaumaturgist

  • Members
  • 508 posts
  • Deadfire Backer
  • Fig Backer

Which path leads to not losing any companions?

I haven't gotten far yet but is there a faction choice that's neutral, as in you don't lose any companions?

I was told you could go the solo route and not side with anyone . But siding with the pirate (principale) , nobody leave you .
Could you let me know what part of the game this choice appears at to go solo and not side with anybody? Also is this an official route?

Also is siding with the principale route a second route for nobody to leave you?

When do a these choices appear so that I don't mess up? Are there clear indicators?

Cheers
I can't tell you which route is the solo , since I haven't found it myself . I was doing the principal quest and end up stuck with them and no way to say 'NO THANX! BYE!' . You can say NO to the Valliant when they ask you . Dunno about the Huana and the 3rd faction .

It's late in the game though . Just be careful and SAVE alot .

When I went to the Valliant , they tell you 'It's time to choose' same with rauatia . That is the indicator .

Principale homewhever , they just went 'Let's finish this quest Ahoy!' and before I could say anything we were in buziness ...
So how many factions are there, and which characters leave you during what faction quest line?

What act/chapter does all this happen in?
act and chapter?

There is no chapter 1 , chapter 2...or anything .

There are : The Principal (Pirates)
- The Valian (Think greedy corporation)
- the Reauta (really have a hard time spelling their names) .
- And the Native .(with a queen) .

Maia belong to the Reauta . Tekehu belong to the Native . Xoti is aligned with none , and neither is Eder (but they both probably will leave you if you piss on Eotha the whole journey) . There is also the orlan companion and he is with the Principale (dunno how he feel if ya were to kill them though) .

Pallagina is with the Vallian . And she is an ass about them .

Maia will leave you if you side with the Vallian (romanced or not ) . Tekehu will leave if you betray the Native . Pallagina probably will spit on you if you do anything to the Vallian .

I know the Reauta tell you at some point to make a choice (that is how you decide if you wanna join them ) . The Valliant did the same and I got to say No Thanx and keep Maia .

Becareful with the Principale , they got me stumped and locked in joining them cose they have an awesome quest . Grrr I didn't wanna join them !

And you can do all their quest , just becareful and save often .

Cheers for the response.

So i can do all faction quests up until they say something like ''Hey now make your choice''?

And the only way to keep all characters is to side with the Principal?

Side with Valian = Maia leaves
Side with Reauta = Tekehu Leaves
Side with Native = Pallagina leaves
Side with Principal = Nobody leaves

That about right?
yup .

You could try and turn down the Principale too .

The reauta , Vallian and the Native are like the main factions .

You can check on your characters sheet , the differents factions and how much -1 , 0 , 2 influence you have with them .

I'm not sure if the Principale are even a faction as such . But they are there and you can join them . (maybe join someone else + Principale , but I can't be 100% sure) .

And you can go solo . If you figure out how to do that lol let me know .

Maybe you can go Principale & solo (if you say that maybe Principale isn't a major faction)

Maybe if you say no to all 3 major factions when it comes to choosing it automatically starts the solo path.

#36
E.RedMark

E.RedMark

    (6) Magician

  • Members
  • 672 posts

 


Maybe you can go Principale & solo (if you say that maybe Principale isn't a major faction)

Maybe if you say no to all 3 major factions when it comes to choosing it automatically starts the solo path.

 

maybe...

 

up to you in the end though  ;)



#37
Ryz009

Ryz009

    (4) Theurgist

  • Members
  • 344 posts
  • Deadfire Backer
  • Fig Backer

 

 

 

 

I romanced Maia and as far as I know, there's no way to keep her if you join the Huana's side. I tried begging as her lover and the diplomatic option, she still left.

 

What's worse, I can't side with the female pirate captain due to a glitch of quest order, and I don't like the male one. I don't have enough cash to upgrade my ship, either. So now I'm torn between Maia and Tekehu, my two favourite companions. Crap.

You can do the ghost ship quest and take the ship and just not return to the principi, thats what i did.

 

that maybe the mistake I made . Once I was done , I went back..and that was it . No way to back out . 

 

 

Yeah I did that and returned the sword. Ship kind of blows though so I ended up going back to my normal junk XD

 

Ha does it? My junk is fantastic right now so I will probably make the same choice.

 

I'm torn between choosing the Huana, since I like the queen, and just going solo if that's an option. 

 

Does siding with the Huana make you lose both Pallegina and Maia?

 

 

Yeah less cannons and less hull/sails.

 

I think my nicer version of Serp will choose the Huana where my more douchey version of him will go solo.



#38
Gary1986

Gary1986

    (5) Thaumaturgist

  • Members
  • 508 posts
  • Deadfire Backer
  • Fig Backer


Maybe you can go Principale & solo (if you say that maybe Principale isn't a major faction)

Maybe if you say no to all 3 major factions when it comes to choosing it automatically starts the solo path.

maybe...

up to you in the end though ;)

Cheers for the responses, really appreciate it.

I'll keep an eye out for the final choices on when the factions ask me to pick sides.
  • E.RedMark likes this

#39
E.RedMark

E.RedMark

    (6) Magician

  • Members
  • 672 posts

 

 

Maybe you can go Principale & solo (if you say that maybe Principale isn't a major faction)

Maybe if you say no to all 3 major factions when it comes to choosing it automatically starts the solo path.

maybe...

up to you in the end though ;)

Cheers for the responses, really appreciate it.

I'll keep an eye out for the final choices on when the factions ask me to pick sides.

 

just remember to save ALOT . can't be stressed enough lol 

 

Happy gaming!  :grin:



#40
Hazmy

Hazmy

    (2) Evoker

  • Members
  • 90 posts
  • Location:Hungary

After finishing my own playthrough, I can confirm. I sided with Vailians, I romanced Maia, maxed reputation with her and she still left. RIP. ( Screw the rauatai anyway )


  • E.RedMark likes this




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users