How to keep Pallegina and Xoti together in your group.

[Nomian]

Well quite long time I though up how to keep these companions in my group cause I need both of them. We know that Pallegina does not like Xoti's opinions and Xoti a bit same with Pallegina's opinions, mostly if Pallegina is still a bit upset from my decisions i POE 1. Anyway I had a idea which I am using all that time throught all game in POE 2. If there is some interaction or conversation pro Xoti or Pallegina, I am keeping just one of them in party that moment. For example: If I spoke with Xoti about her live, believes or did her story quest I took out Pallegina from party which means that she did not give negative reputation with Xoti cause she was not there that time. For example same when you are finishing quest - Storm Of Poko Kahara, Pallegina was on ship that time cause there were quite a lot conversation about death, souls and so on, which Pallegina hate. What I saw this problem is mostly with Pallegina, she realy hates that poor little girl but Xoti does not have so big problem with Pallegina opinions or duty or whatever she wants. I did Pallegina quest without problem with Xoti in group. Conversation with Pallegina I did without Xoti in group, just for case. Now I am just few quests from the end of the game and in the end Xoti has 1 positive point with Pallegina relationship and Pallegina 1 negative point with Xoti so is much more dificult for Pallegina likes Xoti then for Xoti to like Pallegina. So my advice how to keep them together in one group, in important interaction or conversation which has affliction to one of them or another of them is take Pallegina or Xoti (mostly Pallegina) from group for that time to copmplete quest, conversation or interaction and after put them back, nothing will change in reputation between them.

 

NOTE: My big apology for my poor english.

[antoniokolano]

Thing is, unless I'm terribly mistaken, neither of them will ever leave the party just because they don't like each other. They will clash at some point but the situtation can be solved with a very low Diplomacy check. 

[AeonsLegend]

But does anyone like Xoti's opinions? I mean anyone not being an deranged religious zealot?

[Nerfer2123]

I had Pallegina leave my party once from my choices in a quest. Spoilers below:

 

 

It was the one quest where you go to Dunegage to find Guccio (A pirate band of godlike have him hostage) if you choose to have him killed then she will leave the party.

[Nomian]

Actualy I've never had situation where they fight to each other, fortunately, but I red quite a lot of topics where some players have that problem in the end, mostly with Xoti and Pallegina, that's way I am using this method to keep them in peace. What I saw for example Eder like her opinions same as Maia. I did not try another companions, so I do not have experiences with serafen, aloth and others. I am using Eder and Pallegina in front line, Xoti as buffs and healer specialist and Maia and my MC (wizard)for range attacks.

[the streaker]

Wrong forum... but Xoti is religious in a world where gods obviously do exist to some extent, so it's not equivalent to our world.

[Manveru123]

You're just wasting your time because neither will leave because of difference in opinion. All you need to do is be careful how you do quests because it feels like Pallegina is just waiting for an opportunity to leave if you make one questionable choice. But if she leaves, it won't be because of Xoti.

[Nomian]

She will leave party cause it is her personal quest so you have to save Guccio for all cost. But be honest I realy do not like her person in POE 2, in previous game I like her,but here not realy. Anyway I think that obsidian still need a bit improve all reputation system in POE2.

[Manveru123]

I agree with that. The only reason I'm bringing her with me is that she's the only NPC who can be a Herald. If it wasn't for this, she'd rot in my ship. Such a terrible companion.

[OldViking]

I agree with that. The only reason I'm bringing her with me is that she's the only NPC who can be a Herald. If it wasn't for this, she'd rot in my ship. Such a terrible companion.

Well, Xoti is not better.

I really hate stupid religious zealots and she is a prime example.

Her cringeworthy accent doesn't help either.

 

I really dislike all the story companions, but xoti, serafen and fishboy are the worst. Im so glad i don't have to take any of the cast with me.

[Manveru123]

The difference is, with Pallegina you have to be very careful about how you approach quests, because I feel like there's many ways to get her to leave by accident.. while Xoti sticks around at least. Also Xoti can easily be replaced, Priests are not as good as they used to be, especially after 1.1 nerfs, while Pallegina's sub class is simply too strong to ignore

[Nomian]

I agree with all of it, just as I said before, I would like to have xoti and pallegina together. Actualy as you said Pallegina has very good subclasses, but I am not using her as a Herald like a lot of people but just like crusader in front line with eder. And xoti is just healer and buff's specialist for all group. With that group I've not have problem throught all POE 2 with any fights at all.

[Myztik]

Other than her personal quest what choices is Pallegina leaving your party?

[Manveru123]

If you don't resolve Family Feud peacefully, for example. You can't side with one family and kill the other if you have her in your group.

[Farsha]

I had them both in party for my first walkthrough.
I was pretty anti-gods/religion, as any sane person would.
Never had any real issues with keeping them in party really.
There were some scripted arguments but nothing even close to leaving.

So I'd say it's pretty easy to have them both, as I managed on my first blind walkthrough with no issues.

[Nomian]

For now I know for sure just two situation, probably there will be more what I found in forums such as if you will screw up some faction quest or if you will do that in another way then she likes, but for sure her personal quest if you will leave kill Guccio.Another one if you will try stealth something in VTC base and guards catch you, mostly in director's office after that she will leave and begin hostile.

[Nomian]

Farsha, that's possible for sure but my watcher was a bit oposite then your's, that's way I have succesfuly romance with Xoti and with Pallegina different opinions in a lot of situations so it means more negative points with her.

[Farsha]

Farsha, that's possible for sure but my watcher was a bit oposite then your's, that's way I have succesfuly romance with Xoti and with Pallegina different opinions in a lot of situations so it means more negative points with her.

All your romancable companions want to bang you all the time. No matter what your opinions are. Had to be very active in keeping Xoti away even though I bashed the gods regularly. Romance in this game is both terribly written and implemented, not to mention pointless.

It should have not been added.

 

Pellagina only cares about he personall quest and VTC quest line, if you don't screw those two up for her she'll be fine. And as I said Xoti will want to bang you no matter what, I pushed her towars Eder, but bitch friendzoned the poor guy anyways.

Edited June 26, 2018 by Farsha