I know you just spent a post explaining how America isn't exactly a democracy, but the way you chose your president is decidedly undemocratic.
Not only do you discard the mandates (electoral votes) of the losing side ,which are supposed to represent voter influence, you give those mandates to the enemy. So if a state has been 60% democratic for the last decade, it is a defacto democratic stronghold where republican influence, on the presidential level, is nonexistent. It's not so much one man one vote, but one man 2 votes one place, and 0 in another.
Does it really matter that much where you live, and are the differences between the states in cultural and political tradition so great as to make this necessary. I know everything to do with the constitution and its organization of the political system is a holy cow in the US and will continue in its antiquated state indefinitely, but still.