Nah, they would have lost several games. Apparently you havn't watched Vicky much this season if you think he isn't over-rated. They guy has had a few 3 and 4 turnover games himself. He will never lead a serious super-bowl team, that as you might say, doesn't win in spite of him. Vick is, and always will be, less the sum of his parts. However, Ron Mexico is still a little funny.
As I have expressed before, which is why I think your upset and brought out the Grossman calls, the only other "Gross-ly" over-rated QB in the league is Eli. When Grossman was "over-rated" he was putting up HUGE numbers, considering he didn't have much of a history, it would be hard to say at the time he was over-rated. Clearly time has proven that tho. Like Grossman, Eli is extremely spotty and goes from great games to horrible ones.