I don't find women attractive, but then of course I am one.
Hmm. Atton, Carth or Disciple? Well, Carth is sweet but kinda old, and for some reason the whole son thing (Dustil) put me off. Atton is pretty good, but I always got the impression that Disciple had a bigger...lightsabre " Then again, Disciple is boring so I choose Atton.
PS. my poll vote went to Bastila coz she is Female Revan's 'sister'.