Atton all the way...that vocie of his is the kicker for me. It has almost exactly the same tonal qualities of my 1st love and II was hooked into Atton's character from the get-go.
Disciple annoyed me as being too goody2shoes at first, with a foppish voice, and I felt like every time he talked I was staring up his nose....but his protective devotion to 'me' finally broke my evil reserve and now he's the co-leader of my harem...er...I mean my group.