How shallow!

 

i don't suppose it's easy for you to pick up when someone is joking <_<

*nudge* I think Kum was joking too.

How bout them Cowboys!!

 

*fires six shooters wildly into the air*

Clearly we need a top ten active QB debate (as of now, not their prime):

 

1. Brady

2. P.Manning

3. Brees

4. McNabb

5. Palmer

6. Hasselbeck

7. Bulger

8. Vick

9. Trenet Green

10. Grossman

 

Muddled Middle: Eli, Rivers, Plummer, Leftwich, Roethlisberger, Delhomme, Favre

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I'll bite. I'd break your top-10 into 3 tiers, because, while it's often too hard to make individual distinctions, there are some clear breaks in the data:

 

Tier 1:

Manning the Elder & Brady (collectively, "Peytom Branning")

 

Tier 2: Your 3-6 (Brees, McNabb, Palmer (if healthy), & Hasselbeck), which I have no problem with.

 

Tier 3:

Bulger, Green, Roethlisberger (if healthy).

 

This leaves me with a top-9. I don't really know which of the remaining players should be #10. I'm not a Mike Vick fan. I don't think we have enough data on Grossman or Rivers (both can count the number of games they've played against non-horrendous defenses on their thumbs) to crown their asses just yet. Delhomme is nothing without Steve Smith. The Giants homer in me wants to pick Eli, but he has 3-4 scary dumb/inaccurate throws per game, which is just too many.

"crown their asses"

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

 

Both good lists. Brady and P. Manning are far ahead of the rest, after that I'd say McNabb, Brees, Hasselbeck and Bulger (12 TDs, 1 INT, that's why) are the next tier.

 

Grossman is definitely playing top-tier ball, but I don't think that would be happening without his supporting cast.

 

I'd drop Palmer into the third tier with Michael Vick, Trent Green and Phillip Rivers, who also wouldn't be having as great a year if he didn't have a strong running game for defenses to focus on.

 

The Burger is so hot and cold... I mean he was in the zone against Atlanta before he got knocked out - but then he'll play an awful game the next week.

Back in his prime, Favre PWNs.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

he's a cutie too, for an older guy

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

That he is.

How shallow!

 

i don't suppose it's easy for you to pick up when someone is joking <_<

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

*nudge*  I think Kum was joking too.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

I was, hence the supermodel joke stuff right after it

HUh, no plummer love at all, I thought someone might knock me for leaving him off.

Plummer is alright but he sure isn't John Elway. A shame.

Plummer is alright but he sure isn't John Elway. A shame. 

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

How many people are. I feel sorry for that guy, he plays well, but "he'll never be John Elway"

and the bears blow it to miami 31 - 13

 

 

well I hope the colts can hold it together tonight against the pats or today will be very depressing ... as the packers got killed by themselves ... bears lose as stated above, I need the colts to win

wow...um...I think we had something like 7 turn overs. Several in our own red zone.

 

Well, at least everyone near us but the Giants lost too. See you next week Vol

Looks like Chicago has been picking up plays from Detroit. They lost to nobody Miami???

Wow, everything's breaking for the Giants this week. Every other NFC contender except New Orleans has lost.

 

Now if we can just get the Defense healthy. 6 important players either sat or missed the majority of the Texans game (DE Umenyiora, DE Tuck, LB Arrington, LB Short, CB Madison, & DE Strahan). Plus the starting RT (McKenzie had a migraine) and #1 WR!

Next week, Giants v Bears, is HUGE.

I hope the Giants win; but it's in Bears Land so the Bears have the edge. It should be a fun game. Rex has no exuse cosnideirng the defensive injuries the Giants have.

 

We'll see how the Bears vaunted D recover against an offense that has struggled someone despite two home wins against pretty easy opponents.

I hope the Giants win; but it's in Bears Land so the Bears have the edge. It should be a fun game. Rex has no exuse cosnideirng the defensive injuries the Giants have.

 

We'll see how the Bears vaunted D recover against an offense that has struggled someone despite two home wins against pretty easy opponents.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

The game will be at the Meadowlands. The Giants will likely be lacking their top 3 DEs (that surprise pick of Kiwanuka in the draft is looking to be more helpful than expected), but Madison & Burress at least should be back.

OOps. I thought it was in Chicago. My bad. Ok. The game favors the Giants then.

Next week, Giants v Bears, is HUGE.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

The Bears will lose. LOLZ They lost to Miami who has that former trashy QB from Detroit. LOLZ

yeah the colts won (w00t) ... the weekend wasn't a total wash. sorry any pats fans

My Jags won, so I'm happy ^_^.

 

But that Chicago loss sucks....my entire family up north probably didn't take that one too well.

 

So long as they don't make it a habit, da Bears should be ok. One flub during the normal season is all right. Making a flub like that during the playoffs isn't.

Giants missed a field goal, go Bears!

 

EDIT: O god, after grossmans int, the Bears can't lose or I'll never hear the end of it.

Edited November 13, 200619 yr by kumquatq3

Steelers won! (finally) I got to admit, I was a little worried, especially after their last minute touchdown in the first half and Polamalu's injury. Plus, the Bengals lost, too! It was a good day.

Steelers won!  (finally)  I got to admit, I was a little worried, especially after their last minute touchdown in the first half and Polamalu's injury.  Plus, the Bengals lost, too!  It was a good day. 

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

You beat the Saints too, thanks!

 

BTW, go Grossman!

If the Bears lose this game it's 100% Grossman's fault.. Well.. 90%. 8% the running back's fault... 2% offensive lines' fault.

 

With the Giants defense DECIMATED with injuries there is no exuse not to beat them up.

 

 

P.S. Outside of that last drive, Grossman has played horribly as predictable as that is.

Edited November 13, 200619 yr by Volourn