Laozi

There's a big difference with Dragonlance and Forgotten Realms, they are not derived from a movie, there authors had there own characters and only wanted to write in a pre established world with set rules, and in the case of Forgotten Realms D&DA rules. Star Wars books after ROTJ with the exception of X-Wing books are all based off of the futher adventures of Han Solo, Luke Skywalker, etc. Its only natural that some Star Wars fans, who love it as much if not more than you, aren't going to want Luke to fall to the DS because they cloned his father and the Emperor, they don't want Chewie to die fighting some bio mechinical race of S&Mers, and don't want Princess Leia to waver on her love for Han, because some Prince comes from a "closed off section of the galaxy, blah blah blah Its only fair that these people get a chance to preserve their ideas of what the Star Wars galaxy is like and not have it tainted by poor storytelling

Although I will agree with you Nur Ab, the way you present your case is often simplistic

Yes but when the novels aren't even 100% correct and you worship them, then when a game is off, maybe you should cut them a little slack

And I say this "EU" building is built on poor foundations, and infested with termites feeding of the dollar bills of true star wars fan, tear it down start again........was that a metaphor?

^ what he said

Unless Artis has extremely hairy arms for a girl, its not her

Good try Lamo

Oh for the love of pete, Kevin J. Anderson, one of the best authors? You know how they say you can't judge a book by its cover, well I'm looking at Dark Apprentice right now, and the cover suxs and the book suxs, so I guess that's not 100% true about the cover judging

Doesn't it seem pretty crappy that the EU is so lame that people who love it don't want to see a game made in its time period?

You will try to use reason, but to no avail, there fate is sealed

I guess, what do you mean, it sad because its aXboX game or that PCs want XboX games

And the fact that it even exist is because of XboX

I don't really care what you think, and millions, well maybe, but its safe to say that a very large group of people who bought those novels and read those novel, dislike the EU. I know I'm not the only one who doesn't like it, you know I'm not the only one who doesn't like it. I love good novels and read them all the time, thats pretty much why I don't read "EU" novels anymore, And as for your last statement its a testiment to your creativity, how'd you ever come up with that one?

Kind of like rocket shoes

I guess I'm sorry about the Trekies comment, maybe

Really that doesn't sound very intimidating

Does it pay money or exp

Or just come up with something original

Ya I'll probaly have to upgrade for that one

Nirnaeth Arnoediad

I actually cried when Fingolfin died, come on it said that even after Morgoth beat him that none of his sevant spoke of it with pride, he went one on one with a god and cut him to shreds before he wore down, and he was the grand papy of Gil-Galad(s. star of radiance) very impressive but guess what, we're off topic

I was actually very disappointed by Salvatore's effort as well

Fingolfin though eventually smited by Morgoth was the ultimate bad ass. and Battle of Tumhalad?

His pet is a little S&M midget that he slings around by its leash, causing massive destruction to his foes.

Well I can't say for sure, I can only speculate