So I take it you would also like combat to be resolved with a single die roll? After all, there's an extraordinary amount of player skill required to resolved the combat mini-game in RPGs.
I tend to cheat a lot in my games so I don't even have to worry about combat, as its usually the least enjoyable part of the game for me. Having the option to skip the whole process would be nice.
I actually really liked Tactics. I thought the additions made to the combat like cover and positions as well as the phase based option was really nice. Other than the improved graphics, improved combat, and more focus on combat, I found it to definitely have the fallout feel.