I know that because of this view you and I disagree over drug policy, but believe it or not I am generally the same way. I certainly don't believe that putting up with attacks is tenable. However, I'm not sure there is the political will yet to carry out the necessary action to eliminate the problem. I think we're going to see the phenomenon spread, most likely to Nigeria first. Maybe the LTTE will try it as well.
As for criminlaising paying the pirates I don't see your point, Volo. Paying up finances more crime, and more victims. The cycle has to be broken somehow. If it were criminal to pay up, then the owners would be obliged to protect their assets properly.