Should helmits have a bonus vs crits?

[ctn2003]

  I don't like helmets being worthless, The way helmets are now i just sell them or take them off so i can see my characters face. Having helmets have a bonus vs crits well give players a small choice at the begging of the game. Well you spend your small amount of gold on a helmet for your character or well you save it for something else? like food or to rest? Now i understand their are magic helmets in the game but their rare and wont be found tell way later on in the game.  Icewind dale 2 had the same problem.

Edited September 27, 2014 by ctn2003

[Matt516]

Don't personally think bonus vs crits would work in this system - a +5 Deflection would do about the same thing though.

 

Either way, unenchanted helmets shouldn't be worthless. That's just silly.

[wanderon]

Don't personally think bonus vs crits would work in this system - a +5 Deflection would do about the same thing though.

 

Either way, unenchanted helmets shouldn't be worthless. That's just silly.

 

If there is going to be an armor bonus for non-magic helmets then shouldn't there be a penalty for reduced vision and head turning as well...

[Starwars]

If there are helmets then there should be a bloody reason, mechanically speaking, to wear them in my opinion. It's not a freaking tie, helmets exist for a practical reason after all. It should do something.

[Sensuki]

I think they should give something too.

[PK htiw klaw eriF]

A small deflection bonus sounds about right.

[Hiro Protagonist II]

I agree with helmets should have something. I'd also like to see other headwear have something as well. I see a lot of hoods in the beta and it's be good to have something on them. It feels worthless when you pick them up and see no bonuses on them at all.

[Sensuki]

Reducing the crit range or something would be enough (that doesn't make you harder to hit, just harder to crit).

[gkathellar]

I actually think they should remain as they are. Magical helmets should give bonuses, but since mundane ones aren't interesting, I'd rather they remain a cosmetic decision.

 

That, or Obsidian should give them an invisibility switch, as per Divinity:OS. "Make helmets invisible," is an almost ubiquitous mod in fantasy CRPGs at this point, and it's that way for a reason.

[Elerond]

I think helmets could be changed so that they give +1 - +2 DT and -1 - -5 to accuracy. Which gives them role that isn't fully cosmetic but don't make them too overpowered. 

[morhilane]

I'm currently checking enchanting and the BB Fighter's helmet can't be enchanted.

 

Which means we can't make our own enchanted helmet. I personally think they should allow at least +skill increase on helmet, would make them a bit more useful beside decoration.

[Sensuki]

There are hats that give bonuses as well, so I'd say that's a fail.

[Lephys]

I think helmets could be changed so that they give +1 - +2 DT and -1 - -5 to accuracy. Which gives them role that isn't fully cosmetic but don't make them too overpowered.

That could even be a range. Simple little helmet? Just +1 to DT (Or a minor Deflection bonus... whichever). Full, face-covering helmet? Significantly higher defense bonus (+5 or so), but now a -2 or -3 penalty to Accuracy. I dunno exactly how this plays out in real life with helmets, but you could even do an increased penalty specifically to ranged accuracy. I would think melee accuracy would be less of a problem, since it's harder to see a little pinpoint target you're trying to hit from 30 yards than it is to see where a body is from 2 feet away. *shrug*