The German 360LiVE Magazine (it's not an official magazine): 8.5. Just for comparison, other ratings in the same issue are: L.A. Noire 8.8, Red Faction Armageddon 8.1, Brink 7.3.
Graphic: 7
* detailed enemies, nice enviroments, but there is room for more
Sound: 8
* brilliant ambient noise, good synchro, nice music
Controls: 8
* Such games only work with mouse and keyboard? As if!
General Pro & Cons:
+ motivating gameplay
+ coherent look
+ bulky magic effects
+ good length
+ demanding enemies
+ very well thought out combat system
+ well arranged menu
+ comfortable help function
+ carefully balanced heroes
- you can't create your hero from scratch
- the presentation of dialogs
- the first hour is a little bit dull
- sometimes loading times could be shorter
- no optical difference when you equip your hero with a new armor
* the reviewer thinks the game is very addictive ("Just one more level up!")
* 25 hours for the first playthrough on normal difficulty.
* inventory is really good
* an absolute stable framerate