Jasede

It should have weight if inventory / weight management are considered integral parts of the game, such as offering feats for increased carrying capacity, heavy but good items that restrict your load, dodge penalties, movement penalties, STR or CON based carry / equip weight limits and so on and so on. Still, it should be something kept for expert mode because today's gamer can't even open a doorway unless it's marked on a compass, has a light trail pointing to it, a tool-tip describing they should go there, an NPC telling them they should go there AND an arrow on the map pointing to the correct direction, as well as an on-screen quest journal that says "Go to the Doorway! It's to the north! Look on your map to find it, then open it by clicking on it!". Oh, and there's a bright yellow outline around the door once you can see it, just in case. Bitter? Naaah...

- overly long cut-scenes - clear best weapons - mini-games - quests that involve killing rats or wolves or spiders - sewers - lack of challenge - a too drawn-out beginning (Mortuary, Telos) - "epic" - hand-holding - grim-darkness - space marines - Gandalf - lack of flavor text - re-specs without a heavy toll - strict linearity - Bioware-syndrome (find 4 map pieces / magical ingredients / shards of the sword / Jedi masters / demon souls) - spelling everything out; give me some credit - lack of diversity in spell selection - boring class advancement - useless skills - overpowered skills - boring skills that are used twice in the entire game - lack of skills (don't be like The Elder Scrolls 7 where they will remove most skills in favor of Fighting, Magicking and Thieving because that's easier to understand for the target audience) - full voice acting; I can read a billion times faster than they can act, thank you - bad voice acting, like in a Bioware game. Good voice acting: Kotor 2, PS:T, Bloodlines. - references. easter eggs are okay but should be sparse / well hidden. No Fallout 2 please, unless it's all Vault City; praise MCA - annoying companions, see next points - Lawful Mc Paladin - Annoying Thief Girl - Emotional Mage Female That Can't Contain Her Powers - Rugged Mercenary Who Has Seen It All - Charming Rogue - Obviously Secretly Evil Wizard - Gandalf again - children unless I can kill them - unkillable NPCs; think Arcanum here for a positive inspiration and anything Bioware for a negative one

I believe this is a meaningless and useless feature. That said, provided that it is optional and there is sufficient time to add it in I don't see the harm. Cosmetics should never be a priority; substance is key.