Pros: Good roleplaying from the start, great voice acting, fun dialogue(Malkavian) and nice urban environment set in southern California.
Cons: Horrid combat, overabundance of uninspired quests with said horrid combat, uneventful and predictable story, worst collision detection ever seen, bugs, and massive loading times(unless you're on a good PC).
I wont ever give it a second play through but I can see how it appeals to others.