Pan's Labrynth is good, I also liked The Devil's Backbone from Del Toro (and the two Hellboy films)
It was a bit of a toss-up, they're both really good. I could have went for either as well. Looking forward to The Northman from Eggers.
I also could have included a bunch of Terry Gilliam's films (in particular Brazil and The Brother's Grimm, but also Tideland, 12 Monkeys, Baron Munchausen and Dr. Parnasus) or Hitch**** films. Or David Lynch for that matter.