Gromnir

that is ridiculous. da is a Game. choose boot over car or battleship not give you an advantage in monopoly. choose mage should not give disproportionate advantage in da neither. 'course, as da is a rp game that allows players to make choices in character development and generation, it is unlikely that the developers would be able to achieve complete balance... is predictable and understandable that as player choices and options increase, the likelihood of achieving balance decreases. even so, there is no excuse for how poorly balanced mages is compared to other da classes... is just plain silly. "it's magic" is Not any kinda gameplay argument. make argument that magic should be powerful? maybe. no doubt some folks will argue in favor of low magic settings and systems, but we can see that some folks might prefer more traditional high power magic stuff. but Overpower? is no valid reason to argue in favor of overpower. inherent in definition of overpower is Excess. HA! Good Fun!

compare d&d to da is a ridiculous way to argue against over-power of da mages. one of the most frequent complaints regarding d&d (pre 4e) is that mages is way too powerful at higher levels. the fact that da has a similar problem is not some kinda wacky validation of bioware's efforts, but rather a criticism that they could not fix one of d&d's flaws... inspite of fact that the biowarians started with their own rules system from scratch. da magic is flawed similar to d&d in that some spells is disproportionate powerful, and high level mages have access to far too many spells with insane array o' utility... can buff and immobilize and damage and heal and... whatever. "Apart from the Deep Roads..." agreed. deep roads had far too much undifferentiated combat... really felt the grind. otherwise we were not bothered by degree and frequency o' combats. HA! Good Fun!

2 points, 'cause some folks hasn't seen in a while. 1) Gromnir never suggested that rogues is worthless. we said the opposite... said that rogues is effective, but unnecessary. could simply have created a warrior class and a mage class and allowed any character to choose rogue skills if they so desired. cobbled-together quasi-warrior that is rogue is unnecessary bloat. 2) vol didn't pay attention to boo follow-up "Edit: you're right, I've noticed just now that everyone ignores Wynne, which keeps my healing steady. Weird. " is not a matter o' Gromnir opinion and am not certain who you thinks we is speaking for in this instance. we passed along information that were provided by bio and confirmed by numerous players, including boo. armour determines targeting priority. ... debating with a chimp. HA! Good Fun!

The first one is only effective if done by two or three people, the second suggestion is the most effective. Even though storm of the century is a gamble to do that way. The way that I find them most effective is to put them right on the edge of bottlenecks and have them clogged by paralysis spells and/or tanks. Edit. The same way with traps. the most effective parties have multiple mages... the aforementioned tactics is just one reason why. stack up glyphs o' paralysis, grease and multi elemental spells. typical we gots 1 combatant, shale and 2 mages in party. shale can does hurl rock (knocks folks back into kill zone) and rock barrage AND be tank while the two mages do their elemental havoc or earthquake or whatever. HA! Good Fun!

You realize that it costs money to make games right? that sounds like a legitimate question... for iron tower... not so much for the consumer. nevertheless, if vinnie can gets consumers to pay shekels to support his game Before it is finished, then more power to him. HA! Good Fun!

Those last tier spells; specially the primal ones, are a waste of points. Aside from a few exceptions, they waste and exuberant amount of mana and do damage for the three seconds it takes enemies to run through them. blizzard frequent freezes enemies so that they may not move out of range. couple the area effect elemental spells with earthquake (groan) or grease (better) and you may also greatly increase the likelihood of doing damage for a longer duration. additionally, and we hesitate to mention as is such a horrible bit o' cheatery, as boo has observed, enemies do not notice you if you is slightly beyond range or around a corner. area effects is large and enemy ai is stoopid. chances are that the no-goodnicks will try to avoid being burned, electrocuted or frozen by running to a corner of room that is currently being blasted by cold, lightning and/or flame. worst-case scenario: you position your melee combatants at the very edge o' the area effect-- any enemies that tries to leave kill zone most fight you before exiting. HA! Good Fun!

optimizing is a cheat, and a very effective one. for those who wish to alter the challenge factor o' the game, using the point-redistribution mod is far more effective than moving the difficulty slider. is a cheat, but we do not blame you for using. if the powhaz were actually balanced properly then it would not matter how points and powhaz were distributed. sadly, da balance considerations is somewhat lacking. even so, point redistribute has a significant impact on game difficulty. HA! Good Fun!

that is indeed possible, but Gromnir never presumes cheats... even if the cheats is perfect reasonable in light o' the idiotic choices the developers made for some o' the jnpc powhaz. HA! Good Fun!

the conrad thing were a bit puzzling as am certain that we were nice to him. shalia (sp?) the asari we spared on theros is met on ilium giana parasini gives us a little peck on cheek in me2 saw fist in afterlife bar meet reporter (al-jilani(sp?)) and take her down a peg for a second time. save the council and made anderson a council member... kinda regretted saving the council in retrospect. ashley were still dead in me2... we were pursuing a romance with her and then let her die. emails made up much o' me1 crossover content, but we only recall a handful. got narali's body back for saresh (sp?) received email we didn't read. corporal toombs displeased that we is working with cerberus... email we partial read. etc. HA! Good Fun!

Wasn't talking about the vent mission. I was talking about a random death after the end boss. Non-loyal squaddies seem to have a chance of dying here, but I have no idea what triggers what person to die. All I know is that it's decided sometime before the actual boss fight because restarting the fight has no effect. Calax: Garrus, Miranda and Jacob are all suitable for the leadership position. And the shot is fatal if the person is not loyal or not leadership material. if you do same and mordin not survive... *shrug* HA! Good Fun!

am genuine baffled by the frequency with which others experienced mordin death. Gromnir never had mordin die and we played finale a couple o' times. never had mordin do the escort mission. the wacky thing is that our end-boss party were only the second time in the entire game we utilized miranda, grunt and Gromnir, and the reason we chose grunt were due to a misconception. based on grunt health numbers and regen, we figured that he would last longer than any other possible teammate... and he also had the squad variety o' inferno ammo. after we finished game we heard all sorta complaints 'bout grunt and his seeming suicide tactics. we brought miranda along because she had access to max warp and her cerberus leader power. ... was not our most effective party. in any event, am not certain what it is that triggers mordin death. he were loyal, but we didn't always agree with him in conversations... typcialy we criticized his involvement with genophage. we didn't have maxed tech damage upgrades, but we did have maxed smg. had 7 medi-gel 'stead of 8... and am pretty sure we were 4/5 for damage reduction. we did have all ship upgrades... including a useless 50k platinum expenditure for the medical bay improvement. *shrug* HA! Good Fun!

redcliffe is no problem at level 7-8... if you is playing a mage. morrigan maybe not even have access to heal at that point, and she clear don't have fireball. is yet another bit o' evidence regarding the disparity in power between classes. btw, for boo... with few exceptions enemies prioritize targets based on armour strength. the community were informed that this enemy ai quirk were done intentional, in part to keeps player & player party mages from being made dead too frequent. if enemies used tactics similar to the tactics you utilize to combat enemy spellcasters, morrigan and wynne would be wormfodder with alarming regularity. you will get attacked once you do damage to enemies, but you are relative free to position self on the battlefield unmolested... which is a major tactical advantage. HA! Good Fun!

never spent much time in the brothel, but some o' your observations are oft repeated. seeming overpower o' mages? check ability to cast are effect spells on passive/stationary foes 'round corners and beyond closed doors? check. as for stonefist + petrify... dunno. at least on higher levels of difficulty, petrify would seem to work marginal more frequent than cone of cold to freeze enemies. am pretty sure that stonefist counts as an auto critical, so you does get a nice deathblow attack v. most mob-level enemies. nevertheless, there is many ways to generate an auto crit that will shatter a frozen or petrified foe. also, earthquake is a relative dog spell... not much use 'less you stack it with some other area effect spell. denerim is clearly no athlaka... but da would be a ridiculous immense game if it were. is still more than enough to keeps you occupied on the remaining world map. morrigan and allistar offer you curious advice relative early in game. go to redcliffe first? pike off allistar. confront flemmeth? perhaps at level 15 or maybe even 20, but not at level 9 or 10. is almost as if your party mates is trying to get you killed. most of us has learned that there is little subtlety in crpgs... seeming spoon-feed you important info through dialogues is no accident. da turns conventions upside down... teaches the player that following joinable npc advice is not always the best course of action. HA! Good Fun!

Wow, I hope I haven't actually said that because... lol? I designed the "original" (BioWare/BIS/IPLY) NWN website in late 1999/early 2000, but I'm not sure for how long it had already been in development. alpha protocol coulda' been in development for a decade and Gromnir wouldn't be aware of that fact... and lord knows how we woulda' seen comments regarding as we ain't never even viewed the ap portion o' the obsidian boards. is the only original obsidian game we could think of that is current in development... am imagining it has been in development longer than 1.5 years, but as that seems to be the number du jour... *shrug* thanks for feedback regarding the ip boards and nwn. HA! Good Fun!

"Get out of the human mindset. Krogans are *aliens* for a reason, and that's a good thing. " there are no genuine alien characters in mass effect or mass effect 2-- and that ain't a criticism. makes genuine alien and you remove possibility of simple empathy and understanding. for a story-driven game to work it is necessary for krogan and even geth to be human. sure, they is savage tribals who were forcibly evolved and then smacked down hard via a disease that attacked their native fecundity, but there is nothing alien 'bout krogan emotions and characters... they is human, regardless of how they looks. some silicon-based puddle of goo from tralfax iv could be making for an intriguing alien, but unless it gots recognizable human emotions and motivations it would never be suitable as a crpg character. HA! Good Fun!

vol is correct. clearly bioware then and now is different beasts... but are you telling us that you agree with the notion that nwn were only in development for 2 years... or that da were the only bio game to get the +3 year treatment? 'course not. a biowarian shoulds know better, and if he gets info wrong he should simply man-up and admit... equivocation looks bad. *shrug* again, as alan is a biowarian, people will conscious and unconscious defer to alan expertise on those things bioware related. as such, alan shoulds be more careful with his opinions, 'cause whether he likes it or not his opinions reflect on bioware and not just alan. don't state opinions in such a way that they seems like facts. if josh tells us that alpha protocol were in development for less than 1.5 years we tends to believes... we believes 'cause we know he worked on alpha protocol, but also 'cause we expect that an obsidian would know more 'bout such stuff than the average boardie. is natural to defer to expert opinions. alpha protocol will be super-groovy-keen=opinion alpha protocol will offer no less than 20 hours of gameplay= fact if majek or Di thinks ap sucks it is unlikely that they will chastise josh for stating that ap will be super-groovy-keen. however, if gameplay is a mere 5 hours do you thinks majek will be pleased? is just one reason josh never shares gameplay estimates no more. is no biggie, but alan gots it wrong. should be more careful... and should equivocate less when he is wrong. josh is actual a good role model for such stuff. he hates to be wrong, but when he is wrong he admits... he also does a fair job of educating self. HA! Good Fun!

indeed. knowledge o' trivia is hardly a prereq for hiring... though Gromnir does recommend that people attempting to get hired should know the history o' their potential future employer-- you would be surprised by how easily impressed interviewers is by prospects who has done their homework regarding their potential future employer. in any event, Gromnir don't know your job qualifications... am simply pointing out that the 3-4 (plus) games bio has made clear ain't limited to da. as you is a known bio employee, and sometimes shill, people may mistakenly thinks you have some special knowledge or expertise regarding bio games of the past. sorry, but as an employee you is gonna be held to a higher standard, so when you get wrong you should try to accept with dignity and humility. 2 year would seems typical, with significant more or less being rarities. HA! Good Fun!

It'd be more of a mistake than me being dishonest. I intentionally prefaced my statement with "that I can think of." I don't know how long NWN was in development because I didn't really start following BioWare as a company until after I played Baldur's Gate and Baldur's Gate 2 in 2000. However, since NWN came out in 2002, that would mean that a 5 year development cycle had them starting the game a full year before the original Baldur's Gate was released. Is this the case? I specifically mentioned Dragon Age. And I think 4 years is probably a conservative estimate. As for SWTOR, I don't know how long that game has been in development. It was officially announced in 2008 IIRC, but I would expect that some time has already been spent on the game. maybe they should needs have biowarians pass a quiz before gaining employment. that frumpy guy you meets on the road to nashkel mines, the one that speaks o' neverwinter... no accident. and the "books" that showed up on the interplay website to reveal future d&d games had totsc, bg2 and nwn all pretty much shows up at the same time... we were then informed that nwn had already been in some development for some time. between 4 and 5 years... much closer to 5 than to 2. as for boo's dog... wouldn't Minsc have been a more appropriate name? HA! Good Fun!

IIRC, the blood rage thing is "promoted" to survive in the post-nuclear environment and had nothing to do with the salarians. Which is pretty stupid by itself and another excellent example of what I'm saying, as it's not uber macho bull**** that can rebuild a society but initiative, intelligence and, yeah, you guessed it: production. Looks like somebody in the writing team isn't familiar with the concept of diminishing returns. I wasn't saying that the Salarians had anything to do with the Blood Rage itself. Just that before the Krogans were uplifted, before they had the technology to destroy themselves, the Krogans actually viewed the Blood Rage as a bad thing. It was only after the whole given advanced tech, blow themselves up, and the Blood Rage becoming a near universal thing to the Krogans that they stopped viewing it as a bad thing. And frankly, the Krogans as is, come off like the psycho gangs in any apocalypse movie.. because they haven't rebuilt anything. They've reverted to the tribal clan structures. They don't really have their own spaceships, they don't seem to have much in the way of production at the moment. If it wasn't for other people turning up to hire them as mercs you wouldn't really see them off-world. Heck, Wrex is the one that's actually trying to rebuild the Krogan's as a "unified" society. He is showing initiative, and attempting to use intelligence and increase the production of the species. But he's mostly the exception to the Krogan rule. bold quote is the reason we find wrex superior to grunt. when grunt gets flushed from tank he is having infinite possibilities for development... he doesn't accept his conditioning. 'course, in virtual no time at all, the me2 writers is having grunt act likes stereotype krogan, which ain't such a bad thing, but seemed somewhat anti-climactic. also, is kinda strange that grunt were one o' the more stable and undamaged o' your crew mates. sure, he gotta go through some rite o' passage ritual 'fore he can gets his rage stabilized, but compared to the rest o' the crew and their family traumas, grunt is a poster child for mental health. am hopeful that me3 sees grunt gets better development... 'cause we were slight disappointed with me2 grunt. HA! Good Fun!

Kind of like the amount of time from Baldur's Gate to Baldur's Gate 2. Few of BioWare's games have "3-4 years of development time." In fact, the only one I can really think of that took that long is probably Dragon Age. ok, keep in mind that 1.5 does not shock Gromnir, but for a guy working with/at bio to make such a statement is... perplexing. nwn required approx 5 years, and da made 4 years disappear, no? star wars: the old republic is a mmorpg, but that game has seemingly been in development forEvar. can quibble and say that nwn took More than 3-4 years and that star wars ain't been released yet, so... still seems dishonest. gap between mass effect 1 and 2 were slight in excess of 2 years... though if some folks not look at actual dates of release, it might seem like 3 (late 2007 release for me1 and january 2010 release for me2.) virtual all other bio games we can recall seemingly gots the 2-ish year time period of development: jade empire, kotor, mass effect. *shrug* if da2 and me3 is released in first half of 2011 we will not be shocked, but we can understand why some folks will be surprised. HA! Good Fun!

Bioware makes that up with numbers. They're now not a game studio anymore, they're an EA facility. Hating on Bio because they consistently produce quality RPGs (unlike most RPG studios) consistently on time (unlike most RPG studios)? Come on Morgoth, you can do better than that. Unless you'd much rather that they produce buggy rpgs and/or titles are delayed beyond their official release date (Hello Obsidian?). Bio > Black Isle > Obsidian (so far) > Troika Sorry, but from DA to DA2 (or whatever it will be called), there's only like 1,5 years of dev time. This reeks. Bioware has a tradition to take about 3-4 years per game. So either they have the numbers to compensate that, or they're pressured from "above" to churn out sequels so fast. How big is Bio these days anyway? Someone has numbers about the Edmonton, Montreal and Austin studios? another option other than vast numbers of available man-hours or ea pressure: the biowarians were working on sequel simultaneous to working on da. peter jackson were considered alternatively delusional and visionary as he filmed all three lotr films simultaneous... assuming success rather than waiting for returns from fellowship of the ring. is any reason why bio couldn't do same thing with dragon age? who is to say that the biowarians ain't been working on the da sequel for a couple of years already? such an approach requires considerable planning, and it does mean that the biowarians is somewhat locked into doing da sequel according to their Big Picture plan... feedback from da will not be able to be much incorporated into game development beyond mechanics changes as sequel may already be very deep into development. *shrug* is pure conjecture on Gromnir's part, but we can see how a sequel might take only 1.5 years. also, as a point of reference, keep in mind that bg2 were released in september o' 2000. bg1 were released in late 1998, and bio released an expansion in-between bg1 and bg2. HA! Good Fun!

"Not sure who's holding the gun to people's heads and forcing them to gather all the stuff in advance." answer: bioware you may not have noticed, but there is at least one mission that compels immediate attention... without any warning. lost our fish that way. in any event, if you not know when you is gonna be forced into completing some quest or side-quest it makes perfect sense to prepare for the possibility that, without adequate warning, you may find yourself unable to go on a platinum or iridium run. also, given the fact that fuel costs credits, it is also reasonable to probe planets the first time you is in system, rather than making a costly return trip at some later time. resource acquisition in me2 is a mindless and repetitive endeavor that requires no skill. horrible resource acquisition is made worse 'cause the developers not give the player any clues regarding what quantity o' resources is appropriate AND they adds a cost factor into fuel and probes, without no context to make an educated decision regarding optimum or reasonable expenditure for probes and fuel. is as if the biowarians were contemplating some sorta strategic resource management mini-game, but then they simply stopped 1/3 into development. is clearly the most pointless feature we can recall in a bioware game, and is arguably the most asinine. as for vol's idiotic observation about the lack of fury over the dialogue wheel... maybe vol didn't notice, but as dialogue wheel is old news, few is the people trying to sell the notion that the dialogue wheel is innovative or a monumental rpg advance. HA! Gromnir got banned from bio 'cause we criticized the dialogue wheel. every dialogue wheel thread on the me1 boards were locked. chris priestly rationale for locking: the potential for spoilers. HA! dialogue wheel is a resource saving device for developers to be getting multiple uses out of a single vo recording... nothing more. Gromnir were more than a little surprised by the sheer number o' folks who fell for bio's line o' crap regarding dialogue wheel innovation, but... etc. *shrug* is old news and nobody cares no more. folks who ain't yet figured out that dialogue wheel is little more than a bit o' biowarian sleight o' hand ain't never gonna realize. we could be likes karzak and scream 'bout dual-wielding thieves and curse bioware at every opportunity, but that would be a waste o' our effort. dialogue wheel was part of me1 and me2... and it will be part o' me3. sure, whenever we hears claims o' dialogue wheel "innovation" or "brilliance" we respond with no little venom and mockery, but there ain't been many such comments in some time. after all, mass effect were a 2007 game... would be pretty tough for bioware to sell the dialogue wheel "innovation" a second time +2 years after the fact. hell, even vol would be unlikely to buy that kinda nonsense. HA! Good Fun!

I haven't heard of him dying in either of those situations. It's when he isn't chosen for anything that he tends to die and it doesn't seem to be tied to upgrades or anything. Time spent killing the final boss doesn't seem to have any effect. Bumped it down to casual and took him out with 5 shots from the widow. Mordin still died. the final time we played end sequence, our final boss battle party were as follows: miranda, grunt, Gromnir. we had jacob lead the normandy survivors back to ship. all team members were loyal. all ship upgrades were complete. no casualties. HA! Good Fun!

we had that problem with jack. her shockwave were very effective, but unless we babysat her through battles by choosing her cover position, she rarely survived beyond the time it typical takes to heat up a cup o' coffee. mordin, on the other hand, were far more durable, but we has heard deraldin's complaint from others. mordin also appears to be one o' the characters that dies easily during the end-game battle, regardless o' loyalty or upgrades. *shrug* between neural shock and incinerate, mordin were a very effective party-mate for Gromnir, but as we played an infiltrator with heavy incinerate, mordin were kinda redundant for most missions, save for when we faced many krogan... or harbingers. mordin and Gromnir letting loose with incinerate at same time were enough to instant vaporize the armour o' any foe... 'cept for praetorians, scions, and end-boss. btw, has anybody checked to see what impact cryo bomb has on biotic barriers? we confirmed , at least on the xbox, that cryo ammo shreds biotic barriers (even though documentation does not identify this fact). as our xbox recent went belly-up, we did not get a chance to see what impact cryo-bomb has on biotic barriers. if cryo-bomb does to biotics what incinerate does to armour, then mordin becomes even more effective... in addition to being a well-written and amusing character. HA! Good Fun!

yeah... without benefit o' meta-knowledge/hindsight, the player gots little notion as to how much resources will eventually be needed, so is making sense to let loose rapine and plunder 'pon unsuspecting planets 'cross the galaxy-- eventual end up with excess resources and surfeit credits. the whole economics and resource acquisition scheme is flawed. is no genuine strategy or intelligence involved. is no skill related to resource acquisition. so far, the best argument we has heard for planet harvesting in me2 is that it gives the player a break from frenzied gaming-- creates a relaxing interlude. ... what? turn off xbox or pc if you wants a break from gaming. maybe talk with some of your party mates or shoot monkeys on the krogan planet. dunno, but if all the resource acquisition accomplishes is to give the player a "break" from the game, then something is serious wrong. HA! Good Fun!