Their dense concentration in one place is what's jarring. It's a very tired argument in all recent BW games - why are there so many bi & gay people in your party? You can try arguing that it's a fantasy game, but actually it's not normal for any fantasy world, just for player party, it seems . Because recent BW games resemble pandering date sims wrapped in fantasy settings more than anything else. Too bad POE2 went the same way and it's not because of lack of money, it's because they chose to:
https://jesawyer.tumblr.com/post/173771124776/before-deadfires-release-you-said-that-every
The party that's filled with 2 godlikes (these are supposed to be rare), freed slaves, a priestess that captures souls in her lantern? Like you do realize your PCs party is made of exceptions to the rule right? So all these rare people on the boat is fine...til they're sexualities aren't straight. *Then* its an issue? Also judging from the brothels it doesn't look like there's any stigmatizing of sexuality so why wouldn't people be more open about it in the Deadfire?
Godlikes, priestesses and all the other unique stuff of that world doesn't bother me as much because it is truly fantastical, without any parallels in the real world, so it is easy to suspend my disbelief about that. Everybody being LGBT around meis not, because in the real world it is not and I can't help by make parallels when I play. That's why it breaks the suspension of disbelief.
Also, brothel is a poor example because it's a brothel - a place where people satiate any kinds of sexual desires for money. It doesn't mean hosts there are LGBT, it's just their job.
But whatever, as I've said before, it's a very tired argument with no resolution. If you're ok with all that then good for you, I'm certainly not gonna judge your preferences.
I hate to break it to you honey, but in real life most LGBT ppl do hang out with other LGBT people. Most of my social circle, for instance, is not straight. I'm sorry that you think 4 bisexuals in a group is more unbelievable than dragons or fireballs. That sounds more like a you problem then an issue with the game.
As for "pandering" I gotta roll my eyes. The same ppl who cry about everyone being bi are the same people who didnt care that BG2 was pandering to straight dudes when they had 3 options for males and 1 option for women (and no options for gays). When was the outrage then?
I'm glad Obsidian decided to make everyone bi. To me it always makes sense, cuz then it gives the PLAYER more options.