So the world is simple. It's trolls vs fanboys. How cool.
I did not back the game, I played BG in 98, and replayed BG, BG2, IWD IWD2 last year, and to me, PoE is so far (about 30 hours and 2 parties) the best of the series. The game asks for some implements, right, we agree, but is already fekin good. Seriously, I'm a big fan of BG and D&D in general (I played D&D and pen and paper RPG for 25 years) and I find PoE amazingly good. Am I a fanboy? an idiot?
Most of the critics I read are like compliment to me :
- "It sucks, we can't buff before combat !" : I say, that's great
- "it sucks, we can't rest for 8 hours every ten minutes !": I say, that's great
- "it sucks, paladins are not like D&D archetype !" : same
- "it sucks, it's different and I can't apply my old BG routines !"
etc, etc, etc.
I like how the combat works, I like all the tactical decisions you have to make to survive one or two dungeon level before rest etc. Great fun, pretty immersive.
I understand that some can dislike the game and his changes, but I barely understand the critics like "your system sucks", "it's broken", "it's idiot", etc. It's not