Unbiased Poll on Player Crafted Parties

[Shevek]

Another poll thread exists on this topic but I feel the poll is flawed. It is essentially a push poll that uses very biased languange and a sort of false choice to achieve certain results. In other words, it suggests it is a sort of either or phenomena. It suggests that we get either custom party members OR pre-fab NPCs. That would not be the case. If posting this second poll is against board rules, I will understand if a mod wants to close the thread. I just honestly felt the other thread did not present this question well.

 

I went ahead an used the wording Nub used in another post on these forums. He phrased the question eloquently and I hope he does not mind if I used his wording in this poll.

Edited September 22, 2012 by Shevek

[Monte Carlo]

Yes absolutely. It should be easy to implement and if you don't like the feature you can ignore it.

 

Was an awesome feature of IWD / BG

[Merin]

I voted - but there are other threads on this subject -

 

 

http://forums.obsidian.net/topic/60531-should-there-be-player-generatable-companions/

 

http://forums.obsidian.net/topic/60149-1-pc-plus-companions-or-create-multiple-characters-plus-companions/?do=findComment&comment=1189259

 

- and I sense a merging happening.

[ogrezilla]

Could it be an option that is unlocked after completing the game once?

[Jozape]

Could it be an option that is unlocked after completing the game once?

 

Yes, but why? That would only be keeping people from playing the game they want the first time.

[Jaesun]

How many of these threads to we need?

 

Anyways again, voting NO because the game was specifically designed with the already existing companions to be a part of the story.

[ogrezilla]

Could it be an option that is unlocked after completing the game once?

 

Yes, but why? That would only be keeping people from playing the game they want the first time.

Because if the story strongly includes the companions, keeping them out of the party could cause you to miss quite a bit couldn't it? I guess my thoughts on this are assuming that's the case: that companions will be an almost necessary component of the story.

[Tale]

I don't think it's really a good idea to end up with dueling polls because everyone thinks that their poll is better worded. The discussion is where the meat of insight is to be gained anyway.

 

The previous poll can be found here: http://forums.obsidian.net/topic/60531-should-there-be-player-generatable-companions/