I seen another forum tackle this topic and they were all siding with darth Vader but i can see a couple ways malak could emerge victorious

 

any ideas?

Vader had class. Malak had ? Can't think of anything.

They would put there differences aside and start the 'Donate a VoiceBox' foundation. "

well i think vader has more capabilities in the force but malak appears to have very good lightsaber skills. But then again we really never saw Darth Vader try to kill some one with a saber because Vader was tryin to seduce Luke. Oh but the duel with Obi Wan but i don't count that obi was so old and feeble.

Edited October 28, 200520 yr by foxdez

well i think vader has more capabilities in the force but malak appears to have very good lightsaber skills. But then again we really never saw Darth Vader try to kill some one with a saber because Vader was tryin to seduce Luke. Oh but the duel with Obi Wan but i don't count that obi was so old and feeble.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

Um, first off Obi-Wan lost to Vader on purpose, he knew that the only way Luke would become a real Jedi would be to fight Vader. As for Vader 'seducing' Luke, that's just not the word I would have picked.

but thats not my point i meant that we never seen Vader in a heated battle like say the ones he had as anakin

but thats not my point i meant that we never seen Vader in a heated battle like say the ones he had as anakin

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

Malak would still probably win, considering he could still move with his armour on.

how about Vaders force he could probably chuck just as much stuff at malak as he did luke

Thought we were talking about lightsaber duels though?

whats a Star Wars battle without a little force

Thought we were talking about lightsaber duels though?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

well, we were only talking specifically about lightsaber duels because foxdez said this:

well i think vader has more capabilities in the force but malak appears to have very good lightsaber skills.

but the topic says vader or malak: who would win? so that includes any resource they have to battle with.

 

I think vader would throw a bag of pixie dust onto malak until malak involuntarily begins to be lifted off the ground. Then vader would go in for the kill with his lightsaber, but then realise that malak can control his flight, so malak chops up vader and the end.

This is a stupid topic to argue for two reasons.

 

1. Vader was a movie character and Malak was a video game character

2. Completely different time periods in the SW universe.

Vader had class. Malak had ? Can't think of anything.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

He had a metal jaw thingy

 

may come in handy

This is a stupid topic to argue for two reasons.

 

1. Vader was a movie character and Malak was a video game character

2. Completely different time periods in the SW universe.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

So what none of its real anyway

 

But if these were to duel I would have to give the edge to Malak, he still was considered one of the better lightsaber duelists and was still human , unlike vader who was largely mechanical.

 

And with force powers not sure maybe a tie? I only remember the force choke, and wasn't he unable to produce lighting since losing his arms, and Malak more of a duelist then a force user

I think Yoda would own Vandar :ph34r:

Edited October 28, 200520 yr by 25054267

I think Yoda would owned Vander

nobody correct him on the name. we all know what he meant.

Edited October 28, 200520 yr by Blank

Ya Yoda would have kicked Voggendaus's ass anytime

Ya Yoda would have kicked Voggendaus's ass anytime

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

nobody correct him on the name, we know what he meant...

I think Yoda would own Vandar

nobody correct him on the name. we all know what he meant.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Whoops,

 

Thats how I thought it was spelt "

I think Yoda would own Vandar

nobody correct him on the name. we all know what he meant.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Whoops,

 

Thats how I thought it was spelt "

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

well now you know. go forth and sin no more

Like inside his suit he's filled with nugat?

Like inside his suit he's filled with nugat?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

Something like that

 

Vader is teh rul3z L33t! He's from the original movies, his force power is great and he reminds me to my father.

 

Malak is bold, annoying and... well... he's cool too. He also has good 'evil' style.

 

Still! Vader would defeat Malak by far!

Vader is the chosen one. He can't be beat by a wuss like Malak.

As Revan VS. xxx polls are locked, these are made?

 

Anyway, the high amount of spam inside makes it lockdown worthy