I like it except for two things:
-boarding is always better since it gives you more loot
-so many enemy ships, even high level ones with 4 star captains, are missing guns and crew.
I fought this one named pirate (not principi) that had a big ship (80+ hull) and dropped a lot of amazing loot, but only had 2 cannons out of 3 on one side of the ship and only 1 cannon on the other side. He was also missing 5-6 crew members so I was able to take him down easily with The Defiant starting ship. Shouldn't be possible tbh