I'm absolutely loving and enjoying this game.
This is the first isometric, "old-style" RPG I have really played, so I can't claim to be any sort of serious veteran (I'm very casual and periodic in my gaming). But I've played RPGs for several years now, Morrowind and Kotor were the first ones. Dragon Age:Origins has been my favourite one for some time now - the sequels were a huge letdown. I forced myself to play through DA2 once, Inquisition I was unable to even finnish. I also tried Divinity: Original Sin but there was something that made it very difficult to get into, so I quit and thought isometric games just weren't my "thing".
Pillars of Eternity has totally changed my opinion though. Not once have I missed flashy graphics or full voice-overs. I don't get over-whelmed, the learning curve has been very smooth. I'm playing on hard right now and the challenge seems just right. The story felt rich and intriguing right from the beginning. It's true that the companions aren't as "showy" as they have been in BioWare RPGs. Someone could certainly think they are bland because of that, but to me they feel very real and pleasantly down-to-earth, like real people tend to be. The story might not be the most original, but then again, it compares just fine to every other RPG I have played before. Almost all stories in the world have been told, one way or the other. What matters to me is the atmosphere and immersion.
I don't really know why I wrote this post. This is just the opinion of a one almost middle-aged lady, who has learned to love RPGs relatively late in her life. Overall Pillars of Eternity just feels very right to me - like it has a soul. I know that's not very analytical or technical, but it's just the thing I have felt lacking in most games I have tried during these last couple of years. I was becoming very cynical and depressed about games overall, so playing this one has been like a breath of fresh air. Maybe I will even get the confidence to try Baldur's Gate series after this very positive experience.