Jump to content

Maedhros

Members
  • Posts

    299
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Posts posted by Maedhros

  1. On 12/14/2025 at 4:55 AM, Zoraptor said:

    Rings of Power S2. 5?

      Hide contents

     

     

    I agree with everything here. For me, hobbits have nothing to do in a show about the second age, and the whole mystery box plotline with the Wizard was just as needless. Another big weaknesses of the show is that they feel the need to ape after PJ's Lord of the Rings. From trying to invoke the same "feels", to borrowing Howard Shore for the intro theme, to literally buying the design of the Balrog and alike. I actually quite like some of the original designs they have, like Numenor, and their version of the Grey Havens.

  2. Super short reviews of three recent films, using the nationally famous https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Die_throw_(review)

    Sinners - Intriguing up until a certain point. There was potential there to be a great film, but for me the last part was rather generic and uninteresting. 4/6

    28 years later - Surprisingly good. There's tension there, and heart. It looks great and sounds great, with a good dose of weird too. I liked it. 5/6

    Fantastic Four - Competent and coherent, but uninspired? I was never bored, but also never surprised or feeling any excitement. Much better than the other F4 films of course, but it felt very "comittee made" and followed the moviemaking playbook. I liked the guy who played the Human torch. 3/6

     

  3.  

    The entire Palestinean team behind this documentary has now been killed, according to its (non-Palestinean) director:

    "The team we worked with in Gaza for @prayingforarmageddon have all been killed. All of them. Such young brilliant brave and talented filmmakers with dreams and high ambitions for the future. They were trapped, directly targeted and slaughtered by the Israeli bombs, and their office at Ain Media was leveled with the ground. They leave behind babies, toddlers, wifes and so many broken hearts."

    • Sad 1
  4. 11 hours ago, Zoraptor said:

    Of course, you don 't hear much about it, now, because it ain't Trump doing it, it's Biden.

    I think rather the war in Ukraine is the reason. Turkey is more important to NATO and the EU than ever.

    • Like 1
  5. On 10/15/2022 at 2:51 AM, Hurlshort said:

     

      Reveal hidden contents

    I never bought that grey robed guy was Sauron. 

    Elrond is a little jarring because Hugo Weaving sets a high bar.

    Elrond (and his friendship with Durin) is the best part about the show I think. They nailed the "kind as summer" Elrond from the books, unlike Hugo Weaving who is nothing like the character. People like his Elrond because they like Hugo Weaving...who's just being himself. He also looks just as much an elf as bloody Hugo Weaving with his receding hairline did.

    ---

    As for the show. The hate and unreasonable criticism it's getting is so over the top. I've read all of Tolkien' writings (including the obscure stuff) a gazillion times and the feel I'm getting is that these guys know Tolkien better than Peter Jackson did.

    While the showmakers take liberties at times, and invent stuff left and right they kind of have to as there are so many blank spots to fill in, in the second age. The dialogue for the most part is Tolkienian (more so than PJ - "let's hunt some orc!"), and he even had so much dialogue to pick from the books.

    I'd rate it a decent 7/10, with the expectation that things will get even better now that they've sat things in motion. Big kudos to them that they manage so much with so little to go from, AND with big constraints put on them in terms of where these characters have to end up. I especially loved the dwarven stuff, and the orcs looked better than ever. The dialogue was at times beautiful, and some scenes were much better than they could be expected to be (like the intense back-and-forth with the two Durins).

    • Like 2
×
×
  • Create New...