Felt the same way with the PS2 comparison. Even just the normal maps set this generation's graphics miles apart from last generation's, not to mention shaders and higher poly models. Agh, i hate those uneducated disses.
The other day, actually, i showed one of those videos of Mike talking to deep throat Balaklava to a friend and his only comment was about how great the game looked, specially the facial animations. And i agree.
Ditto, I don't know how someone can say these graphics look like PS2. They don't look top notch but they don't look that bad either.
Gamespot has put up a score of 6.0 but no real review as of yet.
http://www.gamespot.com/ps3/rpg/alphaprotocol/index.html