Nur Ab Sal

No offense taken. I don't want Aurora Team to rush things at all. This topic is just for fun.

You know, some people like to use their heads for other things than wearing a hat. And no, I'm not referring to banging it against the wall like you do. <{POST_SNAPBACK}> That's quite empty answer considering that your speculations lead to nowhere becouse of lack of arguments

Really? Here's the excerpt from the novel, right at the point when Palps was firing lightning at Mace and had him in trouble. Pg. 334 of the hardcover Revenge of the Sith novelization: If you will notice, Palpatine was on the brink of destroying Mace, but with Mace pleading with Anakin for help, Palpatine figured Anakin might side with Mace so he goes DIRECTLY from dominating Mace to the point Mace says "Anakin, he's too strong for me...", to becoming that feeble old man. So Nurb, I'd say the novelization does make it quite obvious that Palpatine "gave up" in his fight because he didn't want to risk having Anakin side with Mace at that moment. That excerpt, atleast, definitely points to it. <{POST_SNAPBACK}> Actually it is a stalemate. Neither of them is able to take advantage at this moment. When Ani cut off Mace's hand and he loses lightsaber then Palps uses lighning to finish him (Windu was a swordsman and hadn't big experience with force absorption like yoda so without lightsaber he was defenseless)

Ekhm, are you talking to me?

Speculations, speculations, speculations.... that's all you have people.

Actually Visual Dictionary says that, but on other page it says his visage was deformed by Jedi. He wasn't stupid to give up and risk death. Besides movie and novelization never said or hinted anything about Palps faking duel. It's your imagination. Becouse there's no proof. All you have are your interpretations. Yoda withdrawed fro the duel but he wasn't beaten totally. Both opponents were exhausted. That was a stalemate. And Yoda was seen as wisest and oldest Jedi but no one said in the movie that Mace wasn't more powerful. Palpatine moves with the same speed all the time in the movie showdown. The distance between Mace and his henchmen was giant, so they died quickly. Mace was as fast and deadly as Palpatine (as we see on the movie and read in the novel) No I just defend actual way of things. There's no proofs for "faked duel" theory. These are only your suspicions/ interpretations/ dreams. You are ignorant becouse you have no facts to back your theory. In the movie Palps got spanked although he fought ferociously. Movie didn't show Palps intentionally dropping his weapon. All you are babbling is just your theory. But the problem is that theory is a hoax without any clear (or even visible) evidence.

Thank you master Flatus.

Yeah, yeah *yawn*. But the waiting is terribly painful.

No. I just say you don't have proofs for your ridiculuos theory. Using your way of thinking, we can speculate that Jews originated from Mars or that Atlantean Kings are secretly controlling US goverment. Movie and book don't support your theory, but of course you can believe in anything, your brain will produce.

I admire your blindness to obvious facts we can see in ROTS movie and read in novelization. There was no faking from Palps side and discussion is over.

George Lucas said many things that contradicts each other. The movie, the screenplay and the novelization, rule out "acting theory", state that Palps was fighting for real, and say that Anakin is the most powerful. What George said in some forgotten interview doesn't matter.

Who told you Yoda's most powerful? Anakin is the most powerful Jedi of that time. I also think Yoda is old and exhausted while Mace was in his height. Besides novelization stated clearly that Palps wasn't acting Do I really have to repeat that? You don't have any proof for "acting theory", live with it.

Hmm I see a powerful mental depression coming!

Is it possible to beg for some drawings of my beloved Taris?

Well, waiting is boring, so let's speculate!

You people just read official novelization. In official novelization Palps uses every power to beat Windu yet he fails. The duel is described in details and it is clear that Windu was superior. Also illustrated screenplay shows that there was no "play" from Palps side. HE LOST. You children only speculate. Movie shows how Palps got spanked and you just have no proofs. Same I could speculate that Palps attacked Luke in ROTJ cause he wanted to be killed by Vader "

Weak argument

Powerful? That was his last desperate effort. If he could kill Windu he would do that and later tell Anakin some new bulls...t He got spanked instead. Get used to it.

Mace already defeated Sidious. Sidious was left at mercy of Windu and Anakin and their disagreement caused his survival.

I was wondering which resolution is the best graphically... you can say your mind or whatever.

And let's hope that this is, what next developer will do. "Real Sith" sounds redundant and lame.

That's very true; but in essence the determination of good vs. evil depends on who writes the history books (i.e., the winner of the conflict). <{POST_SNAPBACK}> Yeah? Sonny, Stalin murdered millions and today commies try to cover that by saying that he was trying to fight social injustice. Revan tried to take over the galaxy, also murdered millions and now morons like you try to cover him, only becouse he was your PC and you feel powerful thanks to him.