Kotor 1's story was complete. The designers also purposely strived for recreating the magic of the original trilogy, and a cinematic feel.. that latter of which was only partly achieved.
Too many areas were butt ugly, and things could have been fleshed out more. That said, it really only needs a facelift, the artwork for certain things and certain areas and the interface from Kotor2 will do nicely. Then it will be one kickass game.
it is linear and simplistic but that is going along with the movie experience. The player does not have to think or try too hard, just let the story unfold. However, I noticed that many of the worlds, for instance Manaan, could have, with development, been self-contained games in and of themselves. Imagine a game entirely set upon Manaan with the same basic story, or better. Then, imagine such games for each of the planets, then tied all together into one big Kotor. That would rock. That would be truly epic. That would almost certainly be one godly game.
That said, the developers did a good job in developing the skeleton of the planets enough so that such fleshing out was not necessary for a passable enjoyable experience. They did a good job seizing upon the bare essentials.. unfortunately imo too bare, especially w/ regards to artwork for certain things.
The cinematic effect was pulled of quite nicely though, both in story elements and also in breathtaking vistas.
I had hoped not to write pages and pages of review.. I wouldn't even read it. But let's continue :D
Kotor 2 showed its Black Isle legacy pretty strongly. It also seems to draw upon System Shock 2. Can say Aliens, Star Control et al., Mission Critical too. It had great promise and there were several points especially relatively early in the game where I thought in ecstasy and with great joy 'I love this game.' Peragus had potential for an Aliens or System Shock 2 experience; was merely ok but that is ok as well since it is only the beginning. I liked the situations I found myself in, the broken ship, the mysterious station, Telos arrest, getting shot down, and there is good humor and excitement. I loved having my own new empty ship even moreso than Kotor 1. Nar Shadda was pretty cool and Onderon is badass, space battle, mysterious moon landing, and Onderon planetfall, although I would have preferred even more gigantic battles.
That said, I didn't think much of the characters, despite clever words, and the story is unfinished unfortunately. Dantooine and Korriban are rehashed. This game was well made and detailed, it had fun and awesomely cool parts, but it was not finished. Kotor 1 was not as detailed but it was finished