Sikon

Why killing? They can take Revan and Exile out of the picture by, erm, removing them from Republic space and leaving their fate unspecified (not that I would be fond of it, but it's an example showing that not everything is so obvious). Maybe the True Sith were introduced for precisely this purpose and will remain in the background for the time being. Who knows?..

If somebody truthfully tried, they could connect anything to anything. Kreia. Duh. Atris calls her that, even after saying that it's not her name. This is why I think she was figuratively speaking about the Sith identity.

I don't understand why. Honestly.

No, we don't. The only thing we know for sure is that the Republic, the Jedi, and a number of planets will survive it. Everything else can only be speculated.

Who do I like better, Palpatine or Darth Sidious? Neither. Who do I like better, Kreia or Darth Traya? Both.

But was Brianna Atris' spy to begin with? And why do you presume that Atris kills the Handmaidens? Why should she? By the way, good to see that there is a person who doesn't hate Disciple!

If they want to explore that time period in detail, and there are a lot of signs that they do, they can't just say that "historical details were lost". Because in contemporary materials, it isn't history, it's modern age. When saying "strict continuity", I didn't mean that the continuity is free from problems. There are inconsistencies, but if they didn't care about the continuity, they wouldn't retcon them at all. The retcons at least wrap it up and reduce the number of loose ends, and this is the right direction to take, even if they don't totally succeed in it. Inconsistencies here and there are inevitable due to the amount of existing material, but with the introduction of the Holocron, the problem was reduced. So, if you don't like the fact that the genders were canonized,

It's B-4D4, not B4-D4.

There are way better parts.

Why is everyone so obsessed with these romances?

There is no hierarchy. Evey discrepancy is solved individually, without regard for the form of media, and when possible, they try to preserve both stories.

Those who care about how it "really" happened. Including Wookieepedia. Just this very thread proves that many people care about it. ,...presuming K3 will have something to do with Revan or Exile at all, which isn't something you should take as granted... To have a single, consistent universe. Why not? Revan and/or Exile can appear in the KOTOR comics, although it's not very probable. And why the need for another story at all? Aren't there just the considerations of a strict continuity? Leland Chee said that the only reason they mess with these genders is to allow their authors to reference this characters at all - with correct pronouns. Well, I think I'm good at explaining why I don't like this theory, but I won't because it's irrelevant here.

Even better: Kreia never says anything about Brianna joining the Council, but does say so about Mical. Only in your dreams, Padawan.

I do know we're talking about C-canon.

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Star_Wars_canon

Don't dispute Lucasfilm's canon policy, mortal.Seriously, can we be done here? This ranting is so old, someone arbitrarily takes one form of media and declares that they are allegedly non-canon. "Comics are not canon", "video games are not canon", "essential guides are not canon". They all are, and the Holocron continuity database (and future authors) treat them all as equally valid.

There's no need for theories now, it has been officially stated who the "True Sith" are. They are descendants of the original Sith species.

Why "even"?

Everything counts, but every single discrepancy is resolved/retconned individually, if at all. In case of this one: the phrase "Dark Lord" may be interpreted as "former Dark Lord", while both the NEC says that Republic forces defeated Malak and destroyed the SF. http://www.starwars.com/databank/technology/starforge/ The NEC, in addition, explicitly mentions that it was Revan who, together with the Republic, destroyed it. In this case, LS clearly supercedes DS.

There are no parallel universes in Star Wars. There is a single continuity where all published works belong, and there are stories that are deemed non-canon/Infinities. The KOTOR games are no more or less canon than the rest of the EU.

Players can play whatever they want, but only one of the possible choices actually happened in "true" Star Wars.

On an unrelated note, it seems that they officially adopted the term "Jedi Exile". Which is good.

It yields funny dialogue.http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Quote:HK-47

That was sarcasm. But still, I don't think Disciple is one tenth as bad as he's portrayed.

No, Mical is one the best video games party members ever. (Opponent's argumentation preserved.)