Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

The problem is how you represent them to the player in a 3rd-person game. If you just put them on the player's avatar without changing the view the player sees on his/her monitor, they become little more than a fancy hat with a few stat bonuses for the dolly-dress-up element of the RPG. ("The Goggles, they do nothing!") If you tint the whole environment to make it 'realistic' when Thorton dons the goggles, you're undoing much of the work that your artists, et al., did to make the environments look good.

 

There's a reason that you don't see them much in the spy films that inspired AP-- the scene would have to be too dark to film in order for there to be much reason to use them. And in a visual medium like film (and games), I think it's better to compromise verisimilitude a tiny bit (by putting at least minimal lighting in your scenes) than it is to undermine the audience's visual experience by putting scenes in a green haze or in too-dark-to-see lighting.

Posted (edited)

That said, there are times when the demands of verisimilitude make ugly night-filters a better option. I hated the way the night vision spells/potions looked in Oblivion and The Witcher, but it is better to have that option than it is to make the player carry a light source or to put eternal torches in every troll cave.

 

With a game like AP, where the action is presumably all going to be taking place in environments inhabited by humans, it's easier to rationalize some lights being on. (I haven't played any of the modern roguelike/action games, so I really don't know whether or how they have included night vision.)

Edited by Enoch
Posted (edited)
I dont see how it hurts what the artists have done when you only use them in the dark when you cant see much anyway.

It's not so much the goggles that hurt in that instance-- it's that you've made the scene too dark to begin with. You want to give the player a visually interesting environment. If you turn all the lights out, everything looks the same (with or without night vision goggles). That's boring.

 

Plus, night vision goggles do nothing to mitigate the most serious risk of a pitch black video game environment.

Edited by Enoch

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...